46 minSeason 1, episode 37

Looking Back, Looking Forward

With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles

Teams, careers & security culture

Join Izar, Matt, and Chris in a broad discussion covering the dynamics of the security community, the evolving role of technology, and the profound impact of social media on our lives. As the trio considers what they are most thankful for in security, they navigate a series of topics that blend professional insights with personal experiences, offering a unique perspective on how these elements intersect in the modern world.

Episode title image: Looking Back, Looking Forward

Listen to the conversation

About this episode

Join Izar, Matt, and Chris in a broad discussion covering the dynamics of the security community, the evolving role of technology, and the profound impact of social media on our lives. As the trio considers what they are most thankful for in security, they navigate a series of topics that blend professional insights with personal experiences, offering a unique perspective on how these elements intersect in the modern world.

Chris begins by highlighting the importance of collaboration and learning within the ever-expanding security community. Shifting to broader security concerns, Izar emphasizes the value of mentoring and the potential for institutionalizing it through platforms like OWASP. Matt critiques over-relying on AI. He advocates for tool-assisted solutions rather than tool-performed ones and stresses the importance of accurately representing AI's capabilities.

In a particularly engaging segment, the panelists explore the influence of social media and technology on personal well-being. They share anecdotes and observations on the pursuit of simplicity in a tech-driven world, discussing the concept of 'social media sobriety' and social media's impact on happiness. They conclude with a collective call to action, urging viewers to engage in positive change through volunteering, mentoring, and contributing to open-source projects. This discussion is a must-watch for anyone interested in the intersection of technology, security, and societal trends.

Follow AI Security Table:

➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/

➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable

➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/

➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable

Transcript · 46 min conversation

0:10Chris Romeo we can get into that. So, hey folks, welcome to this episode of The Security Table. This is Chris Romeo joined by Matt Coles and Izar is now only literally using one, his first name on anything. Um, his, the previous episode has gone to his head and he doesn't even put his last name into things anymore. Like if you don't know who he is, then that's on you is kind of his,

0:32Izar Tarandach Look, when you have a name like mine, all you need is a first name.

0:36Chris Romeo That's true. That's true. I wish I had the same

0:38Matt Coles Just remember if you have any IT calls, you know who to

0:41Izar Tarandach Don't call me!

0:44Chris Romeo Come on, it's the holiday season and that's when all of our relatives liked us to fix their, their computers, their smartphones, their TVs, their tablets, anything that's connected to the internet.

0:54Izar Tarandach And that's why I have a t shirt that says, No, I don't do Windows.

0:59Matt Coles You know you'll find that one, that one relative who has, you know, something strange.

1:05Chris Romeo Yeah,

1:05Izar Tarandach My relatives, all of them, have something strange.

1:10Chris Romeo Oh, that's fun. That's fun. You mentioned right

1:13Matt Coles can you fix my 68000 series Mac? Come on.

1:16Chris Romeo Sheldon

1:16Izar Tarandach it goes like this, Oh, wait, you work in computers, right? Yeah, you have a degree in computer science, right? Yeah, so listen, you're gonna help me with this. Excel. I open it and I have this strange, like, stare that I do when they say that, where very quick they stop asking and just move away. So... No, I'm just like looking at the horizon with the 100 windows stare.

1:49Chris Romeo I'll say you're doing the Elon Musk thing. Apparently Elon Musk does that where he'll go into like a trance for a while. And then as people are talking to him and eventually they'll just stop talking and then he'll kind of like finish thinking about whatever he's solving and then he'll come back to the conversation.

2:03Izar Tarandach Yeah, exactly that, minus the solving thing,

2:08Matt Coles You know with the, with the, you know with the Neuralink, you know with the Neuralink chip he's just, you know, organizing his threads.

2:16Izar Tarandach He's running garbage collection!

2:19Chris Romeo Hey, I'm, uh, that's probably true. I'm just, I'm almost finished with, uh, Isaacson's book on Elon Musk, which is the latest. And it's fascinating. Like, I'm, I'm learning so many, so many things about how to be a good leader. Like fire people during a meeting if you don't like how they,

2:36Izar Tarandach Oh, by the way, you're fired.

2:38Chris Romeo yeah, if you don't like how their response is, just immediately fire them in the middle of the meeting in front of everyone else.

2:43Matt Coles The firings will continue until morale improves, right?

2:46Chris Romeo yeah,

2:47Izar Tarandach Immediately what came up.

2:49Chris Romeo yeah, I mean, he gets, he gets stuff done though. You know, he's got a lot of successful companies, but that's not why we're here.

2:55Izar Tarandach Yeah, just be happy we don't have SCSI cables anymore.

2:58Chris Romeo uh, you don't have those? I need to upgrade my stuff then.

3:01Matt Coles And if, uh, you know, if Elon is listening, you know, maybe we need a new guest on the show.

3:06Chris Romeo Yeah, come on. You're always welcome, Elon. You can connect over Neuralink from your, your Tesla, from a spaceship, or from Twitter, I guess. VX, or 2X,

3:16Izar Tarandach no.

3:17Chris Romeo is. Oh,

3:18Izar Tarandach Oh, it's gonna be a blast.

