Experts Want to Excel
With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles
What constitutes an expert in the field of threat modeling? Today Matt, Chris and Izar explore cultural references, the intricacies of threat modeling practices, and the criteria that define an expert.
About this episode
What constitutes an expert in the field of threat modeling? Today Matt, Chris and Izar explore cultural references, the intricacies of threat modeling practices, and the criteria that define an expert. The discussion touches on the evolution of threat modeling, the roles of facilitators, and the importance of experience and recognition in the field. The guys humorously debate the challenge of scaling practices in large organizations and share thoughts on how expertise can inspire others. Enjoy this amusing episode complete with tangents on movies, old media technologies, sports analogies, and competitive Excel.
Follow AI Security Table:
➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/
➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable
➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/
➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable
Transcript · 44 min conversation
0:08Izar Tarandach We get the best movies and the best songs.
0:11Chris Romeo I love the fact that you guys get the movie references though, because a lot of people I interact with don't get the references and they're like, why are you doing that? Like, oh.
0:22Izar Tarandach It happens a lot at work, you know? You throw one that you're sure it's going to like Everybody's going to see it and just run with it. And what you get is like blank stare. Why is the old man talking like that again?
0:36Chris Romeo Yeah, yeah, that'd be cool. Yeah, cool.
0:40Izar Tarandach Fire, fire. I remember when we used to do things.
0:46Matt Coles Yep.
0:48Chris Romeo Yeah, movies are, uh, I have a Fight Club reference.
0:54Matt Coles You don't talk about Fight Club.
0:55Chris Romeo Yes, but it's in my threat modeling. It's in my workshop. And so I put up this slide that says, okay, and, you know, now I'm going to explain to you the rules of Threat Modeling Club. And it's got like the Fight Club poster with threat modeling interspersed on top where Fight Club was. So it says Threat Modeling Club. And then I'm like, okay, there's 3 rules. Like, first rule is we don't talk about Threat Modeling Club. Second rule, we don't talk about Threat Modeling Club. The third rule, I wasn't witty enough to come up with one, so you'll have to give me one after. And the fourth rule, if it's your first time at Threat Modeling Club, you have to threat model. But the funny thing is, like, I look across the room and I see the people that get it. And these people are like, what is this guy doing?
1:41Izar Tarandach Oh gosh.
1:43Chris Romeo All right.
1:44Izar Tarandach Where's this word going?
1:46Chris Romeo Yeah. Why aren't people just following all the cultural things that we've experienced in the last 35 years and applying them to their lives?
1:54Matt Coles 35?
1:55Chris Romeo I just made that up. I pick random numbers for examples all the time. Nobody ever calls me on it. Thanks, Matt. Until now. Nope. All right, Matt, you had a, you had a, you wanted to tee this up for us. You have a a discussion topic that somebody brought to you. So I'd love to hear kind of the background story of it.
2:17Matt Coles Yeah, so just an idle conversation, I suppose, but a serious one. What does it take to be an expert in threat modeling? It's a simple question, but it's not an easy answer, is it? So what is an expert in threat modeling?
2:37Izar Tarandach That's the question, yeah.
2:39Matt Coles I mean, so we're all considered experts in threat modeling, right? Well, people, I think people think we're experts in threat modeling. I hope we are.
2:48Chris Romeo Yes, I would clarify that. Other people have given that moniker to the work that we've done, especially you guys with the book and everything. But I think the first thing to think about when we're talking about what makes an expert is, Anyone who declares themself as an expert is in fact not an expert because you may not self-proclaim that you're an expert. And I see people do it on LinkedIn all the time. Like their bio is like, you know, I security expert. Like, no, you can't write that. Like, AI can write it about you, but you can't write it about yourself.
3:27Matt Coles With 35 years experience working with these other companies. Okay. All right. Hold on. Oh, that wasn't a valid comment because AI has been a research field for more than 50 years.
3:40Chris Romeo No, wait.
3:41Izar Tarandach But you have to be like an expert. You have to be an expert in the current thing. Otherwise, you're a historian.
3:48Chris Romeo Please.
3:51Matt Coles Expert.
3:51Izar Tarandach That's a good title.
3:52Chris Romeo Expert or historian.
3:55Matt Coles So, wait, are you saying that all those experts in COBOL programming are really historians of COBOL? True.
4:01Izar Tarandach Yeah, actually. No, no, because COBOL hasn't changed since, at least not the last time that I looked at it.
