Computing Has Trust Issues
With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles
Join us in this episode of The Security Table as we dive into the world of cybersecurity, starting with a nostalgic discussion about our favorite security-themed movies like 'Sneakers,' 'War Games,' and 'The Matrix.' We then shift gears to explore a critical topic in modern computing: the vulnerabilities and implementation issues of Secure Boot.
About this episode
Join us in this episode of The Security Table as we dive into the world of cybersecurity, starting with a nostalgic discussion about our favorite security-themed movies like 'Sneakers,' 'War Games,' and 'The Matrix.' We then shift gears to explore a critical topic in modern computing: the vulnerabilities and implementation issues of Secure Boot. Discover the intricate details of key management, human errors, and the challenges of maintaining trust in hardware and software systems. The conversation extends to the practicalities of password management, passkeys, and the broader implications of securing digital identities.
Follow AI Security Table:
➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/
➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable
➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/
➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable
Transcript · 46 min conversation
0:10Chris Romeo Crash and Burn, isn't that your hacker handle?
0:13Izar Tarandach Oh my God.
0:13Chris Romeo No, it's, it's, weren't you in a movie in the '80s or so where it was very futuristic?
0:23Izar Tarandach It wasn't futuristic.
0:24Chris Romeo Was it?
0:25Izar Tarandach It was like, uh, no, it was sort of undergroundy.
0:28Chris Romeo It was like, let's show you how the city underground actually works. All the things you don't know about. They were kind of cyberpunk-y, I think is what they were.
0:35Matt Coles Kind of cyberpunk-y, but really not.
0:36Izar Tarandach Kind of cyberpunk, yeah. More like cyber new wave, I think.
0:41Chris Romeo Cyber new wave.
0:42Izar Tarandach Yeah, there was all this neon and people in like bright, uh, lemon parachute cargo pants.
0:49Chris Romeo There were a lot of skateboards and stuff too.
0:52Matt Coles There were skateboards and rollerblades.
0:53Izar Tarandach Yep.
0:53Chris Romeo Yeah, 'cause that was kind of the, yeah, that was kind of the, yeah, 'cause you, you go to a bar and you're holding a drink and exactly what you need right now is people on skateboards flying by, right? And road plates.
1:04Izar Tarandach What could possibly go wrong with that? Oh my God, I'm getting old.
1:10Chris Romeo All right.
1:11Matt Coles Try to get old. We can talk about sneakers too.
1:13Chris Romeo So, uh, oh dude. Okay.
1:14Izar Tarandach All right.
1:14Chris Romeo Hold on. Hold on. Best security themed movie of all time.
1:20Matt Coles Sneakers.
1:20Chris Romeo You said sneakers. We've had hackers thrown on the table here. Uh, you could say The Matrix is in the category. Mm-hmm.
1:28Izar Tarandach Before The Matrix, there was Existence.
1:33Chris Romeo What's Existence?
1:34Izar Tarandach He touched, ah, you see, you haven't even seen that one. He touches with, in, uh, uh, immersive gaming, VR, and, uh, has a bit of Inception in it.
1:44Chris Romeo Okay.
1:45Izar Tarandach Has a really good, good, uh, cast.
1:48Matt Coles And was it based on a Neil Ste— was it based on a Neil Stevenson book by any chance?
1:52Izar Tarandach Don't think so.
1:53Chris Romeo Existence. Okay. We'll put that in the category. No. And it, and it's, it's written with a Z, so it's, that's why you wouldn't be able to find it. Yeah.
2:04Izar Tarandach And it had, uh, who was it in it, man? I haven't thought of this movie. It's from 1999.
2:11Matt Coles Okay. So just around the time of The Matrix was coming out. Yep. And, uh, which is why nobody heard of it because Matrix just, it had Jude Law in it.
2:21Izar Tarandach It had Jennifer Lason, Jason, whatever her name is, and William Dafoe.
2:27Chris Romeo Okay.
2:30Izar Tarandach That's a good, a good movie.
2:31Chris Romeo Yeah.
2:31Izar Tarandach Spent some, uh, let me see. How long is it?
2:35Matt Coles Doesn't say.
2:36Izar Tarandach 97 minutes.
2:37Chris Romeo There you go. Even better. Yeah. So. If you don't like it, you don't have to hang around for long.
2:43Izar Tarandach But if you don't like, you're welcome.
2:45Chris Romeo Okay. So Matt, your, your vote is Sneakers. Sneakers.
2:49Matt Coles Yeah.
2:49Chris Romeo Okay.
2:50Izar Tarandach I'll have to think about this one.
2:51Matt Coles It's a class. It's a classic. It's got everything you need. Uh, you know, drama, uh, intrigue, right?
2:59Chris Romeo But what a cast. What a cast in Sneakers. Redford, Aykroyd, Madam President.
3:08Matt Coles Yeah.
3:08Izar Tarandach Yeah.
3:09Matt Coles Ahead of his time.
3:10Izar Tarandach What, no, what's her name?
3:13Matt Coles What's her name?