3:21Chris Romeo That'd be fun. Alright, well, we wanted to have a little holiday episode, which we all wore our most festive holiday gear that we could find, which is basically the same thing we would wear to a holiday party, or a Thanksgiving gathering here in the United States. We probably would literally be wearing the same thing that we

3:42Izar Tarandach Not true, I got long pants.

3:44Chris Romeo Okay. All right. All right. Well, that's, yeah, that's, that's good. Please wear long pants to holiday gatherings. Uh, but we wanted to start our conversation here today, because, you know, we're close to American Thanksgiving, with, let's all share something we're thankful for. I'm going to say in security. I'm gonna make it broader than AppSec. I wanted, I wanted to focus this in on AppSec, but I'm like, eh, let's, let's take the, take the AppSec blinders off, or whatever illustration you can think of that would constrain us to that. If you have something wittier yourself, feel free to insert that into your mind now as you're thinking. Um, but, so what are we, like, what are we thankful for

4:25Chris Romeo in the world of security? So, who wants to go first? Because I'm

4:28Matt Coles Why don't you go first,

4:29Chris Romeo I'm thankful for nothing, so that was easy.

4:33Izar Tarandach Not true, not true.

4:35Chris Romeo okay, alright, I'll go first. I'm going to take the one side. You guys making me go first? Guess what? You guys are going to be really upset because I'm going to take one that you want to share. I am thankful for a community that the two of us... three of us are all a part of that includes the likes of Brooke Schoenfeld and Kim Vutz and Adam Shostak and Avi Duglin and Siva Diller Snyder and many other friends of ours that we're, uh, that are our threat modeling besties is the best way I can think of to describe them. So I am thankful for that community. Uh, it's made going to conferences such a fun experience now when I know that some of those folks are going to be there, some of you are going

5:16Chris Romeo to be there, and we get to hang out and talk, and, uh, and so that's, that's something, and I think that's something that, that, it's, other people can replicate that too, like it's, yes, the, the, the group that we have, Joined up with is a special group, but other people can do the same thing. You know, it's not, it's not, there's nothing special about, we didn't, we're not like some great people at making groups or whatever. Um, but it's good to, it's good to have community inside of our, of our organizations and inside of our, our jobs and, and professional careers, right? Cause this can be a pretty lonely environment if you don't have some community to lean into and some people to tell you

5:55Chris Romeo when you're full of it and stuff like that. So there, I took the one.

5:59Matt Coles Yeah, I want to take that a step further than Chris, so just a different, different angle on, or not a different angle, but a different area for that. So I've had an opportunity to work over the many years, uh, oh my god, decades now of doing security of some sort. And I haven't had the pleasure of working with so many interested and interesting people. Talk about community, but talking about really, uh, people who want to share their experiences and share their knowledge. And I'm talking about folks in standards bodies. So whether that's, uh, something like OWASP, you know, a community initiative, or something, you know, uh, where you have to, you know, pay to get in, or, uh, or whatever, or

6:43Matt Coles they're making, you know, fancy, uh, fancy documents and specifications and, and whatnot for the industry to follow, the folks who define those things, uh, spend countless hours And I'm thinking, you know, more recently of like CVSS v.4, for instance, with our, with the launch of, of v.4, the dozens of people who are involved in making that happen, writing documentation, sharing ideas, putting their brain power at work to help the industry at large. Uh, I am, I will say I'm thankful that we don't have to figure this out for ourselves and that we have an opportunity to share amongst our, amongst the members of the, of the community, the security community, to make us. all be more effective and

7:23Matt Coles efficient and capable in the work that we do.

7:29Chris Romeo He's already had a lot of time to, to ponder here,

7:31Izar Tarandach Yeah, so I had to quick pivot here. And I am very thankful for SBOM and DAST. AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

7:41Chris Romeo podcast. Thank you, folks. This

7:44Izar Tarandach WAIT! WAIT! WAIT! There is more! There is more!

7:46Matt Coles wait, oh wait, Izar's video seems to be hung. There's a...

7:50Chris Romeo Yeah, that's right. He's just been kicked out of the call.

7:52Izar Tarandach There's more, there's more. No, uh, I'm actually very, very, very, uh, thankful to them because they gave us so much to talk about, right?

8:02Chris Romeo Ah.

8:05Izar Tarandach And he saves! So, but actually, I, I, I, my original one. I wanted to build a bit on what both of you brought up, and I, I think that it's not random that the Three of us immediately jumped to community because in joint ways and in separate ways we have had so many amazing experiences this last year and a bit before but the one thing that I am really really really thankful in terms of security is, in terms of community, is that, and especially outside, beyond the realm of AppSec. I think that in a ways we have shared that label of a security that eats its own, of a community that eats its own.

8:55Chris Romeo Hmm.

8:56Izar Tarandach I think that we used to be very insular, very closed, we used to be very unwelcoming of new people, and we used to be very, if you don't understand, then go away, I don't want to talk to you. And I think that we have, we have matured past that, and I'm very thankful for that. And the reason I am thankful is that first it gives me an opportunity to do something that I really, really enjoy, which is mentoring other people. So people feel that they can come up to us and say, Hey, I want to learn some of the stuff that you know, could you spend some time with me? And on the other hand, it gives me plenty of opportunity to say, I don't know, and there are people who know, and I can go to them and

9:39Izar Tarandach learn from them. I think that a couple of years ago that wouldn't be as much of a given, but as I said, I think that we matured past that and that security got so big and so important and finally we got this place perhaps at the children's table so far, uh, we are not the dog coming under the table and asking for a bit of the, of the turkey anymore. So, yeah, I'm thankful for that.