4:07Chris Romeo Well, if you're a COBOL programmer in this day and age, you're a baller because like nobody can touch you. No, you can literally, you can literally come into work and like your boss says you need to do this and you're like, no, I'm not going to do that. I'm just going to sit over here and if something breaks, I'll fix it.
4:25Matt Coles Okay, cool.
4:26Chris Romeo Just don't get mad and leave. Because there's only 4 of you left in the world. Okay.
4:33Matt Coles I don't know anything about it.
4:33Chris Romeo All right. Expert. So, so I gave a kind of a, yeah, so you can't self-proclaim. I think that's, I think we all agree on that. You can't self-proclaim. Anyone who self-proclaims as an expert is not an expert at all because you can't do that. You have to be, so part of what makes somebody a threat modeling expert, I would say the first principle I'll throw on the table is you have to be recognized by other people in the field as for your accomplishments, achievements, whatever that you're doing.
5:00Izar Tarandach Oh, but wait, then it's people in the field all the way down. Who was the first expert that could recognize other people as threat modeling experts and who recognized him as or her as an expert?
5:13Chris Romeo It's not a chicken and egg problem. Come on, we didn't have to go to chicken and egg for this. What came first, the chicken or the egg? So is it the threat modeling expert or the ability to recognize other people.
5:29Izar Tarandach There was a first one. So who was the first one and what can we learn from him or her about being a threat modeling expert?
5:39Matt Coles Well, okay, so if we have to take it back to the history of threat modeling, oh my God, I can't believe we're about to do this. It didn't start with Microsoft, right? It started with those folks who were building stuff, rockets, right? Or, you know, even further back, I'm sure, but, you know, let's talk about things like—
5:59Izar Tarandach Apparently those folks right now have forgotten how to do it, but let's not go there.
6:03Matt Coles Okay. But we've also, the threat modeling has evolved, right? Threat modeling was all about risk analysis and looking for hazards and threats and things like that. And, you know, so you have papers from, say, missed, right? This risk management framework is an early threat modeling document. If you take it to an extreme, yes, think about what you're working on, look at the threats, document them, figure out which ones are real, which ones aren't, and then do something about it, right? Whether that's do nothing or transfer the risk to whatever, but that's an early form of threat modeling, or that is the early threat modeling. And that's certainly not the first. So expertise, an individual with it as an expert versus the industry expertise. I don't know. Uh, I'm just grasping at straws here. Well, I've— right, because it— how do you answer the question? Are you a historian?
7:04Chris Romeo We are all historians because we're older.
7:07Izar Tarandach No, I make stuff up. I already forgot all the stuff, so I just make it up.
7:10Matt Coles What do you mean?
7:11Chris Romeo Do you want to ask somebody?
7:13Matt Coles Do you want to ask somebody who the first threat modeler is and see what comes up? I don't want to do that search, but please go ahead if you want to.
7:22Izar Tarandach I have it open here totally by purpose.
7:26Matt Coles Sure, sure, it's right here.
7:29Izar Tarandach Who was the first recognized threat modeling Expert.
7:38Chris Romeo Oh, let's see if someone poisoned the trading data.
7:44Izar Tarandach Okay, 50 bucks to the first one that says which name popped up.
7:48Matt Coles Adam Shostak.
7:50Izar Tarandach Ding ding ding ding ding! Give the man a ChatGPT.
7:56Chris Romeo I think to Matt's point though, that's not—
8:00Matt Coles he's not the first.
8:01Izar Tarandach Oh, but wait, let's see why. The first widely recognized expert in threat modeling is Adam Shostak. He played a key role in formalizing threat modeling practices and is well known for his contributions while working at Microsoft, where he helped develop the STRIDES threat modeling methodology. Shostak's 2014 book, Threat Modeling: Designing for Security, is considered a foundational text on the subject and has influenced how many organizations approach threat modeling today.
8:31Matt Coles Yeah. I think that's actually false because there's 3 people at Microsoft who might be very upset about that answer.
8:37Chris Romeo Yeah. And I think, I think, I think Lauren is the one who created, Lauren Kohnfelder and somebody else created STRIDE.
8:43Izar Tarandach Wait, wait, wait. But he says he played the key role in formalizing. He didn't say that he created it.
8:48Chris Romeo Okay.
8:50Izar Tarandach Where he helped develop the STRIDE.
8:53Chris Romeo So, yeah. Okay.
8:54Matt Coles No, no, no.
8:55Izar Tarandach Tell you the truth. I'm fine if he's an astrologer.
8:57Matt Coles I'll accept it.
9:04Chris Romeo Sure.
