Privateering the Cyber Seas: New Legislation on Cybercrime
With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles
We’re discussing the intriguing world of cyber privateers and the concept of 'hacking back' against cyber criminals. The discussion centers around a proposed bill in the U.S. Congress, H.R. 4988, that aims to authorize private individuals to pursue cyber criminals with the full backing of government-issued letters of marque.
About this episode
We’re discussing the intriguing world of cyber privateers and the concept of 'hacking back' against cyber criminals. The discussion centers around a proposed bill in the U.S. Congress, H.R. 4988, that aims to authorize private individuals to pursue cyber criminals with the full backing of government-issued letters of marque. We explore the historical context of privateers, the potential legal and ethical implications, and the modern-day ramifications of such measures. And debate whether bringing back this old concept could be a solution to modern cyber threats or if it opens the door to more significant risks and unintended consequences.
US bill proposes 21st-century privateers to take on cybercrime
H.R. 4988 - Scam Farms Marque and Reprisal Authorization Act of 2025
Follow AI Security Table:
➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/
➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable
➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/
➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable
Transcript · 36 min conversation
0:09Chris Romeo Good afternoon. Good morning. Good evening. Welcome to the Security Table. This is Chris Romeo, joined by Ezar Tarendasch, Matt Coles. They are, uh, turns out, constitutional scholars, which will play out in our conversation today.
0:25Matt Coles We're doomed. Doomed, I say.
0:27Chris Romeo Okay, maybe not constitutional scholars, but they're scholars and gentlemen. So that's—
0:33Izar Tarandach I just wanna know who's Bill.
0:35Chris Romeo Yeah.
0:35Matt Coles Who is Bill? Watch the video. Watch the video, will you?
0:38Chris Romeo And why does he live on Capitol Hill?
0:41Izar Tarandach Yeah.
0:43Chris Romeo Why is he singing a song at an after-school special?
0:45Izar Tarandach Remember after-school special? Why does everybody want to sign him?
0:49Chris Romeo But after— they don't have after-school specials anymore. Because kids are supposed to, I guess, go outside or something or play their Xbox.
0:55Izar Tarandach What?
0:56Chris Romeo Which was tablet.
0:56Matt Coles Oh, you know, and it's kind of funny cuz that video or, or that TV show actually happened during the time when people were going outside and, and being free.
1:05Izar Tarandach Nobody was watching it.
1:05Chris Romeo Nobody was watching it. We were, you know, it was after school special.
1:08Matt Coles Well, that explains a lot.
1:10Izar Tarandach What does outside do people keep referring to?
1:12Chris Romeo That's true. Most of our, to most of our, for most of our audience, outside is The place that, uh, you'd normally experience it when walking from your office door to your car and then from your car to your house.
1:24Izar Tarandach And then you have to turn and clean the lenses. Oh no, this is a different sci-fi thing. Yeah. Have you guys watched Sino?
1:33Chris Romeo No, not yet.
1:34Izar Tarandach Oh, it's good. It's good.
1:37Matt Coles Okay.
1:37Chris Romeo There's a, there's a long list of things. That's the problem with, with entertainment via television these days. There are so many different things. And people are always like, oh, you need to watch this. You need to watch that.
1:48Izar Tarandach No, that's not, that's not a problem with entertainment. That's a problem with work. It keeps us from going back to the TV and watching all the good things that are in there. Please.
1:59Chris Romeo And once again, coming back to that idea of outside.
2:02Izar Tarandach Oh yeah.
2:02Chris Romeo Which, wait, you did a recording of Security Table from an outside location.
2:08Matt Coles That was just a background, wasn't it? I mean, it was a virtual background.
2:12Chris Romeo It's undisclosed.
2:12Izar Tarandach I was in a, in a, undisclosed location.
2:16Chris Romeo Yeah, he was the, uh, what do they call it? The success— the person who stays under the— in the bunker.
2:22Matt Coles Survivor.
2:23Chris Romeo The other name is survivor.
2:24Izar Tarandach I was, I was setting the infrastructure for today's episode. Okay.
2:29Chris Romeo Where we going?
2:30Izar Tarandach So now disclose direction.
2:32Matt Coles Ah, okay.
2:33Chris Romeo Well, we should probably get to that, that topic before everybody hangs up the call.
2:39Izar Tarandach What, what do we do today, Pinky?
2:42Matt Coles Trying to take over the world.
2:45Chris Romeo Matt found an interesting, uh, bill in the United States Congress.
2:52Matt Coles Not a gym, you will—
2:53Chris Romeo yes, U.S. bill proposes 21st century privateers to take on cybercrime. Wow. So, and then there's a picture of Johnny Depp in this article, like an AI version of, uh, what is he, what's, uh, Jack Sparrow.