10:11Chris Romeo Hmm. Yeah, that's a good, uh, that's a good assessment. Because I remember... You know, being around security, I've been in this for 26 years, so, you know, pre Twitter, pre Infosec drama, and all the things. And, I don't know if, maybe it's the AppSec community has, has formed a sub group of people that are just nicer to each other. And, but I can't think of, and maybe I'm insulated from this, but I can't think of any major AppSec drama in the last year. Of something where I was like... There is a big disagreement between people in the community, and I know it's happened in the past, right? Human beings are, are, are what we are, and we're gonna, we're not gonna all get along with everybody

10:59Chris Romeo along the way, but I, yeah, I think this has been a really good year of just being open minded towards people, and, and being willing to mentor, and like, Jenkin does this Mentoring

11:13Izar Tarandach what I was thinking,

11:14Chris Romeo Yeah, Tanya does this Mentoring Monday thing where she's always looking to connect people and and find somebody who needs mentoring with somebody who's willing to mentor. And you know, this is something that all of us that have been around for a while, we gotta, we gotta do more of this. We gotta continue to embrace this idea of building the next generation because You know, I'm looking at 26 years and like, am I going to do this for 26 more years? I don't think so. Like we gotta, we gotta bring some more people. And that's why I've been pushing our industry too. Like let's push some of the boundaries of things people believe and see if we can get people to think about these things. And, and

11:49Chris Romeo instead of just going, well, we just, this is how, this is how you do DevSecOps. You just always have DAST somehow in your

11:55Izar Tarandach Yeah, but, you know, and don't forget to generate an SBOM by hand. But, with the values and the address for delivery. But if you don't know what I'm talking about, you have to watch the previous episodes. You're not into the inside jokes, come on, get up to it. But anyway, uh, about mentoring, first of all...

12:13Matt Coles right?

12:14Izar Tarandach Right. So, uh, about the mentoring, definitely the first thing that comes to mind is Tanya's efforts, which are definitely laudable, but on an institutionalized level thing, and I'm doing air quotes for whomever is not watching, My plan, and something that I would love to have the opportunity to push forward, was to involve OWASP in that. And, as part of the making it bigger for the, uh, for the membership, to create some form of system where people could, almost an eBay for mentorship. Hey, here's what I'm willing to mentor on, and here's what I'm looking for, and cross those two sets of people. So, yeah, if anybody out there... Loves to write this kind of systems and would like to to get that

13:05Izar Tarandach going. Please. Let me know.

13:07Chris Romeo Yeah. It's a mentoring marketplace is what you're looking for.

13:16Izar Tarandach Okay Where else are we going?

13:17Chris Romeo No, Matt thought Matt was going to say something. Matt was looking like he was going to say

13:20Matt Coles I, I, you know, the only thing I was going to add was really was that it really has been, I think, since the pandemic, right? Pandemic changed a lot of people's outlooks on things. And since then, the flame wars in public, uh, you know, drag out fights around, you know, my opinion versus my opinion, uh, is, is, I think is, at least in the circles we've been involved with, uh, right? People are much more willing to debate, to discuss, to share ideas, to, to mentor, uh, or to be mentored. Uh, oh,

13:57Izar Tarandach You haven't been to Reddit lately, huh? No, no, I kid I kid. It's much better.

14:03Matt Coles it is much better, it is, well, it is different, and we're not talking, there's certain platforms I suppose that you could go to that, uh,

14:11Izar Tarandach if you're going to 4chan to get your AppSec

14:14Matt Coles or,

14:15Izar Tarandach you're in the wrong place

14:16Matt Coles or, or, oh well, I don't, I'm not on, I don't do X, I don't do X anymore, um, but, uh, you know, and, and I think Mastodon's a ghost town at this point

14:27Izar Tarandach Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, I have to parse this one. When you say I don't do X anymore, you mean X,

14:34Matt Coles that thing

14:34Izar Tarandach known as Twitter.

14:35Matt Coles Yeah, the thing formally known as

14:36Chris Romeo Solve for X, solve for X, please.

14:39Izar Tarandach good, good, good, because otherwise we would have to have some EDM around here, and some lights blowing, and stuff.

14:45Matt Coles ha.

14:46Chris Romeo different kind of X.

14:47Izar Tarandach Yeah, and see if we can get Matt in the thing again.

14:50Chris Romeo Yeah. I'm, I'm definitely not thankful for Mastodon because I never figured it out. I'm like, I consider myself to be mildly intelligent and I just don't get this. Like, why don't things connect to each other? Like, why do I say it's one thing here and it doesn't get over there? Like, what's happening here?

15:06Izar Tarandach Yeah, so I feel like Mastodon just got like, in a block of ice somewhere, and it's waiting for global warming to make something happen, and perhaps there's a movie there, I don't know.