9:05Izar Tarandach Okay. Because he's the first public one. Like, he is like the name that we usually call him the ambassador of this thing, right? He's the first public face in this thing.
9:17Matt Coles Yeah.
9:17Izar Tarandach All the greats that came before him were more subdued, more foundational, more How do we do this thing in here?
9:24Matt Coles Well, so that's an interesting, so now what you're bringing up is to be an expert, do you have to be outgoing?
9:31Izar Tarandach No, but I think that we, we sort of allude to that when we said you have to be recognized by others, right? If you don't have a public face, you're not seen, if you're not heard of, it makes it harder for people to recognize you as such.
9:47Chris Romeo Yeah, but you don't have to be recognized by people across the industry. You could be recognized by people inside your own company, for example, and I would still say you're an expert, even though you're not going to get the publicity because like, that's one of the things I'm doing on the AppSec Podcast right now is for the next couple of months, we're trying to only interview people who are, have not been in the limelight because we've been in an echo chamber for how many years. And I look at who we've interviewed there and it's kind of the same group of people rotating in and out. And I'm like, it's time to get some new voices. It's time to get some new people, because there's a lot of people doing cool stuff in our industry. They just don't run the conference scene like we do.
10:30Matt Coles And then— Sorry. Even before that though, I would, you know, at some point, at one point, or I guess previously, the conference scene wasn't even the recognition, right? You would get recognition from like ACM or IEEE or one of those other academic organizations. Or industry organizations that were driving the field forward, right?
10:53Chris Romeo Yeah.
10:53Izar Tarandach So true, true. So we came back from San Francisco actually with one or two names that we'll give it later. Some really cool new people that deserve to be listened. But back to being, yeah, so, so, —what we need, we need—
11:16Matt Coles how do we get to the, what does it take to be an expert? So, being recognized by others and not self-recognizing is number one, right? So, we're starting a list here of, you can't self-declare expert. You can self-declare an expertise, I would say, right? So, we are all security threat modelers, right? Some people are privacy threat modelers. So they can, I think you can claim expertise, self-proclaim expertise, although it's nice to have, uh, you know, sort of reputation for that other by others. Again, whether it's within the company or, uh, in the public space. Uh, so can't self-declare expert. You can have an affinity towards certain technologies or domains or, or other, other things. It's good to get, you could do your process or you do technology, whatever. Um, but what else does it take to be a threat model expert?
12:13Chris Romeo How about experience? Like what level? So let's use Adam as a, as a guinea pig here, right? Because a lot of people know about what he's done and accomplished. And so I would say part of what makes Adam an expert and a recognized expert is the fact that he has real-world experience. And so he worked in the Microsoft environment. Trying to not only understand and master this concept, but also roll it out to lots of other people?
12:46Matt Coles Yeah, so I was thinking, as I was trying to think of an answer for my colleague, I was thinking about this. So when you're threat modeling, you have to be an ex— you have to be familiar obviously with the process of threat modeling that you're using. So you have to be familiar with, you know, STRIDE and DVDs and, sorry, DVDs. DVDs. Oh my God. Yeah, throwback. You were talking about throwback technology, right?
13:14Chris Romeo Yeah, probably, yeah. To those, to those younger people listening to the show, a DVD is a disc that we used to put into a machine to watch a movie.
13:25Izar Tarandach Wait, I think that I have a threat modeling course in VHS here somewhere.
13:31Matt Coles For those who don't know, VHS is a block of stuff with a tape inside that we used to put into a brick to attach to our TV.
13:40Izar Tarandach And before that, there were small signals.
13:45Matt Coles Remember LaserDisc? Where we used to take a bigger disc and put it on the— Remember? Remember?
13:52Chris Romeo I do. I had one.
13:54Matt Coles So I was trying to say DFD. Data Flow Diagram. And sequence diagrams. So you have to be familiar with that. But if you're not familiar with the technology that you're threat modeling, is that okay? I mean, we can't possibly know all of the technologies and all the constructs and all the patterns and all the things, right? That's why we don't threat model alone. That's why we're not the hero threat modelers, right?
14:20Izar Tarandach Yeah, so I would say that not only that's not a requirement, that would even be, that would even score against you, I think.
14:32Matt Coles Because how are your superpower?