3:15Izar Tarandach Meta President from Galactica. She plays in Sneakers. What's her name? Yeah, I don't, I'll never remember. But anyway, my problem with Sneakers is that it reaches out to the mode of, uh, the black box that decrypts everything.
3:30Matt Coles Oh geez, you mean like the Clipper chip?
3:33Chris Romeo Yeah.
3:33Izar Tarandach Yeah. Exactly. Like the Clipper Chip.
3:37Chris Romeo You know, life, uh, follows life.
3:39Matt Coles Life interrupts.
3:41Izar Tarandach No. Invasion, invasion.
3:43Chris Romeo Pop attack. All right.
3:48Matt Coles So you're going with existence.
3:50Chris Romeo You're going to say that's your best? No, no, no, no, no, no.
3:53Izar Tarandach I have to think about that one.
3:55Chris Romeo I have to think about that one. There's no time to think. This is a live show.
3:58Matt Coles James Earl Jones was in Sneakers. Come on. You can't get any better than that.
4:01Chris Romeo I thought it was James Bond.
4:02Izar Tarandach I'm certified.
4:03Chris Romeo Oh, WarGames. Come on, man.
4:04Izar Tarandach I got a WarGames poster right behind me.
4:06Chris Romeo That's kind of the OG, man. That is, that's, that is an OG security-themed movie. I mean, we all wanted to be the person with the high score on Galaga after WarGames.
4:18Izar Tarandach I actually wanted to be the guy with the modem in his bedroom, but, uh, that's not cool there.
4:22Chris Romeo You didn't have a modem in your bedroom?
4:24Izar Tarandach Uh, uh, no. It was my bedroom in Brazil. No, it took a while for me to have a modem in my hand.
4:32Matt Coles Yeah.
4:34Chris Romeo I had an office. I was a weird kid.
4:37Matt Coles Um, yes, you were.
4:39Izar Tarandach Unbelievable. All right.
4:42Matt Coles So as a kid, I grew up with a VT100.
4:44Izar Tarandach So, um, you know, I had a VT100 with a modem in my room later on.
4:50Matt Coles Green screen, green screen and clicky keyboard.
4:52Chris Romeo And you never had eye strain?
4:54Izar Tarandach I had a VT203 that had the orange screen.
4:59Chris Romeo Ooh.
4:59Izar Tarandach That was awesome.
5:01Chris Romeo Fancy. And, uh, if you have no idea what we're talking about, just, just go to Google, put in VT100, VT203, and you'll get a picture probably from the Smithsonian Computing Museum.
5:14Izar Tarandach Do better, download, uh, an emulator and use it as your shell. Yeah, as your terminal in whatever operating system you are in.
5:22Chris Romeo That sounds really good.
5:23Izar Tarandach Which should be, which should be a specific one.
5:26Chris Romeo One that's attached to a penguin. Okay.
5:30Izar Tarandach So what we talking about today?
5:31Chris Romeo Today we're gonna talk about your trust issues. We're gonna have a—
5:37Matt Coles gotta go.
5:38Izar Tarandach Yeah. I don't know if I can talk about that with you guys.
5:44Chris Romeo We're gonna unpack. These trust issues that, uh, now we're going to focus on trust issues. Recent trust issues in computing is the working title of this. And so, Matt, why don't you tee up the first one? You were telling us about something with Secure Boot.
6:03Matt Coles Oh my. Yeah. So Secure Boot, uh, is, uh, as it turns out, not so secure. Well, at least some implementations of it. So, uh, for those who aren't familiar, of course, Secure Boot is the means by which you can boot a system, operating system and its firmware in a trusted way so that you can trust it to know that it's not been compromised, that it's what you intended to install. Uh, and of course then it can verify the kernel and then potentially other things as well, if it, if it so chooses, or if the system is configured. The problem is, uh, so Secure Boot runs on, uh, a key, a key pair system, right? So there's a, there's a key, uh, often there's a, a key that encrypts a key, uh, and so you can do fast verification of, of modules. And then, but there's a, there's a key that gets baked into the hardware, uh, and the, the, um, the oper— the, the system, the things that are gonna be trusted get, get of course digitally signed by that key. Or by the public, you know, the private key. And so, um, there's a set of key pairs that exist and, uh, to make development possible, of course, you have to have development keys. Now, remember, these keys are baked into hardware, so sometimes they'll bake in test keys. And that seems to be what happened here is that there's a, a small set of keys that are being used as either test keys that aren't removed or aren't properly, uh, uh, taken care of in, in the, the system, or they're, they're used as the keys and, and therefore they're, they're well known. And so that's, that allows for compromise of Secure Boot because now your trust has been broken and it's all, it's, it's, uh, untrusted turtles all the way up.
8:01Chris Romeo Are these changeable? Are these keys, can you replace them?
8:06Matt Coles Not often. Okay. They're burned, they're burned in. Yeah, they're burned into EEPROM or they're, they're baked into a, if you have a TPM, in theory, the TPM is, is, um, rewritable or not. You can erase and then, and then reburn or re, um, reallocate keys. Uh, is our, you okay with it?
8:29Chris Romeo We can't hear you.
8:33Matt Coles He doesn't know that we can hear him.
8:36Chris Romeo We still can't hear you.