15:19Matt Coles Maybe, I mean, we're, yeah, we are, we are older. We were older white guys with glasses and until recently all had beards, and I'm sure we can't figure out this distributed computing thing called Mastodon, uh,

15:34Izar Tarandach I got my login working, I just don't get to get there. Hahahaha Infosec. exchange

15:42Chris Romeo There's the problem. I shouldn't, we shouldn't have to define it, but you know, that's, that's neither here nor

15:47Izar Tarandach Hey, Yotsim,

15:48Chris Romeo we're, we're

15:48Izar Tarandach it's just your email, right?

15:51Chris Romeo Yeah, I mean, I would say I'm thankful also for this podcast, the experience

15:54Izar Tarandach Oh yeah,

15:55Chris Romeo in just, it's, it's been fun to just riff on things,

15:59Izar Tarandach high point of my

16:00Chris Romeo all right, I'm gonna let our audience in on a little bit of, a little bit of behind the scenes here on the security table, so get ready.

16:06Izar Tarandach Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Thanks.

16:08Matt Coles wait, under the table. This is under the table

16:10Izar Tarandach This is

16:10Chris Romeo under the table? Okay, under the security table. This is a special episode. We are under the security table. Yeah, he started disappearing on the video feed. Under the security table. Whoops, I managed to lose a headphone. I was laughing so hard. Um, but the, yeah, I mean, the, the, under the security table. We don't have, listen folks, we don't have any budget for special effects either. I

16:34Izar Tarandach No, notice that the only camera that's not following anybody is yours, which is supposed to follow you.

16:40Chris Romeo AI camera that's supposed to be following. Just to let folks in on a little bit of secret here, like, we don't actually prepare a whole lot before we start recording. So, but it's been fun!

16:54Izar Tarandach Or at all.

16:56Chris Romeo we often have a topic that

16:58Matt Coles is, this is my preparation for, this is my preparation for today.

17:01Chris Romeo what's good. That's cool. You did more than I did. I'm just freestyling, but it's been fun.

17:05Izar Tarandach the security riff.

17:07Chris Romeo Yeah, but it's been fun to just explore topics and just talk about them in a recorded

17:13Matt Coles Oh, oh, by the way, something else for our guests to know, we usually choose the topic either the day of,

17:20Izar Tarandach Or 15 minutes

17:21Matt Coles moments before the episode,

17:24Izar Tarandach Or, even worse, 15 minutes after.

17:27Chris Romeo after we, after we start recording. Now, we often have a discussion before we hit record to

17:33Matt Coles and

17:33Izar Tarandach sometimes is better than the podcast

17:35Matt Coles always complain that we don't hit record early,

17:37Chris Romeo yeah, I try to hit record as soon as I possibly can. We can always edit out anything crazy anybody

17:43Izar Tarandach So, now, we were planning to go with, uh, What was the next one? Things that we

17:50Chris Romeo So this was holiday gifts. So two holiday gifts that you would like the AppSec industry. to give you.

17:58Izar Tarandach yes, and I'm going to add to that one. Things that you want to be thankful for next year.

18:04Matt Coles oh, now yeah, you're upping the ante,

18:07Chris Romeo Come on, I was trying to sell this like it wasn't a prediction by calling it a holiday gift. And

18:12Izar Tarandach not a prediction, it's a request.

18:14Matt Coles So, so let me throw, let me throw a different alternative for you since it is the season of the holidays. We just said what we're thankful for, for Thanksgiving. We're going to talk about what gifts we want, uh, for the holidays from a security standpoint. Let's consider New Year's and what should be somebody's New Year's resolution around AppSec.

18:37Chris Romeo Oh ho

18:38Izar Tarandach I would not try to threat model with ChatGPT.

18:44Chris Romeo The glo Dude, you just dropped the gloves right off the start. The game started and the gloves were off and Izar's like, Let's go. It's go time. Start swinging. Wow. Okay, let's go back to the uh, let's push those New Year's resolutions a little bit. down here, down the, the, uh, the agenda. And let's, let's, let's explore this, this holiday gift giving extravaganza. So Matt, we're going to, since you appeared to have a sticky note where you had prepared some thoughts, I'm going to

19:16Matt Coles I didn't, if I didn't, I'd be, I would just be sitting here like Stuck,

19:21Chris Romeo Oh, look at Izar has literally 50. Blank sticky notes that he's attempting to make us think he's prepared. So Matt, what do you got? Like, what, what's your, like, what, what's the gift you would like the AppSec industry to give you

19:34Matt Coles right, I'm going to start with, I'm going to start with a lame one. I have, I have a couple ideas, but I'm going to start with a lame one. Um, although I, I think Izar may have already stolen it. Remember that hu I want the AppSec industry to remember that humans are part of the AppSec process.

19:50Izar Tarandach god, yeah.

19:51Chris Romeo Hmm. Interesting.

19:52Matt Coles want, I want, I want, I want tools that do their job, but I want them to know that there are humans at the other end, that we cannot automate away, as much as I love automation, and don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan of automation, but... There are humans in this process, and I realize this now over many years and working with people and even more recently from actually from the Threat Modeling Con conference and talking to people doing threat modeling. Uh, that, you know, humans are part of this process. We can't automate everybody away. And, uh, my fear is with the, with the push to AI to replace humans, uh, that we'll move to tool performed, not tool assisted.

20:44Izar Tarandach Remember

20:45Matt Coles that's my wish. That's my wish that people remember there's humans in this process.