14:36Izar Tarandach Because it biases you maybe? No, perhaps. But I think that the real difference between, and actually we could go back to that famous pyramid of education and all that stuff. But I think that what makes an expert an expert is the fact that their foundational knowledge, that their understanding of how, in threat modeling, the understanding of how things break in general and being able to spot those patterns into whatever scenario is put in front of them. Sometimes it will be a bit more educational. You have to sit down and read the docs and whatnot. That's always a must. But the The finesse of being able to identify a thread and pull on it and almost always get to something that's valuable. I think that that's a big difference between somebody you can call an expert and somebody who you perhaps not yet. Yeah. And developing that thing is the— is the secret. Yeah.
15:45Chris Romeo I would go a step further. So I agree with what you just said. I think that's part of being an expert is being able to see the patterns, but not understanding or having to be an expert in all the technologies, but being able to see the patterns in many different types of technologies. I would take it a step further and say, if you're going to call yourself an expert or if someone's going to call you an expert at threat modeling, I expect that you can draw that out of other people. In a collaborative environment. So you can, and so like what I love to do, I love to use the Socratic method. And I joke about this, but I would say 50% of the time I feel like I know the answer to the question that I ask of a development team, for example, in a threat modeling session, probably the other 50%, I'm winging it. I'm like, I don't know the answer to this. I'm just going to throw this question out. But it's the question that unlocks their thinking and draws them to say, well, yes, okay, I see this. And sometimes I'm like, yeah, even though I'm like, I had no idea that was what they were going to say, but it's being able to draw other people out and make them. And so there's a teaching and drawing out part of this as well.
16:53Izar Tarandach But that for me is finding the thread that you're going to pull.
16:56Matt Coles Yeah. And for that, I think I liken it to sort of like either a QA process, right? So if you've done QA engineering at all, that's or quality assurance, that's, that I think that helps a lot here, those types of skills, right? Or root cause analysis, right? So the 5 Whys process, for instance, not the Five Eyes, that's different. The 5 Whys.
17:21Chris Romeo We always go to national security. Why do we always go to national security?
17:24Matt Coles Because it starts there, right? That's where it started from. That's, you know, critical infrastructure and all. But, you know, having a process where you're you're never satisfied with one answer and you always know how to dig deeper, but you're, you're pulling out information, right? And so you're getting, well, you know, getting deeper and deeper on layers and you have to, you don't start at just the context and then stop there. Worth taking a process where you, like QA or like RCA, where you are always digging. What is this? Why does this exist? What's below it? Socratic method works too, I guess, but it's recombining those because you want to pull out answers. You don't want to pre-guess answers. You want to predict them, but you don't want to presuppose them. And getting to the inner shell, I guess, is what we really need to do when threat modeling. And it's that— those are soft skills, right? Those are Those are very much soft skills on how you deal with people. You have to have interpersonal skills. You have to have empathy, right? But wait for a second.
18:37Izar Tarandach Yeah, yeah. That's where I wanted to fork the thing a bit. Okay. So we touched on the sort of technical skills, sort of like the subject, the matter of threat modeling. But soft skills, I would say that they help make an expert. They may not be if and only if, but at the same time, we have to look into it and say, okay, I personally know people who are not technical, who don't have that thing to identify the thread, but they are amazing soft skills people who understand the methodologies and who understands the dialogue around the thing, and that makes them great people who can lead threat modeling sessions. Does that make them great threat modelers?
19:36Matt Coles I would say no. Well, that's an interesting question. So what's the role of a threat modeling facilitator or leading a session?
19:42Chris Romeo It's to draw out the answers from the other people. It's, I think of facilitation as primarily an educational opportunity, right? Because if your model is we're going to facilitate threat models forever, you're never going to scale threat modeling to anything. You're always going to be limited by the number of facilitators you can put in place. I see facilitation as I'm teaching these people how to threat model by asking the right questions at the right time so that next time they can do this themselves or they can lead a session like this. Where they're asking the questions because they've seen the methodology that I'm using.
20:22Matt Coles But, but at the particularly more basic level though, is the threat modeling facilitator actually doing threat modeling? Or are they just simply connecting people who are actually doing the threat modeling?
20:35Chris Romeo I think they're connecting people, but they're not an ex— I would not say that a great threat modeling facilitator is a threat modeling expert. 'Cause if you can't do it on your own, like, a threat modeling expert can threat model something by themselves and come up with a great result. And they can also, in my world, they can lead a group of people in an educational experience where those people leave the session with a better understanding of how to do threat modeling.
21:02Izar Tarandach So the threat modeling facilitator, the great threat modeling facilitator is not an expert threat modeler. Is every, Expert threat modeler, a great threat modeling facilitator?
21:15Chris Romeo I would say no, that doesn't make you— I would say if you can't facilitate a session and where other people walk away with more knowledge and experience about threat modeling, if you can just sit in the corner and do it by yourself, you're not an expert, not in my book.