3:10Matt Coles Jack Sparrow.
3:10Chris Romeo Captain Jack Sparrow. So all of a sudden I'm starting to get on board with this idea.
3:14Matt Coles Parsnip. Parsnip. Parsnip. Parlay. That's it.
3:19Izar Tarandach Parlay.
3:21Chris Romeo So we get to be pirates, basically. Security professionals become pirates. So Arizona lawmaker David Schweiker introduced a bill called Scam Farms Mark and Reprisal Authors Act. I thought it was Marquis for a second.
3:35Izar Tarandach Marquis.
3:36Chris Romeo I don't think it is Marquis.
3:38Izar Tarandach No. No, it's, it's Mark.
3:39Matt Coles It's Mark. It's Mark.
3:40Chris Romeo It's Mark.
3:41Matt Coles Marky came from it, I think. But yeah, Mark is, Mark is how it's pronounced.
3:45Izar Tarandach So wait, we have Mark and Bill.
3:48Chris Romeo And Bill.
3:49Matt Coles And Bill.
3:49Izar Tarandach I'm just trying to keep the names.
3:51Chris Romeo Lawmaker created this bill, Scam Farms Mark and Reprisal Authorization Act of 2025, which allows state-sanctioned pirates to target cybercriminals threatening the United States. What could possibly go wrong?
4:06Izar Tarandach I was waiting for that question.
4:10Matt Coles What could possibly go wrong? Um, let's see. How did pirates turn out for us? Uh, how did privateers turn out for us for, uh, in the 1700s, 1800s?
4:21Izar Tarandach Uh, actually it came out nice.
4:24Matt Coles Well, depends on, depends on whose side you were on, I suppose.
4:28Izar Tarandach Right, right. On the side of the, the, the, the privateer. I mean, there was a lot, if I remember my history lessons correctly, there was a lot of cleaning up. And if I remember my HBO series correctly, there was a lot of adventure and hanging from chandeliers and jumping through the window and people saying savvy at the end of the sentence.
4:51Chris Romeo So, yeah. Didn't everybody get scurvy?
4:53Matt Coles Gangsters? Didn't you get scurvy?
4:57Izar Tarandach I don't think they gave overpowers. Isn't it going to be something that already hits basement dwellers anyway?
5:02Chris Romeo Um, yeah, to set this up, so the— this is based on the article from cointelegraph.com. The bill would allow the US president to issue letters of marque to privately armed and equipped persons contracted by the government, authorizing them to employ all means reasonably necessary to seize property and detain or punish cyber criminals the president deems a threat. These threats include crypto theft, pig butchering schemes, ransomware, identity theft, accessing computers without auth, gathering sensitive personal data or classified information, online password trafficking, and compromising computers with malicious code.
5:42Matt Coles Yep, the list is, uh, list in the bill is, is extensive and a little bit broad, but an interesting list. Uh, for those who are interested, this is Bill H.R. 4988. I don't know if you mentioned that.
5:58Chris Romeo Specifically, uh, it's important in case they want to read it themselves.
6:00Matt Coles In case they want to read it. It is short and it is in English apparently. So we can, it's easy for us to, to take a look at this.
6:08Izar Tarandach I have questions.
6:11Matt Coles We, we probably don't have answers, or at least not good, but we'll try.
6:15Izar Tarandach I have questions. I have questions. So it says here that, uh, issued letters of marque and reprisal. So many of privately armed and equipped persons and entities as in the judgment of the president, the service may require with suitable instructions to the leaders thereof.
6:37Matt Coles Mm-hmm.
6:39Izar Tarandach So it, it, it seems to say that you already have to be something that the government has authorized and then you get the letter of marque.
6:48Matt Coles Well, or you have to be known or, or pitch your, pitch your services to the government, right?
6:53Izar Tarandach I mean, I suppose it's right, but that there is an authorization stage there somewhere. It's not just everybody.
6:58Matt Coles Yeah.
6:59Izar Tarandach Everybody can dial 1-800, uh, letter of mark and, and become, uh, an offensive, uh, national asset. Yeah.
7:05Matt Coles And it's not clear if the president does it directly or would do it directly, or if it's through the chain of command, you know, the president authorizes it through whatever cyber service.
7:16Chris Romeo You know, oh, interesting. The US, I'm just as Chet GPT's right. I wanted to know what a letter of marque and reprisal was because I've never heard that term. But one of the things it says is the US Constitution still empowers Congress to grant letters of marque and reprisal, Article 1, Section 8, but the practice has been largely dormant since the early 19th century. So it's basically a license. It's basically a license. It's almost like James Bond. Not a license to kill, but it's a license to attack cyber criminals with all, with all anything you want without any consequences.