20:48Izar Tarandach Remember when we had the t shirt go away or I will

20:53Matt Coles Replace you with a very small shell script, yes.

20:56Izar Tarandach now it's go away or I'll replace you with a very short prompt. And

21:02Chris Romeo mini AI things that would, the chat GPT, uh, what do they call it? The, the things you can build now, the mini versions.

21:09Izar Tarandach what, what,

21:10Matt Coles Mini LLMs.

21:12Izar Tarandach what makes me very afraid is that I think that the industry jumped Matt's request rather than invest into recognizing that there are people in there. The brunt of the investment now is into taking people away from there. by putting all these mini AIs and whatnot. And going back to that New Year's resolution, and something that we have addressed in previous episodes, people, these things, seriously, they're like an army of monkeys randomly typing on a typewriter, but at the same time throwing a coin up and down to see what's the probable next word. So please don't, don't, don't say that they have superhuman capabilities of inference and Cognizance, and that they are able to do all the things that

22:02Izar Tarandach we should, that we are not able to do much better than we ever will. Because that is not how it works,

22:09Chris Romeo Sounds like you're like, sound like a marketing person now.

22:12Izar Tarandach Right?

22:12Chris Romeo I want to buy whatever, whatever you're selling here. I'm buying man, inference engines. And so that, that leads me to mine though. Let me, let me get, let me tee up my, the gift I would like from the AppSec industry, because it plays into what you just said with that marketing strewn thing.

22:27Izar Tarandach the marketing stuff!

22:28Chris Romeo I would like marketing, AppSec marketing, just to stop saying stupid things. Okay. Am I asking too much?

22:35Matt Coles Can you give us an example there of

22:37Chris Romeo I have, I have a whole bunch of examples, actually, if you would like the, uh, the make

22:41Matt Coles what's your top two? What's your top two?

22:44Chris Romeo MakeShiftHappen is, is a, this is a prominent company that, that this is their, their go to market campaign across LinkedIn and many other places. MakeShiftHappen. So I have so many problems with this. First of all, as a sensible startup founder, I'm never going to put I'm not going to put a cuss word into the, a place where a cuss word began its life, I'm not going to use a substitutionary word into that because I just, it's just not, it's just, I don't know, it's just not very high class to do that to me. And like my company, my brand stands for something like, and it's, it's not, I don't want people to think of it in that regard. So makeshift happen, um, was one of them. I saw another one

23:30Chris Romeo that, um.

23:32Izar Tarandach Do Epic Shift!

23:34Chris Romeo Well, this is my, uh, move AppSec forward campaign for 2024. Don't shift left, move AppSec forward,

23:41Izar Tarandach Oh,

23:42Chris Romeo not about, it's not about shifting, but that's, we'll save that for another episode in the future. But let me, let me see another one of the examples that I had was, um, well, it was something to the effect of, you know, something about, uh, using AI to revolutionize AppSec or something like that was the, and like, to your point there, Izar, like, it's not really possible right now. Like, you can't revolutionize anything with AI. Yeah, in a couple of years, as this, these things continue to get better and better. Okay, then we can talk about replacing the human thought process or whatever, but that's not what Gen AI does right now. It does, it's not like it's sitting there thinking, going, Ooh,

24:17Chris Romeo I got a new idea. Let's roll this thing out. It's pattern matching. It's, it's guessing the next word that it needs to reply back to you with. Based on all the other words and things that has ever been written that it's been able to analyze and put together. And so, yeah, that's the gift. I would like those. I would like marketing. Just represent your product for what it does and leave shift left behind. Let's just, let's just make that a 2023 thing. Let's start fresh in 2024. Let's just stop shifting left. Just find something else to say. It's such a tired phrase. Remember when Wired used to have the wired and tired? If you

24:50Izar Tarandach Oh yeah, oh yeah,

24:52Chris Romeo like, shift left is tired, leave it, find something else.

24:58Izar Tarandach okay. The gift that I would like to be given. It actually connects to what Matt stopped doing, the, uh, the X thing, but not the former Twitter thing. I want us to take a page out of GenAI, and we should start doing something that GenAI does so well. Can you guess what? I want people to start hallucinating. I want people to start getting bored, because that's where the best ideas come from. We are all inside the box right now. We are being fed thing over thing over thing in our echo chambers of Twitter and X and whatnot or LinkedIn or whatnot and we are being told that this is the next thing and that here are the millions and that this is what the VCs are looking for and that this is the shift

25:56Izar Tarandach that's going to take our industry to the next level. And a lot of people that have a lot of capabilities and a lot of talents are just sitting and consuming all that stuff. I want people to stop hallucinating again. I want people to stop getting bored again. And I want people to say, that's not what I want. I'm going to do one better. I'm going to do one, one stronger.

26:19Chris Romeo make something better. So you want people to take the red pill.

26:23Izar Tarandach Um, no, no. I want people to just, you know, once you, you challenged us to, to shift the paradigm. from the scan cycle and all that. I want people to step up to that kind of challenge. I want people to not look at that and say, well, that's how we ever did it and it works, and it's an industry that's worth billions and billions of dollars, so probably something is right here. I want people to say, no, we can do it differently. And I want to see what they come up with.

26:53Chris Romeo So think differently.