21:29Matt Coles But that's not the question he asked. Is every expert somebody who can be a good facilitator?
21:34Chris Romeo Oh, the answer's no. It would have to be yes, according to what I just said, in my mind.
21:41Izar Tarandach Let's go with it.
21:42Matt Coles But is it? Well, okay, so think about the experts that we consider for threat modeling today. Are they all good facilitators?
21:55Izar Tarandach I haven't sat in sessions with every single one of them, but the people who I consider experts have given me enough indication that if that was the case, they would be good at it.
22:10Chris Romeo And we sat with them through both the Threat Modeling Manifesto and the Threat Modeling Capabilities projects, all the people we're talking about here. And so seeing them interact in those environments is what tells me they can facilitate a threat modeling session just based on hearing them interact in that forum and share ideas and and push boundaries and, you know, the way that we did that with so much respect for everybody that was there, that's my kind of assurance that those people are all expert facilitators and expert threat modelers.
22:44Izar Tarandach And yet, very strangely, with very, very, very personal approaches to it. So while we can, we may be talking about Yes, that methodologies for threat modeling, we haven't, what I have seen at least is very personal methodologies for facilitating. So it seems to me that those soft skills are definitely personal and distinct from the practice of threat modeling itself.
23:22Matt Coles Complementary but distinct. I would rephrase that a little bit. There's the process of threat modeling in particular methodology, like how to do STRIDE, how to build DFDs. So those are technical things. And then you have the ways in which you do facilitation or teasing out that information or you know, pulling on threads which are not encoded anywhere, right? Those are somebody wants to use psychology, somebody wants to use games, somebody wants to use whatever. That's, that's, there's flexibility there, right? But you do Stride and you may do variants of Stride, but you do Stride or you do Linden or you do Sparta or you do whatever, right? You're doing some methodology. Which is following a process, right? This, I guess if we think of like Hogwarts, right? And this is, there's the spell, which is codified and then you have the flavor and the flourish and the approach, which may be personal. And so, we keep looking at Hogwarts and not D&D, but that's okay. You know, let's sit. I'm more of a gamer than a hard words person, but anyway, so I think that there's opportunity for personalization in this process and still be an expert. Great, you don't have to write that all down. So let's take this a little bit other direction. Does somebody who, does somebody have to be a good evangelizer of Fred Pollack? So there's one thing to facilitate, there's another to spread the word of threat modeling, right? Get others to want to do threat modeling or find value in threat modeling without actually having done it yet. Is that part of being an expert?
25:27Izar Tarandach I would say that no, in the same sense that the facilitating is, but it's interesting to me that the image that that's popping up in my head now is a person in a conference room being alone, they can know how to do the threat model. Having a lot of people around, they know how to facilitate that session. Standing in the door and screaming outside to bring people in is evangelizing. So how much of what's happening in that room makes them an expert?
26:01Chris Romeo So let me flip the question around then. So can you, if you are not able to move threat modeling forward inside of an organization, are you still an expert?
26:15Izar Tarandach I would emphatically say yes, because scaling that practice and bringing it to the whole organization is such a huge challenge and by itself requires so much different stuff that I think doesn't belong in threat modeling by itself that I cannot put both things together.
26:42Matt Coles I will, I'll go happy medium here though and say, if you evangelize threat modeling and by evangelize here, I mean, you talk about it, maybe you give a training session, maybe you do a presentation to an org or a portion of the org, or you just talk to people who are curious on the topic and they take action on your behalf or at your, I won't say direction, but, you know, but at your, as a result of that interaction, they take action and do threat modeling. That I think is on the path to being an expert in threat modeling. You have encouraged others to take action and they have. Can you take that, move that forward, say you move the needle forward on an organization-wide adoption of threat modeling? That's a stretch. And for all the reasons as are mentioned and more, that is a very non-trivial thing, especially a very large organization, you know, where if you don't have the ability to travel or communicate effectively or there's other roadblocks in your way, right? There's always the not invented here, why are you bothering me kind of security thing, right? So, we, I think you don't necessarily need to be able to scale an organization, but I think if you have the ability to communicate with people about the topic of threat modeling and they take action as a result of that communication and improve their capability, then you're demonstrating your expertise.