8:37Matt Coles His audio, his audio doesn't trust us anymore.
8:40Chris Romeo He can't hear us. We can't hear you. No, we cannot hear you.
8:45Matt Coles We can see you and we know what you just said.
8:47Chris Romeo It's fine. We could try to translate. So, Isar said, trusted boot. Is the best thing of all time. And he's a giant fan and he thinks no key should be replaceable anywhere.
9:05Matt Coles Yeah. So, so devices that don't have a TPM, Secure Boot will work often by burning a key into, into EEPROM. Um, it's called a one-time programmable key. And then, uh, those keys are used to do things. Well, that information that's burned into EEPROM is often used to think, to do things like burn in the fingerprint of a certificate that is used, uh, so that you can trust the certificate because you don't have a full PKI system implementation at that point. Uh, otherwise you're using a TPM or using another trusted, you know, secure element that the hardware supplies as your, as your root, literally the root of trust. You have a hardware root of trust and then everything else is software from there or firmware.
9:49Chris Romeo Yeah.
9:50Izar Tarandach Can you hear me now?
9:51Matt Coles Yes.
9:52Chris Romeo Yes. Yes.
9:54Izar Tarandach So yeah, no, but what I was, what I was going to ask is, uh, since I don't use a secure boot for obvious reasons, um, the TPM itself, it's part of the motherboard, right? It's not something that you can pop and put anyone in.
10:08Matt Coles It's supposed to be, it's supposed to be, it's supposed to be tamper resistant at the very least, tamper proof ideally, although this is now we're talking FIPS territory. So, yep. For those who are unfamiliar, FIPS 140-2 originally, and I think -3 now, uh, they have different levels. There's, there's, uh, sort of, there's, uh, tamper, uh, tamper evidence, uh, meaning if it's, um, if it gets tampered with, you, you know it. It's tamper resistant, meaning it's hard to tamper with. And then tamper proof, uh, is of course, um, It cannot, cannot be tampered with, tampered with without destroying its function. Uh, so you'll see devices, you know, that have kill, kill switches or circuitry, special circuitry to, you know, if it, if you crack the case, you break the circuitry and then everything stops working. Right.
10:59Chris Romeo So that's tamper, tamper-proofing. Most TPMs don't have that level.
11:04Matt Coles No. Uh, HSMs, yes. HSMs usually have tamper, tamper resistance, certainly, and tamper-proof.
11:10Chris Romeo HSM are hardware security modules for those people.
11:13Matt Coles TPMs are. Trusted platform modules.
11:17Chris Romeo Yeah.
11:17Matt Coles And, uh, right. So they'll, they'll often have, they, if they're assuming they're not implemented in soft, in soft.
11:28Izar Tarandach There is that word again, trust.
11:30Matt Coles Don't, don't implement them in software because things will happen.
11:34Chris Romeo Well, software is mod— you can modify it. Um, that's, you could, you could. Modify the software that is supposed to be interpreting the keys and the certificates to always return 1 when you call isTrusted? Whereas in hardware, you were supposed to be able to burn things in so that it couldn't be modified. But that does provide the downside that you've already highlighted, Matt, that you can't update it, you can't change it. So. So basically the root of this is, you could almost say the root of, no, not the root of trust.
12:13Matt Coles It's the root of, it's, it's literally the root of trust was the wrong thing to trust.
12:17Chris Romeo So in some of these situations they used, did they, they left, sounds like they left a test key behind and, but, but in other, in other situations it sounded like you were saying they only left the test key, like they didn't have a production key.
12:32Matt Coles They used, yeah, they used, potentially used the, the test key as trusted key.
12:38Chris Romeo Yeah. So this human error, is that the, the, what, what's the ultimate cause of this?
12:44Matt Coles Uh, ultimately it has to be, I would imagine. Um, I, I don't know all the details specifically in, obviously we can't know all the details in all of the cases, but most likely this is a garbage in, garbage out problem, right? Somebody either didn't understand what they were doing when they were configuring Secure Boot. They had a script that was left in and, and, you know, because of, they may do automation for, for, um, you know, manu— secure manufacturing or for, um, uh, building these systems depending on, on, you know, how they're being provisioned. Uh, and, and so it just may not have been updated. Um, they put the wrong key in the wrong place. There's a host of reasons why that could occur. Um, but most likely it's human error.
13:28Izar Tarandach What else can't we trust this week?
13:32Matt Coles Well, apparently your passwords.
13:34Chris Romeo Oh, Google. Yeah. No, no. I know all of these are passwords. They're super trustworthy.
13:40Izar Tarandach Password 123, right?
13:42Chris Romeo I thought you added a 4 on the end.
13:45Izar Tarandach Oh yeah. Yeah. Because the, uh, the requirements got better now.
13:47Chris Romeo Yeah.
13:48Matt Coles But it's not 4 exclamation mark.
13:50Izar Tarandach It's, it's written 4. F-O-U-R. Yeah.
13:54Matt Coles With a, you have to put a space. You have to put a space cuz I was saying something special.
13:57Chris Romeo That's why I couldn't log into your, and now I'm totally secure.