26:54Izar Tarandach Yeah, don't be afraid of hallucinating, of asking how cool would it be if...

27:01Chris Romeo I'm gonna say, when you first got halfway through that sentence and you were prescribing hallucinations, I didn't know where you were going. I was a little bit concerned for a second, I'm like, Is he gonna recommend like peyote experiences in the desert? To kind of unlock our thinking. We're

27:18Matt Coles LSD

27:18Chris Romeo I didn't know where you were going there.

27:19Matt Coles for your TLC, uh, for your TLS.

27:22Izar Tarandach So,

27:23Matt Coles even say it right.

27:27Izar Tarandach so, okay, so, so, so disclaimer here, like public disclaimer, I am such a coward for that kind of thing that I don't think that I would ever get it there. Even though we keep hearing about this micro dosing thing coming from San Jose and where not, but no, I don't think that I would, that I would go there. I think that what I really want is for people to be bored, to not always be fed by something else that tells them how to think. And once they get there, to step out and think differently.

27:58Chris Romeo Well, you're describing a cultural problem

28:00Izar Tarandach Yep.

28:00Chris Romeo are that were I mean it is a it's an epidemic what you just described It's an

28:05Izar Tarandach We are limiting ourselves.

28:07Chris Romeo of a lack of thinking people are such consumers now of information Like I I don't know about you. I haven't watched the news in probably 20 years. I don't watch the news Because the news doesn't tell me anything good. The news is about telling me all the bad things that are happening. And so I just don't watch it because I don't want to constantly be thinking about the sky's falling because they spend a lot of time saying the sky is falling. Yes, there are problems that happen in the world and they're reporting on those. But a lot of times the 24 hour news cycle creates this thing where they're just trying to find something to make people panicked about or worried about. And so I just said, I'm

28:44Chris Romeo just not doing it anymore. And that's the beginning of unlocking my mind is I'm not, I'm not, I don't have a thread running that's in panic mode all the time about what's going to fall out of the sky or what's going to, you know, what's, what are the, what are the things that are, I should be most, they're trying to make me scared of today.

29:02Izar Tarandach Yeah, so that touches me deep because for the past month I have been glued to the news 24x7 since October 7th. And at the same time, I have been thinking for a long time already, that what makes us good at what we do, namely threat modeling, is the fact that we have these raiders that are constantly looking for what could go wrong. And me myself, speaking only for myself, I, for a long time now, I haven't been able to turn that off and step away from the professional realm and stop looking at what could go wrong everywhere. And I do feel that that puts me in a constant fight or flight mode. So, sometimes I get myself with less patience than I should have, or more stress, more worry than I should

29:57Izar Tarandach be. But, uh, I get what you're saying. People are... I don't think that people... What was the term that you used? People are... Limited, you said? No.

30:11Chris Romeo I can never remember what I say, so,

30:13Izar Tarandach Yeah, no, I think that what's happening now is that people have been looking at things through a paper tube,

30:21Chris Romeo mm hmm.

30:22Izar Tarandach you know, getting that tunnel vision. And what I'm challenging people to do, and what actually you challenged people to do before, is to not be afraid of stepping out of the paradigm and thinking about different ways of doing things, right? I mean, nowadays you get one person, one very smart person, coming and saying, hey, hey, hey, Connected this thing to ChatTPT and it's doing this and then you get a thousand mini me's coming out. Yeah, I connected it too. Yeah, I connected it too. And then you end up with like this huge amount of things. Or the same thing. I got a graph database doing this and that in the auto. Yeah, me too. Me too. Me too. Me too. Me too. And, uh, I don't know. It's, it's

31:02Izar Tarandach like, why, why is it so hard for us to innovate in this industry?

31:08Chris Romeo Yeah, and I'll throw out another thing, just because we're kind of on this, how would we need to change to get better, and I was just, I was looking for an episode of the Tim Ferriss podcast to remember who I heard this from, but they used the term social media sobriety to describe how long they had been away from the social media machine that, that influences us. according to an agenda, right? And it could be X, it could be Instagram, it can be LinkedIn, it could be anything, any social, Facebook, any, any social media platform has an agenda ultimately. And a lot of times it's to get you to buy something or whatever the agenda is. But this, and I can't remember for the life of me who I heard

31:50Chris Romeo say this. It's not an original thought, but just, it kind of, it kind of got me, grabbed ahold of me though, this idea of social media sobriety that you could be away from. Things and I have I'll tell you this other story because it's it's it's it's just a it's kind of a it fits into This this topic we're discussing. So I I know this kid. He's like, I don't know 21 years old or so and He carries a flip phone Do you guys know what a flip phone is? Yes you do. Of course. 'cause you're old enough to remember. That's where we all started with phones. He has a flip phone. And I asked him, I said, in this modern day and age, this is so odd to me. Like I'm a technologist. I have a new phone all the

32:33Chris Romeo time because I always wanna know what the new new things are we can do. And you know, I'm so driven by the need for the latest and greatest technologies and things. And I'm like, how do you survive without a flip phone? With a flip phone? You know what he told me? He said, I don't have social media. I don't use social media. One, it doesn't work on my phone. Which is funny when he's sending a text and he's literally hitting like 111 to make ABC and all that. But it really, it kind of grabbed a hold of me because I'm like, and you know what I told him right at that time? I said, you live a happier life than I do. I'm not kidding. Imagine a day being able to go a week and not being consumed by