28:21Chris Romeo Yeah, I think I'm falling more on, I think we're all, I think this is an odd conclusion because Matt, you're kind of in the middle. Ezar's on the, you don't have to be scalable or programmable. You just have to know threat modeling. I'm going to come in on the far other side, right? Because I think for somebody to be an expert, you could say like, hey, you're just an expert in the topic, but you sit over there off to the side and and you do great threat models, but you don't make anybody else better, to me, that's not an expert. Like, you have to make other people better through evangelization and through the ability to scale the thing, which is what Adam did at Microsoft, right? Like, Adam has all of these pillars that we're discussing here in his origin story at Microsoft.
29:12Izar Tarandach Back to the Threat Modeling Manifesto. When we talked about the hero threat modeler, we were bringing out there the anti-pattern that threat models should not happen in a dark room somewhere and live there and not go outside. Right. So we were addressing the utility of a threat model. Yet that does not negate the fact that if a threat model happens that way and by some feat of archaeology somebody finds it and actually makes use of it, the threat model itself is not going to be worse or bad. It can be a very good threat model. It just happens against the pattern that we saw as good.
30:02Matt Coles But is it a person? Is the person who built that threat model An expert.
30:06Izar Tarandach That's my point. If that person has 20 years of threat modeling under their belt and they did lots and lots of threat models during all those years and they made all the mistakes and they corrected all the mistakes, it just happened in a vacuum. Does that make them less of an expert? Does time in service—
30:28Matt Coles is time in service required to be an expert?
30:32Chris Romeo No, I don't think it gets you. I don't think you can, that someone can say you're an expert because you've been doing something for 20 years. I've been driving a car for, let's see, 35 years and you could argue I'm not an expert at that. I mean, Formula One's not calling me saying, Chris, you got 35 years, we'd put you in one of these cars and get you to work.
30:51Izar Tarandach Well, no, no, but wait, there's a problem here with the analogy. Driving a car and being a Formula 1 driver are very, very, very, very different things. They may share the same mechanics of holding something and changing. Kids, once upon a time there was a clutch thing. So it may involve the same mechanics, but as a skill, they're completely different, right?
31:21Chris Romeo No, driving is the skill. Max Verstappen is the best in the world at driving a car.
31:26Izar Tarandach No, nobody's telling you that you go to driver's ed and you learn how to take a turn at 4G the same way that a Formula 1 driver does.
31:37Chris Romeo You didn't go to the same driver's ed class I did then, so. I went to Sears, baby. Sears was teaching us some 4G turns. Come on.
31:45Izar Tarandach I never ruled against you. But my point is that Even if the basic skill is the same, the requirements to fulfill it are completely different. You don't put a Cessna pilot in the space shuttle and say, land this thing because both things fly, so you should be able to do it, right?
32:04Chris Romeo You should be able to do it.
32:05Izar Tarandach Once upon a time, people had to land the space shuttle.
32:07Chris Romeo If you're an expert, if you're an expert pilot, you should be able to take your Cessna knowledge and apply it to the space shuttle.
32:12Matt Coles Kids, at one time we had a space shuttle.
32:16Chris Romeo We don't fly space shuttles anymore.
32:17Izar Tarandach But anyway, so my point is, perhaps somebody in a Pacific island somewhere is very busy threat modeling for the past 20 years by themselves. And if they stepped out of the island and said, I do this thing, I look at what can go wrong, and I'm very good at looking at a palm tree and saying, how long is it going to take for the coconut to fall? What I'm saying is just because they were alone doing that, we shouldn't look at them as less of an expert in this thing that they became very good over time, right? Just because they were by themselves.
33:02Chris Romeo So they're a self-proclaimed expert.
33:04Izar Tarandach No, no, no, no, no, no. We could proclaim them experts based on the knowledge and experience that they accumulated, even though it happened by itself.
33:12Chris Romeo Even though it was done in a vacuum.
33:14Izar Tarandach I think that what I'm getting to is demonstrated skill. Like if I had a person who came through the most gregarious corporation ever and everything is public and everything is shared and everything is, what was the name, socialized. And I have the guy that came from, or the person that came from the Pacific Islands and only got input from a message in a bottle. If both of them can show me skill, I'd be glad to call both of them experts.
33:46Chris Romeo I think you're being too liberal with your expert tag. If everybody, I mean, if everybody's an expert, nobody's an expert.
33:55Izar Tarandach There is something to that, but again, I'm not calling everybody.
33:58Chris Romeo I'm going to make threat modeling trophies and start handing them out to people.
34:01Izar Tarandach No, you get a trophy and you get a trophy, but I'm not calling everybody an expert. I'm saying that if you come and you show me what you did and I recognize that as expert-level work, then I have no problem calling you an expert. However you grew up in that experience.