7:52Matt Coles I mean, it doesn't say whether it's, whether it's cyber or kinetic or social or other or financial weapons, quote unquote, right? All means necessary.
8:05Chris Romeo I don't think the bill gets that specific. It just says with any enterprise involved in cybercrime. So it doesn't say anything about.
8:12Izar Tarandach What—
8:12Chris Romeo it doesn't say anything about the tactics or techniques that the, uh, privateer would be able to employ.
8:20Matt Coles To employ all means reasonably necessary to seize outside the geographic boundaries of the United States, the person and property of any individual or foreign government who the president determines is a member of criminal enterprise.
8:33Izar Tarandach So the targets have to be outside of the jurisdiction of the United States.
8:38Matt Coles Right. But they can include foreign governments.
8:41Izar Tarandach Yeah.
8:41Chris Romeo I mean, it's, it's an interesting idea. And the reason I think of that is you guys would probably have some friends like this too, but I have, um, a couple of people that I know who used to work, uh, in Columbia, Maryland on the US East Coast, if you know what I mean. And they're some of the most dangerous people, nicest people in the world, but when you talk to them and you realize how good they are and it's frightening, but there is this whole kind of army of very highly skilled, I'll call them red team or penetration testers at this point, that are legit, right? Because if you think about that side of security, there's a lot of people who are not legit in that category, that pretend to be. But these are the people that are really dangerous. Like, they'll get into anything that you point them at. And so basically, this bill would allow those types of folks to operate on behalf of the US government to go after attackers in such a way that, you know, they could have true— they could really cause some consequences.
9:55Izar Tarandach So let's look at a couple of things.
9:57Matt Coles There.
9:57Izar Tarandach So, hey, who says they are not already? Because as we know, those who can and know do, and those who can't talk— and we hear a lot of talk.
10:10Chris Romeo Yeah, but this gets them— this basically just— they don't have, uh, protection if they're doing it right now.
10:15Izar Tarandach Says who?
10:15Chris Romeo From prosecution. Yeah, I mean, maybe it's happening behind the scenes. I mean, classified way that we'll never know.
10:21Matt Coles Well, even if I Even if, even if the government, even if the U.S. government authorizes it, but you know, just say it's their part of their normal work. Even if the U.S. government authorizes it, it doesn't mean that they're free of prosecution around the world. Right.
10:36Chris Romeo Well, this bill wouldn't give them, wouldn't keep them free of prosecution around the world either though.
10:40Matt Coles Right.
10:40Izar Tarandach I'm, I'm talking about, I'm talking out of my three-letter agency, but it's the, the, the, Most of the things that are here on the list, if I understand correctly, are under the jurisdiction of the Secret Service, right? Now, the Secret Service is closer—
10:55Chris Romeo Treasury.
10:56Matt Coles That's the Treasury Department, I believe, right?
10:58Izar Tarandach Yeah.
10:59Matt Coles Yeah.
10:59Izar Tarandach And they're closer to police than a spy agency, all in the name. So, law organization, to the best of my knowledge, and if I remember my digital forensics days back, They can deputize people. So from here to deputizing someone to having them working in an offensive capability, I don't know if there is a problem with this here, but I could imagine it's happening. And if not, that's a great premise for a TV series. You heard it here first. I've got the copyright. Stay away, Carl.
11:35Chris Romeo So, so, all right.
11:37Matt Coles So let's look back at, let's look a little bit back at history then. Right. So you had. You had the military who were authorized to take action within certain bounds, and then you had privateers who were given effectively free rein, uh, to do whatever they felt was necessary to meet the objective of whatever they were given the work for. So that's a, I, I, I think that's a similar approach here, right? Where those in the agencies are certainly given opportunities and, and are required, uh, you know, that's part of their, part of their work in defending defending the U.S. and its interests, but they're under certain restrictions, right? They operate, you know, as part of the, uh, as part of the U.S., the U.S. government. And I, I'm, and I'm just guessing, I don't know all the intricacies here, but I imagine they're under certain, have certain restrictions or boundaries, whereas a letter of marque, and as it's described here, would be able to use whatever reasonable means are necessary. It doesn't find what reasonable is.
12:41Chris Romeo That's a, well, that's a great legal term. So no, so here's the thing.
12:46Izar Tarandach Reasonable.
12:47Matt Coles And who? Yeah.