33:17Chris Romeo things that you see on X or what people are saying on LinkedIn. Or a lot of people get caught in that Facebook rutt of, you know how our friends are, appear to be living such better lives than us because everybody takes a picture of their kid's smiling. Never when the kid's throwing the bowl of spaghetti at them, that never goes on the social media stream. Right? And we've kind of, we've really diverted, we've really taken a wide turn here from where we started, but this is, this is good because I think we're unpacking something that, that, uh, is meaningful. It should be meaningful to a lot of people, but yeah, that story of, of, uh, my friend James, his, his just approach to technology, I'm

33:51Chris Romeo like, he is a happier person than I am.

33:54Izar Tarandach You know what that sounds like to me? That, uh... He found the way for AppSec to off the mind because basically he's doing input validation,

34:05Chris Romeo Yeah, he is. Good

34:06Matt Coles Is he, he's in AppSec though?

34:08Chris Romeo No, no, no, no. He's not a technology, he's not a technology guy at all.

34:12Izar Tarandach Yeah, I I would I would say that that's probably very difficult to be that kind of person and be in AppSec But have you ever heard the concept of kosher phones?

34:22Chris Romeo No. Yeah.

34:23Izar Tarandach that there is a thing like that

34:25Matt Coles Phones that are phones.

34:27Izar Tarandach smartphones that are actually limited in their capabilities So that they can only access certain sites and can have certain chat apps

34:38Matt Coles So kids mode.

34:40Izar Tarandach Kids phones, but channeled to a different public. And that was always something that really, really like... I don't know. The feeling that I have is that we are participating in the biggest experiment in our history in terms of social engineering. And it has never been so clear to me as this past month. When you see a lot of, uh, uh, let's call them opinions. Let's call them very excited opinions

35:17Matt Coles We used to call them FUD. We used to call them FUD.

35:21Izar Tarandach Not even that. We,

35:22Chris Romeo it's gone to disinformation, right? Like I mean, that's a, that's a military term. Like you have in, you, disinformation is, is misleading a public for your own, for your own agenda. And I think there's a lot of that happening right

35:37Izar Tarandach disinformation, psyops, and, and whatnot. And, and as I said, I've spent the last month glued to the, to the TV. And it was the first time that I saw a commercial showing how fake news would be posted. On something that looked like WhatsApp. And the last line of the chat of the, uh, the chat is why are you sharing this? Why, why are you such an idiot? And then the, the reader just going, don't be an idiot. Check your things before you share them. And, uh, it, it just showed me how the cycle. closed, people used to sit down and read the newspaper, then they listened to the radio, then they watched the news on TV, then it was social media, now it gets everything through social media, now TV is

36:26Chris Romeo I mean, journalistic integrity is gone.

36:30Izar Tarandach Totally.

36:30Chris Romeo say it, like, I don't care if anybody sends me an Instagram, I don't care, I'll argue if anybody wants to tell me that it still exists. And so the days of the newspaper being an independent thing, that just reported the news, and there was no side from their perspective, they just reported the facts, those days are gone, unfortunately. And it plays into this whole... Like you said, I love the way you described it. It's a social engineering experiment and the population of the world are the people that are the subjects of this and people are trying to see how they can influence thinking and influence big picture things, right? But it's gone are the days when you could turn on the evening news

37:15Chris Romeo and Walter Cronkite gave you the straight shot about what was happening in the world. Like here's the facts people about what's happening

37:22Matt Coles Well, so let's, let's, let's bring this back to AppSec then. So, so, I, I am probably not alone in using social media, Reddit, and LinkedIn a lot for finding interesting or, you know, current news about Security trends, you know, the latest ransomware attacks, you know, new vulnerabilities that, or attack, you know, attack, um, scenarios that get, get identified, um, you know, advances in crypto, whatever the case may be, versus more, um, I'll say bland or, or, um, uh, you know,

38:01Izar Tarandach Inconsequential.

38:03Matt Coles well, as opposed, as opposed to more academic perhaps, or, or even more official sources, right? So like, I could look at Kev, As an

38:11Izar Tarandach Oh, yeah, yeah.

38:12Matt Coles Or I could be looking at, uh, you know, MITRE pushes out reports on a regular basis. Or even third parties who have, have integrity in their research and publication methods, right? Uh, you know, to be able to push out articles that, that I could go to, but I still look at the social media feeds. but you have to take it with a grain of salt. So I guess maybe the, in pulling it back, I wanted to ask from both of you, what are your, what are your reputable sources for security news?

38:46Izar Tarandach My main one is you, but...

38:49Chris Romeo And my main one is Izar,

38:51Matt Coles Oh, I'm doomed. We're doomed. So the industry is over. It's over. The sky is falling.

38:55Izar Tarandach No, but seriously, I like what you're talking about. And I would say that, yes, there are some there. But I think that my question here is how far ranging would it be to have a source for that kind of stuff that's not reputable and not trustable? I mean, what's the impact? How bad would it be? Because we are all a bunch of cynicals by nature, so that disrespeutable source would first have to give us something that would bring us all to the watering hole.