14:00Izar Tarandach But no, on the, on the, on the password side of things is, uh, we keep telling people to use password managers and I still think that that's the way to go. But, uh, Google in its, uh, infinite wisdom put a password manager inside of Chrome and then they went and they broke it for a number of people with, uh, with With an update. So apparently the update was rolled in waves. 25% of Windows Chrome users already got it. And for 2% of those people, something got screwed up and their passwords disappeared. Now remember that the point of using a password manager is that you have the password manager generate the passwords and they are hopefully complex enough that it's very difficult to guess them. And that means that most people do not have a black, uh, notebook with copies of their password. So yeah, there's been a lot of, uh, forgot my password clicked on this week, I guess.
14:59Matt Coles Yeah. This, this, we know that I, there are some sites where I only use forgot a password, forgot password, and why bother like saving one? So. If you always generate a password, as long as you have a trust, as long as the company is implementing a secure way of doing password recovery or resetting a password, that seems like not a bad idea, right? You basically get a one-time, one-time credential if you're not, if it's not being protected otherwise.
15:31Izar Tarandach Yeah, but then actually you're what, you're farming, you're farming that security to the password of your email.
15:39Matt Coles Well, it depends on if it's just email. Hopefully it's not SMS. I don't do that with SMS systems. That would be bad.
15:44Chris Romeo Oh yeah, totally.
15:45Izar Tarandach But even if you do it with, with, um, with, uh, uh, email, then you're basically just transferring the trust to the password that you have in your email. And we know that many of us keep their email open all the time. And perhaps, I don't know, if you made a text, your phone doesn't have a good, uh, lock or whatever. So it's not that we are getting more security by using the forget password, forgot password all the time. It's just that we are moving the peg one slot to the side, right?
16:17Chris Romeo Yeah.
16:18Matt Coles Who leaves their email open all the time? What are you, nuts?
16:21Chris Romeo Who are you? Hey, he's always got to answer those emails quickly.
16:28Matt Coles So you ever wonder why I'm slow to respond? It's because I don't. Keep it open.
16:34Chris Romeo You don't, you don't let email drive your life. That's a whole other episode coming up of the, uh, you know, how to declutter your digital life.
16:43Izar Tarandach Oh God, if you know how to, please, please.
16:47Chris Romeo So this, this conversation of passwords made me think about, have you guys used any of these? Are they, what are they called? These things in the browsers now where you can. Effectively, it must be certificate-based. Is it a passkey?
17:02Izar Tarandach Passkey.
17:03Chris Romeo Is it a passkey? That's okay. So what, what, what have, what's y'all, what's your experience been with passkeys? Is that a better alternative?
17:15Izar Tarandach You know, I, I, I have absolutely nothing against passkeys. I can safely say that I probably don't understand the whole scheme. But my gut feeling is that you're just going through your different devices and putting an egg, putting a key on each one of them and saying, this device has special value for me. And from this device, I can allow my logins by putting my fingerprint in there. And something in me mistrusts that. I, I much prefer opening my drawer, taking off, taking out the YubiKey. Putting it— did I say a vendor? Putting it in the USB slot and, and clicking on that. But hey, that's, that's just me. That's just me.
18:05Chris Romeo Yeah.
18:05Matt Coles Yeah. I mean, passwords, passkeys are just, I mean, so actually, Isar, can you just for our audience and I guess for me too, tell us about the theory of passkeys?
18:15Izar Tarandach I don't think I quite can, but my understanding is that it generates a, a key pair and the private goes into your keychain, which in each device hopefully is well defended and well kept. And every time that you need—
18:33Matt Coles protected by secure boot unit.
18:35Izar Tarandach Oh God. And, uh, no, wait, who, who uses Windows for this thing? And, uh, damn, I said another vendor. Do we have a jar for vendors? So, Ian. Uh, yeah. So every time that you need it, you actually go and physically, uh, uh, uh, authenticate yourself to the device. And that opens the keychain and that feeds whatever needs to be fed to the browser, to the requiring application, probably some encrypted cookie or secret or whatever. And, uh, crypto magic happens and, uh, Um, yeah, you, you get authenticated to whatever it is that you were trying to.
19:19Chris Romeo So you're at your—
19:19Matt Coles you still have to pass a credential somewhere.
19:24Izar Tarandach Yeah. But the credential now is a key pair that you have no knowledge of. And as we know, if you don't know it, it can't be taken from you.
19:32Matt Coles After you can't expose it.
19:34Chris Romeo Yeah.
19:34Izar Tarandach You can't expose it.
19:36Chris Romeo As Isar has been explaining passkeys, I was reading the FIDO Alliance page for how passkeys work. And, uh, did I get it too wrong? Yeah, no, you're good. Um, it's, it's, uh, it's saying that, um, during registration, the user's client device creates a new crypto key pair. It's bound to the web service domain. The device retains the private key and registers the public key with the online service. And then these cryptographic key pairs called passkeys are unique to every service. They claim, unlike passwords, passkeys are resistant to phishing. Are always strongly designed. Well, I mean, I guess it's, it's because it's taking an action to invoke it. It's not, it's not something that would be—
20:20Matt Coles I'm laughing because this is mutual TLS.