34:19Chris Romeo So your origin story doesn't matter. It's what you can do. It's interesting. Look, what have you done for me lately?
34:25Matt Coles What can you do? Tapas, yeah.
34:27Izar Tarandach It's what you put on the table.
34:28Matt Coles It's the measure. Yeah. Yeah. Does that hold true for other experts? No question. Is somebody who is capable, What, what separates somebody who's capable versus somebody who's an expert?
34:44Chris Romeo They rise to the upper echelon. Upper echelon. Like, use a basketball example for you. I know you guys love sports, right? I mean, you know, you know who Michael Jordan is though, right?
34:57Matt Coles You know, one day there was a basketball player named Michael Jordan.
35:01Chris Romeo Yes, but he was arguably the best at what he did.
35:07Matt Coles He knew the game. Yeah. He knew the game and he was good and better, better than others at scoring points, which was the name of the game.
35:15Chris Romeo But he was driven, but he, but it was a drive inside of him for success. And it's, it's almost comical. Some of the things that he would create things in his own mind that people did and that pretend that people like said something, they kind of— and then he would go off and score 50 points. Come to find out, the person didn't even say it. He made it up in his mind to challenge himself, to go to that upper level, to go beyond wherever he had gone before.
35:42Izar Tarandach So let me ask you something about him. When you think about it, was basketball the same before and after him?
35:50Chris Romeo He inspired others to do great. Yeah, I mean, Kobe Bryant. Kobe Bryant.
35:54Izar Tarandach Did he change Did he change basketball?
35:59Matt Coles Not the mechanics of it.
35:59Chris Romeo No, no, he didn't change the, the, the rules didn't change the game. Now, I mean, how people play basketball today is different. There's just a different, there's the, there's a, the, the, the game has changed, but I wouldn't say it was any individual person. It was the entire group of people that changed it over the course of decades.
36:22Matt Coles It was stepped up though. We're talking competitive sports here. So this is This is different from, obviously we're straying a bit from a non-competitive, stimulatory environment.
36:32Izar Tarandach Because this is where I'm pulling it to now. I could say that an expert is someone who is at a point in their understanding of the thing that they are able to advance everybody else's understanding of the thing. So if we want to step back from my thing with the isolate case and the very shared case and say, okay, no, those two could not be called experts the same way. Then my next step is to say, okay, an expert is someone who has mastered the craft to the point that they can put back something into the craft that makes the craft better.
37:13Chris Romeo Yeah, I agree. Yeah, I mean, I think in the sports example, Jordan did pushed a lot of people to become better in the, in future generations of basketball through his example and his competitive fire. Like, he did drag people along on his own team. He dragged people along that would never have been as successful as they were because he, they rode on his cape almost of, but he, he forced them to raise their game to a level that they would've never been at. And I think that's another mark of an expert is you make, if you make other, you cannot be an expert if you don't make other people better. Yeah. Like, I think we see that across the board, right?
37:54Matt Coles With esports, you know, as with, like, I'm a big gamer. I don't consider myself an expert in first-person shooters, but when I play with experts, I up my game, right? And so I think that that's, you know, that, and obviously we're, again, threat modeling is not a competitive sport. It should be. But the analogy is— well, okay, if we made it a competitive sport, and that would be a completely different episode, we should definitely do that.
38:24Izar Tarandach Yeah, I want to remind everybody that you can tune into ESPN and see competitive Excel. Yes, you can.
38:32Chris Romeo Yes, you can. Wait, what? So the idea— Yes, you can. Yeah. Hold on, pause, rewind. What are you talking about? Are you making this up? No, no, it is totally real.
38:45Matt Coles There are people who compete at Excel.
38:47Chris Romeo They had— is this like on ESPN Ocho?
38:50Matt Coles It's like an, it's a, it's an esports, it's an esport thing that people do competitive spreadsheet.
38:55Chris Romeo So they give like a challenge of like, create a formula that can calculate pi and then divide it by income tax.
39:03Matt Coles Yep. Massive mail merges by hand.
39:06Izar Tarandach You know, it's just, um, So if you go, if you go into the site of the Financial Modeling World Cup. No way. You will see that Excel esports is an actual league thing.
39:20Chris Romeo Okay. Financial Modeling League. What was it? Financial Modeling. smworldcup.com. Financial Modeling World Cup.
39:29Matt Coles I can honestly tell you it is the most boring esport ever.
39:34Chris Romeo Whoa, $25,000 prize. We're in. We're starting the team. You have got to be kidding me. Sign up for the season.