39:34Matt Coles Well, yeah, so let's just throw out an example there. You're on Reddit, you're looking at, you know, InfoSec or Cybersecurity and something goes, so and so was breached, 800 million records leaked. Okay,

39:48Chris Romeo I'm serious, I'm serious,

39:49Matt Coles so there's information overload on

39:51Chris Romeo I mean, we've reached the point where that problem is, I don't even, that doesn't even get my attention anymore, to be honest with you.

39:57Izar Tarandach so, I'm going to give you the Reddit point of view. The first comment is going to be a five page treatise on the theory, well, it's not a theory, it actually has been proven by I don't know who, but it has been proven, that it's actually... A team of very talented Hungarian hackers funded by Experian because it's part of their business model that if there's a breach, people are going to give the 800 million people who got impacted Experian tracking services. of their data, right? So connect the dots, man, get educated,

40:40Chris Romeo So, conspiracy theory, okay, great,

40:42Izar Tarandach So that's Reddit for you. The second comment is going to be, dude, I worked at such and such for years and I could have told you it was just an accident waiting to happen. The third one would be, but did they test their stuff? And the fourth one would be somebody saying I am a first year student and I would love to, uh, contribute to that project. Would you kindly show me how to do it?

41:10Chris Romeo The world according to Reddit, that's

41:12Izar Tarandach Right? So, but, but, but I

41:14Matt Coles you're in my feed!

41:21Izar Tarandach yeah, let's not go there, but...

41:24Chris Romeo I

41:25Matt Coles Wait, was that you?

41:28Izar Tarandach As I said, let's not go there. But anyway, the thing for me, the closing of the cycle here for me is that if we take a look at Chris's friend that's doing AppSec for the mind with his input validation. If we look at Matt's approach that, hey, we could well build a closed environment here of places that we could rely on stuff. I think that connecting a bit to my challenge of think outside the box. What could we as an AppSec community do to change the situation? Is there anything that we could do? Is there any kind of influence in products or in things that we do that we somehow could make the world a better place next year by using our super AppSec powers? Besides threat modeling all the things.

42:23Chris Romeo mean, I think there's always an opportunity for a group of leaders to get together and Come up with some idea that would move the industry forward and then ask a collection of people to get behind it and move forward with it. So it's not quite a manifesto, right? Because a manifesto is, is designed to be greenfield and last beyond just a year. Like the threat modeling manifesto is still going strong, right? We released it, how many years ago? Two years ago?

42:53Matt Coles Three, three years ago?

42:54Chris Romeo Three years. Yeah. So, I mean, yeah, I mean, it's, it's still going strong because so, but, but I think a group of people could get together, a group of leaders could get together and say, here's, here's some place, something we could change. Here's something we could do better. And then ask the community to get behind it. I think that's, that's how you influence change.

43:11Izar Tarandach But isn't that the AEI letter?

43:16Chris Romeo Letter. Well, I mean, the AI Letter was just taking a stance, right? It wasn't, it wasn't an

43:20Izar Tarandach talking about things like a moratorium and things

43:24Chris Romeo but it wasn't, it wasn't anything that anybody could get behind and actually do something. You could sign it and say, yeah, I agree with what they're saying. That's not what I'm talking about. We don't need any, we got enough letters in this, in this world. We don't need people to sign letters. We need people to take action to do, to cause some positive change, right. Based on what you're talking about. And

43:41Matt Coles Well, and what, and what, uh, and what changed? So what change do we need? Because actually my second one, it may be related to this. So my second gift was actually more of a gift idea for others. And, and so I'm not big on, I'm not big on, on, on gifts, like physical things. Um, and maybe this is just an evolution of I'm not, I'm not 12 anymore. Um, but. You know, the things are fun. Some things are fun. My wife got the, got me this for my birthday. It's a fidget spinner and I can't put it down, uh, But, um, you know, it would be,

44:24Chris Romeo Izar's got

44:25Matt Coles oh, where's my, I have, I have a few, I have a few more I could pull out. So, uh oh. Yeah, actually this, this, this, connect, this, this connects fidget spinning. And D& D because it has, it's a D20 dice roller as a spinner, which is awesome. Um, anyway, uh, but, so, as a gift idea, uh, use that extra energy when you're not looking at Reddit or, or social media feeds. And go, and go volunteer. Go volunteer your time. Go, go mentor. Go look at open source projects. Pick an open source project at random. Throw a dice, throw, throw, throw, throw a die or a, or a dart at, at GitHub and, and pick a project and go file bugs. Go find and, go find and file bugs or PRs as Izar likes to say.

45:20Izar Tarandach so

45:20Matt Coles We can, we can help improve the industry in small steps when we're trying to, while we're trying to form something bigger to solve bigger industry problems.

45:34Izar Tarandach definitely.

45:35Matt Coles And that's my, that's my, that's my peace on earth and goodwill towards men, uh, gift idea. Thank you.

45:44Chris Romeo in the, in another episode about New Year's resolutions, AppSec New Year's resolutions, but I think this is a good place to wrap up for this holiday themed edition. As you can see, once again, based on our outfits, very much holiday themed for us. Thanks folks for joining another episode of the Security Table.

Transcript supplied by Buzzsprout. It may contain transcription errors.

View the original transcript on Buzzsprout

Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.