20:23Izar Tarandach Yep.
20:24Matt Coles Basically, that's what they implemented. It's mutual TLS in effect.
20:31Izar Tarandach No, but, but now you don't have like a, for the client side, you don't have an authority. You just have like, it's a, it's a shared, it's a shared key.
20:37Matt Coles It's a shared key pair, but it's a pre, it's a pre-shared key pair for mutual TLS.
20:43Chris Romeo But then what they do is they, they tie it to some biometric.
20:48Matt Coles Yeah. Yeah.
20:50Chris Romeo There's some, so it's multi, so it does give you, it's multifactor-ish.
20:55Matt Coles Multifactor-ish. Yeah. It's a key pair that then gets unlocked. You have a key encryption key basically, or probably that You know, is used and you have multifactor to unlock that key.
21:06Chris Romeo Yeah. Or a FIDO security key as well can unlock it.
21:09Matt Coles Yeah. Because a FIDO key or, or a, uh, you know, the other key that is mentioned or Titan key, you know, they all just hold credentials, right? They'll hold either a certificate, a password of some sort, or, uh, metrics data to be able to do, um, a, um, a pattern match. Yeah.
21:30Chris Romeo All right. So we basically trust passkeys is what you guys are telling me.
21:37Matt Coles Well, they can still be compromised. I mean, uh, if you, if you have access to the hardware device, uh, that's, that's a little bit harder, but if you have access to the software device, you know, bits, uh, bits can be— an interesting question would be, if, if somebody were to dump memory and get bits of keys, first, would you know? And then second, uh, how easy is it to reconstitute the information? Um, so I wonder, has anyone, if anyone's ever done any analysis on, uh, on passkeys, if you have access to memory.
22:16Chris Romeo Yeah.
22:17Izar Tarandach But wait, is, isn't that, uh, Isn't that the same as doing an analysis on any use of, uh, uh, crypto material that lives in an enclave? Because I'm guessing that depending on the hardware, if it's capable to do enclave crypto operations, then those keys are not going to appear in main memory.
22:37Chris Romeo They shouldn't be, or maybe if they are, it's only for a blip. It's not something that sits in memory because, right, the Passkey is an authentication mechanism. Once the authentication transaction has been successful, they better dump any of that stuff and, and zero out any of the memory that was used to hold those things. I mean, that's coming back around to FIPS, right? That's a FIPS principle as well of cleaning up crypto material wherever you use it. You don't leave, you don't leave remnants of it sitting around.
23:11Matt Coles I mean, a good implementation would be, you know, Chrome or or, you know, Bing or whatever you're using, uh, not Bing, uh, Edge, um, to, uh, call to the OS to do the functions, right? So there's no, there's no crypto being done by the browser itself. It should all be done by, by the OS or by, uh, kernelmod or something.
23:31Chris Romeo Yeah.
23:31Izar Tarandach But then we go back to the original question. So we have passkeys and it's great and it's whatnot, but then you get a patch on your browser and your, and that patch just says erase all passkeys that are in there, like just erase them. It's not what's used, what happened to Chrome. Chrome was more of the password manager function in the browser itself.
23:52Chris Romeo Well, I think you need to use different components though. I think part of trust is the age-old wisdom, don't put all your eggs in one basket. And I don't really know why is it if I drop it because all the eggs will break? I don't know. But if you layer your trust using a single source, then it's tough to argue that you have a trustworthy solution if you're using components from the same provider, the same software house, the same vendor.
24:30Izar Tarandach But you, you— there is a—
24:32Matt Coles go ahead, sorry.
24:33Izar Tarandach No, you, you go, man.
24:35Matt Coles No, you go.
24:36Izar Tarandach The, the, you used a word in there that I really liked, the trustworthy. Because when, when Microsoft went ahead with their Trusted Computing initiative, it was trusted. So like, we're going to write these things and you people can trust it. But nobody that I know came out with a trustworthy initiative to say, we wrote this, we designed this in a way that you can trust it. And here's the proof that you can trust it. We're just told to, hey, you know what, trust it, you know, because we say so.
25:08Chris Romeo I, I, I had this, uh, yeah, it was a conclusion. It was a conclusion.
25:13Izar Tarandach I had this teacher back in high school that, uh, every time that we, he, he was a physics teacher. And every time that we would ask him something beyond the, the limit of high school physics, he would look at us and say, well, because Newton said so. And I feel like we're back in the same place. Well, because Microsoft said so, right? It's trustworthy because somebody said so.
25:36Chris Romeo Yeah.
25:38Izar Tarandach And people still don't have the, they are still not naive, but they are not informed enough to come and ask, hey, prove to me that you are trustworthy.
25:47Chris Romeo Yeah. And this is, I mean, my, my conclusion here is I would never use a password manager that was part of a browser. No, because I'm putting, I'm taking two disparate pieces of data or one very important piece of data and I'm mingling it in the realm of, in the control of one player. And so I want multiple players and that's why I use a password manager, for example, that doesn't store, they don't store passwords. They're not in the business of storing passwords. So they give you X number of storage providers that they've integrated with that you can then use to store your passwords, all of the popular ones that you would think of.