39:41Izar Tarandach Can you be— So this is the early December 2024. It's going to be the finals. Okay. At the HyperX Arena in Las Vegas. So if you have insomnia, this is for you.
39:56Matt Coles Or Boris, you're, or if you're, you're just super into spreadsheets.
40:01Chris Romeo And remember, you can get a jersey from the Excel Esports jersey. Like you can wear your jersey.
40:10Izar Tarandach Speaking of which, before we close this episode, I want Matt to model the t-shirt.
40:17Chris Romeo Well, please do.
40:20Izar Tarandach Yeah, the back, the back, the back.
40:22Matt Coles Oh my God, I'm going to try and turn around here without falling over. The back, the back.
40:27Izar Tarandach There you go. Welcome to the Security Table Podcast t-shirt, official, soon at a merch site near you. Sold only in Australia and in any gym close to you. And this is—
40:41Matt Coles wait, wait, the people who listen to our show go to the gym? What? One of them does.
40:46Izar Tarandach We know about the one that screams at us in the gym.
40:50Chris Romeo All right, well, I think it's time to draw this. This very odd, strange conversation to a close. I think it was fun to— it's always fun to think about a concept like expert because it's such a loaded term and there is so much depth to it. So I think it was fun and I think we just scratched the surface. There's likely a lot more we could unpack to define what makes somebody an expert.
41:15Izar Tarandach For what it's worth, I consider both of you experts.
41:18Matt Coles Well, thank you. I think you are an expert too, Atar.
41:22Izar Tarandach Yeah, but I'm looking for an island somewhere to go be an expert there.
41:26Chris Romeo Yeah. I mean, I would just— You have to be an expert at least two so you can tell others, right?
41:31Matt Coles That way you can—
41:32Chris Romeo Oh yeah, that's important. To close, I think you guys are like pretty okay at threat modeling. I'll take that.
41:38Matt Coles I'll up my game next time. I'm just kidding.
41:42Chris Romeo You guys have written the book. I mean, we didn't even get into writing a book as part of demonstrating expertise. I mean, you guys are— Or she built the mother's forward, right?
41:51Matt Coles Or inventing a new methodology or whatever, right?
41:54Chris Romeo So, yeah. But the book is— a book is such a big undertaking. As you guys— I don't even really know the depths you guys do. You've lived it and gone through it. But speaking of which, we should go right on. All right. Well, hey folks, thanks for listening in to this episode of the Security Table. Entitled Expert or Historian? Question mark.
42:18Matt Coles World Cup of Threat Modeling coming soon.
42:20Chris Romeo And the World Cup of Threat Modeling coming soon. Get your jerseys at Izar Tarandash's Shopify site.
42:27Izar Tarandach No, I think that Chris, you should call the next— is this next week, the threat modeling?
42:35Chris Romeo I think a couple weeks. Yeah, a few weeks from now.
42:37Izar Tarandach You should call it the World Threat Modeling Cup. There you go.
42:40Chris Romeo I'm doing that. I was actually joking about the fact that EBIS Excel Esports was on ESPN 8, the Ocho. This has got to be a spoof. You guys are messing with me.
42:50Matt Coles No, it's totally real.
42:51Izar Tarandach No, no, it definitely is.
42:52Chris Romeo I see. You guys are messing with me. Yeah. There's a little thing at the bottom that says Excel Esports ESPN 8, the Ocho. Okay, so listen, I was— Which was from dodgeball.
43:02Izar Tarandach No, wait, wait. I was in a hotel. I went for— it wasn't a conference. It was some work thing. I, I flew in, I got to the hotel, I dropped my things, I turned on the TV, it went straight into the ESPN. And as soon as the commercials went out, there was a spreadsheet in front of me.
43:19Matt Coles I, I didn't see it on ESPN. I saw it on like, uh, G4 or something like that where they do, they do esports and BattleBots and whatnot.
43:26Chris Romeo This is actually real.
43:28Matt Coles And I have, and I have a wit, and I have a witness.
43:30Chris Romeo I'm watching a video of somebody doing this. I bought it from the, and I have a witness watching it.
43:33Izar Tarandach I thought you guys were messing. That was actually real. I think that he just, uh, we just threw his Monday out of the state.
43:40Chris Romeo I'm gonna watch this. I'm watching that. It's an hour-long competition. I'm like, yeah, go get 'em. Put a look up. X, look up. Come on, you got this. All right, with that folks, we're gonna, we're gonna wrap up this episode. See you later. We have to.
Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.
Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.