26:37Izar Tarandach I wish I trusted myself enough to do that.
26:40Chris Romeo What do you mean?
26:44Izar Tarandach I'm sure that at some point I'm going to bark things and erase the wrong file. And lose all my passwords in the process. Yeah.
26:51Chris Romeo Yeah. So it's, so my, that's why you have to back it up. Yeah. No, I have a, so the, the solution that I use, you, it, it, um, uses the storage, but it also has a local, it also does a local backup copy. So, ah, I, I'm never, I'm never in, but also on those storage providers, you have backup automatically, right? Like who stores files on their local computer anymore? Like we have these cloud services that are integrated. You guys do 'cause you're security nerds. But you can also lose your data pretty easily when you have a hard drive. Like, oh, hard disks still fail. Oh man, I didn't know that was going to happen.
27:27Izar Tarandach SSDs still fail.
27:28Chris Romeo I know, that's what I'm saying. That's why, that's why we have this cloud thing, this, uh, this multi-cloud world.
27:37Izar Tarandach Um, yeah, I think, yeah, you think?
27:39Chris Romeo No, no, I'm just, I mean, this, this is part of unpacking. Trust is like, what are the, what are the core principles that define trust? And it's a certain amount of paranoia, I think is one of them.
27:58Matt Coles So it's, I mean, it, trust is all about, uh, uh, having a clear provable identity. Of something, right? That doesn't have to be a person. Uh, and a chain of evidence that you can verify.
28:19Izar Tarandach And that's trust.
28:20Matt Coles I mean, that is trust, right? That, that you have— Nice. Dog in the background. Uh, so we do, you do have a notion of something that you can say is that thing. And then that it has certain properties that you can verify over time, right? That is the concept of trust. And so that's what our challenge is when it comes to security, right? Is how do we prove identity and maintain that identity proof over time? And that, and sorry, and its integrity over time, right?
28:57Izar Tarandach Yeah. So just to go back into some, themes that we keep going back to. So we have trust in all its forms. We have the reasonable security, meaning you should do as much security as you need, no more, no less. We have, uh, uh, what was it, what, what was it that we, we threw in there? Uh, secure by design and secure by default. And if we know all that and we put all that together, why is it that, what's missing here so that we can actually secure the world? And I go back to the care thing. I still feel that with all these breaches, all these problems, all these things, and I experienced this whole week. When I met people, like normal people who know what I do for a living, and they immediately would ask, hey, hey, what's happened? Like, what's this whole thing that no Windows works and all that? Went to the gym, half of the monitors in the gym don't work for the same reason. And people are like, uh, oh wow, how could you guys do this? I'm like, okay, first of all, it's not me, but, uh, second, like What did you expect? And they're like, well, we just expect things to work. That's the thing. People still don't care. And for example, this conversation about the password manager and the ways that Chris is managing all that stuff. Can you really? I can count in the one finger of one hand the amount of non-technical people that I know that would be willing to go that way and take all those steps and manage it by themselves. Yeah. And care enough about it. And this one person actually has a bunker in their, in their backyard filled with cans.
30:57Chris Romeo So you're not supposed to tell anybody about my bunker. Oh, you were talking about someone else's bunker.
31:02Izar Tarandach That's me. No, no, don't back me up.
31:03Chris Romeo Yeah. But no, I mean, to, to address, to, to, to answer your question. The reason we can't secure the world is really about discipline and convenience. Convenience. Yes. On the user, on the user experience side. Yeah.
31:23Matt Coles Easy.
31:24Chris Romeo The easy button. But it's really a discipline problem. The reason why, if everybody would just do what we prescribe from a security perspective, threat model every story and use, so, so you're implementing secure by design, secure by default, uh, use checks and balances within your secure development lifecycle and do this universally with every release that you have. We could, we could get 90% better than we are today, but the problem is people run businesses. They don't run security shops where security drives everything. Because if you get to that level where security drives everything, it's a world that the three of us would love. We'd be like, this is awesome. We love it. Of course we have nothing to do.
32:19Matt Coles So we have to take up playing golf, which this will be, go and do other things.
32:23Chris Romeo I mean, security table golfing show is what this would become, but it's the lack of discipline.
32:30Matt Coles We would all have jobs in those companies that were building cool things with proper due diligence and care.
32:37Izar Tarandach Yeah.
32:38Chris Romeo I don't know.
32:41Matt Coles I would, I'd be playing with robots, I'm sure, or something.
32:44Izar Tarandach Oh, totally.
32:45Matt Coles Or threat modeling.
32:47Izar Tarandach What's, what's the driver that we are missing here to get there? Because we, we, we keep playing Cassandra. We keep telling people these bad things are going to happen and nobody believes us.
32:59Matt Coles I, I don't have, I don't have it handy, but it's, it's, um, it's, uh, it's this, it's this green paper, paper thing that, uh, people exchange for stuff. Right. Uh, but that's no, but that's, that's not, you want some, we gotta give you something. No, I understand you.
33:18Izar Tarandach I, I, I get what you say, Matt, but you know, it's, it's like, we're not asking people to do something unrealistic here. Perhaps we are asking them, okay, slow down 1% so that we can run later. It's, it's not infeasible. It's not—
33:37Chris Romeo the challenge though is that we're all sitting on the same side of the table and we're saying this is only a 1% impact, but is it really a 1% impact? When we think about the depth of engineering. And I think that's, I think we're uncovering a bit of a challenge that we can have as security people in that we tend to see the world with security-colored glasses. And we also think things are a lot easier than they actually are because they're easy in our mind. Because why don't you just run SAST on every, in every build pipeline? Or every time a developer checks in code, they should just run a SAST tool. And they should just fix any of the problems that the tool identifies. That's easy for us as security people to prescribe, but we, we gloss over false positives. And when the tool, they run the tool and it generates 5,000 results, like we miss out on all of those things that the developer experience side of the house sees as blockers, stoppers, or things that would keep them from using this discipline that we're asking them to use all the time, unilaterally.
34:53Izar Tarandach I get what you're saying. The thing is that I always try to bring together my security practice to actual developers. And over the years, the, the, and I can hear my voice saying this in 2010, 2012. We, we've been saying that you have a choice to do your preventive care and see the doctor once a year, or you can wait until later and run to the ER with things oozing out of you, right? And over the years, to me, that's changed into, from, from like, from medical care, the, the, the analogy changed into dental care. You can brush and spend some time flossing every day, or you can see as the cavities and the gingivitis mount up, and at some point you can't eat anymore. And we, we are at the point right now that people are looking around and saying, security people, what do you want from us? We can't eat anymore because you are pointing at too many cavities in our teeth. So it's, it's a self-created problem. If, if you don't do the, the, the basic hygiene in the beginning, if you don't adopt a mindset that I have these number of tasks that I have to do so that I don't have to suffer and pay the time and pay the money. Yeah. In the end.
36:20Chris Romeo Yeah. But that, that, uh, that train has left the station.
36:24Izar Tarandach It hasn't. That's the thing.
36:25Chris Romeo A long time ago.
36:26Matt Coles No, I also wanna, I also wanna throw out there. I, there's something else we need to throw out in this conversation. The problem is, the problem is the analogy is bad, right? It's because dentistry operates on a set of teeth and teeth are teeth, right? There's one teeth, one set of, one type of teeth. There's one technology of teeth that they're dealing with. And so all of the dentistry works on that technology.
36:51Chris Romeo Single stack. Single stack.
36:53Izar Tarandach So we clearly don't watch the same movies. Yeah. Okay.
36:57Matt Coles So, so the problem is the problem, a problem. It is not the problem and it is, it, but it is related that because there's so many, how many programming languages are there?
37:13Chris Romeo 1,217.
37:14Matt Coles How many of those programming language and how many operating systems are there and how many of those programming languages and toolkits and everything else there's this just magnitude of problem, right? All it takes is one of those, let's take a X, X was XZ Utils, right? All it takes is one piece to not have the due diligence to cause a ripple effect throughout. And so when, when you're talking about you're generating tons and tons of issues, well, there's tons and tons of, tons of security weaknesses. Right? The, the CWE database is full of possible flaws for security. Oh, oh, oh, we're not talking privacy.
37:56Chris Romeo No, no, no, no.
37:56Matt Coles We're not talking other things.
37:58Izar Tarandach Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. I'm going to push back on the analogy and it just proved my point.
38:02Matt Coles Oh, fair.
38:04Izar Tarandach There is one set of teeth, but you have different kinds of teeth. You have incisors, you have canines, you have molars. Each one of them have a different geometry, but the fundamentals are that you have to brush and floss. If you brush and floss all of them, doesn't matter which kind of tooth it is, good things are going to happen. Now look at the CWE. The CWE is a tree. It has a root, it has medium leaves, and it has all the branches down to the minimum detail of a CWE. If you adopt the fundamentals right, if you do your hygiene right, you're going to be killing those, uh, those, uh, weaknesses. At the higher level of the tree. So you won't have to worry about the branches and the leaves on the bottom. So the analogy stands.
38:51Matt Coles I sit corrected.
38:54Chris Romeo For the first time on the Security Table, somebody has admitted that they accepted.
39:00Izar Tarandach No, no, no, no. I admit all the time when I'm wrong. I may not say that somebody is right, but I admit that I'm wrong. Uh, so you see, flossing and brush, that's, that's my whole point. I gotta run back to fundamentals.
39:18Chris Romeo I gotta go floss right now. Yes.
39:21Izar Tarandach Ooh, I knew I forgot something this morning.
39:23Matt Coles Yeah.
39:24Chris Romeo Uh, no, I mean, it's, this is, this is a challenging issue. There is no single solution for, because there's certain there are multiple trillion variables that would have in this equation.
39:42Izar Tarandach But Chris, you're like one of the most successful cases of, uh, uh, actually teaching secure development and secure design to developers on a day-to-day basis, not perhaps as an instructor, but as a creator, as a, everything that you put together and everything that you successfully sold out there. Tell us why it's so hard to educate developers.
40:07Chris Romeo I mean, it's ultimately about time is always the challenge is, is I found towards the end of, of my, uh, days at Security Journey, didn't find anybody who pushed back to say, oh no, our developers already know this. Nobody said that. Or, and nobody said our developers don't need this. The challenge comes down to why doesn't everybody do it? Well, because they're under-resourced already to begin with. And this is another thing on top and we have to trade away these features to be able to invest in this foundational thing. And it's a, it, yeah, as Matt's making the, the dollars and ultimately people run businesses and businesses have bottom lines and businesses have revenue targets and things. And that's—
41:06Matt Coles and by the way, and by the way, we have open source projects that don't have necessarily those factors, but have a different problem of not enough resources, not enough time, somebody who's volunteering their time to do work. And that's why we can't solve this problem with open source either.
41:23Chris Romeo Yeah, because they're focused on building a feature because it's, that's what people want. That's what they're, that's what they think is cool. It'd be great if they thought threat modeling their open source library was cool or flashy or was going to get a press release, but no one's going to write a press release about the developer who did a threat model of an open, their open source library pieces.
41:46Matt Coles Actually, that would be an interesting story to tell. Perhaps we should open source developer that had an open source developer that, that knew enough about security and wanted to protect its users.
41:58Izar Tarandach Or perhaps they didn't even know much about security, but wanted to at least do the right thing and threat model it.
42:03Matt Coles Yeah.
42:03Izar Tarandach That would be a really cool story to tell.
42:04Chris Romeo I'd, I'd love to hear that story if we could find somebody who was in that category. Huh.
42:12Izar Tarandach Okay. Challenge accepted.
42:15Matt Coles Challenge accepted. That sounds like a future episode waiting to happen.
42:19Chris Romeo Yeah. Somebody's out there.
42:20Izar Tarandach Let's go hunt for someone out there that did this. There must be someone.
42:26Matt Coles I'm sure there's someone. How many projects are there on GitHub?
42:32Chris Romeo Yeah.
42:32Izar Tarandach Speaking of which, GitHub is another one that we lost trust this week. Because they figured out that deleted stuff on GitHub is actually accessible. And what's one of the things that gets most deleted from GitHub?
42:46Matt Coles Credentials.
42:47Izar Tarandach Ba-da!
42:48Matt Coles Hard-coded passwords.
42:50Izar Tarandach Right? So yeah, well—
42:53Matt Coles So Git Purge doesn't work anymore?
42:55Izar Tarandach I didn't quite read the whole story. Just so much stuff happened this week. But let me see if I can give it a quick— no, I'm not using ChatGPT. I'm using the register.
43:07Chris Romeo Which is usually, it was written by ChatGPT.
43:11Izar Tarandach Oh, you know, sometimes you feel like, but you always have the, uh, BOFH.
43:18Chris Romeo Yeah. Page to save you. I don't know. They went, they went so commercial. I used to love that site.
43:24Izar Tarandach Oh man.
43:24Chris Romeo I used to love their snarkiness that was in every article that they wrote.
43:30Izar Tarandach I used to totally identify with it. But yeah, you're right. Lately they, they became like way too—
43:40Chris Romeo they went corporate. Everybody does. But coming back around, it's about the money. You're running a business.
43:44Izar Tarandach Here you go. Here you go. Data from deleted GitHub repos may not actually be deleted. Um, research at whatever have found or arguably rediscovered that data from deleted GitHub repositories, public or private. And from deleted copies, forks of repositories isn't necessarily deleted. There's a cross-fork object reference. Oh, that's a new term. It even got a new term. Okay, cool. Yeah.
44:16Chris Romeo I mean, anybody can add a new term. There's no committee. It's too abrasive.
44:19Izar Tarandach Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait. Yeah. As we all know, a C4 vulnerability occurs when one repository fork can access sensitive data from another fork. Including data from private and deleted forks. Interesting. The firm showed how one can fork the repository, commit data to it, delete the fork, and then access the supposedly deleted commit data via the original repository. It's almost like when you used to delete a, uh, a DOS file and then go and change the, the, the path and then delete it again.
44:51Matt Coles Let's talk about COVID channels and ADFS and all that sort of stuff.
44:57Izar Tarandach Mm-hmm. Wow. Wow, people. How, how come this didn't become a major thing?
45:04Chris Romeo So there is no trust is what I learned today. Trust is, uh, that's the only thing that I trust is that there is no trust. So that's, that's a good conclusion. That's a good place to end. Good place to end this, this conversation. So, uh, I don't know, we went somewhere and then we turned a couple of corners, then we spun around the block. And then we landed somewhere. And this is a challenging issue. It's just not, this is, it's not something that's, of course, do these 3 things, even though Matt laid it out well, as far as what trust is, it's just really hard in implementation. It's easy on the whiteboard. You can probably use 20 words to describe it and say, that's what it is. But living it, breathing it, and implementing it in everything that you build and everything that you sell.
45:49Matt Coles Funding it.
45:50Izar Tarandach Funding it.
45:51Chris Romeo That turns out to be a challenging problem. So folks, thanks for listening to another episode of the Security Tip.
Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.
Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.