12:48Izar Tarandach I'm going to disagree with you a bit here. And I think that one of the biggest things, one of the things that separates the military and the three-letter agencies from these privateers is basically the plausible deniability, right? If it comes from an agent of the government, it's the government. It's, it's by extension, it could be the big man himself just doing it himself. It's the government. It's the United States.
13:18Matt Coles And there's, and they're subject, they're subject to the Freedom of Information Act, for instance, and all kinds of limits.
13:26Izar Tarandach If it's an individual, then no. But then you don't know if it's operating in a lawful way or in an unlawful way. On the other hand, the moment you give somebody a government document, saying, hey, I let you do this on my behalf. What that means is basically you've been deputized by the government. So I would think that you are automatically under the same limits and, and—
13:50Chris Romeo but you're out— well, no, I mean, this thing, this bill is saying there are no limits to what you can do.
13:56Izar Tarandach Well, no, he uses the reasonable thing.
13:58Chris Romeo Oh yeah, reasonable.
14:00Izar Tarandach But we, you know, let, let's look at the real elephant in the room. Somebody here watched the YouTube channel Hacking the Scammer and said, hey, that's a good idea. Let's put a viewer on that, right? Because that's basically what this is talking about. It's going on the offensive against those farms and people who engage into those things in industrial scale.
14:25Chris Romeo But yeah, this is not a new concept, right? We've been discussing and debating the whole hacking back for as long as I can remember. It probably started in the late '90s when I got into security. I remember there were people started talking about this. So not a new idea.
14:41Matt Coles Right. The best defense is a good offense kind of thing. Yeah.
14:44Izar Tarandach But the thing becomes when you talk about recovering assets, at some point, you have to have some form of authority behind you. And this is what this letter of marque might be implying. That, yeah, having this gives you some kind of authority to be able to go to people who actually have power in their hands to recover assets. Because otherwise, you're just taking down scammers and good stuff and all that. But let's say that, uh, you did something about cryptocurrency theft. What now? How do you actually recover the asset? You ask nicely and you say, I have a letter of marque.
15:23Matt Coles Hand over your hardware token, please.
15:25Izar Tarandach Yep. Which, which would take us to something that we discussed in one of our very, very first, first episodes, which is when, what happens and when do things go kinetic, right? And getting closer to a government, getting closer to military organizations and law enforcement and all that stuff. May raise the, the, the, may lower the bar before things become kinetic for all kinds of reasons. And of course it all depends on how much are you going to recover. And these people are going to have high incentives to invest money and time into recovering assets because that's how they're going to make their money. And the government is going to get a portion and these guys are going to get, get a portion. And all of a sudden, what do you have? What's the name of those, uh, companies? Private military, PMCs, private military contractors.
16:20Matt Coles Mercenaries.
16:21Izar Tarandach So, yeah. So basically, so now we're going to have those in the cyber realm and, um, don't they already exist?
16:31Matt Coles I mean, really, do you have the, I mean, do you have the A-Team already out in cyber world?
16:38Chris Romeo I hope so.
16:39Matt Coles Well, Although it would be the C team then, wouldn't it?
16:46Izar Tarandach Let's not go there. But, uh, yeah. So anyway, it's going to get into Hollywood reality very, very quick. But my worry is what happens when you go against, uh, some North, uh, Asian country and all of a sudden they decide to retaliate.
17:06Matt Coles Yeah. Or they go after a cartel and the cartel decides to You know, exactly, because they're not going to go after—
17:13Chris Romeo you guys are talking about this like it's not happening right now. It may be 100% sure it's happening from our side as an authorized extension of the US government. Not, not with privateers, but it's happening.
17:28Izar Tarandach It may be happening, but you're not seeing anything on the, on the evening news saying that, uh, some random room in a university dorm got targeted by an RPG because, because, you know, somebody hacked out.
17:43Matt Coles I mean, that we know of, right?
17:44Izar Tarandach I mean, no, I mean, that, that would be pretty much obvious. You would be seeing that in the news.
17:50Matt Coles But, uh, I agree.
17:52Izar Tarandach My worry is that this just opens a frontier, let's say, Pandora's box, to become Wild West, to become Wild West, right? So it's starting a weapons race, sorry, an arms race that can become kinetic very, very quickly.
18:10Chris Romeo Yeah, I get what you're saying.
18:12Matt Coles I don't know if it's Wild Wild West though. I would be careful about calling it Wild Wild West. It's not like, well, okay, so today actually you have folks like, you know, the folks who run the Scammer Payback YouTube channel, right? Who are literally taking down data centers and call centers in the, in the, in, you know, in Asia for people who, you know, for scammers who do piggybacking scams, right? For, you know, this is, this is bilking elderly people out of their life savings kind of thing, right? And so that's wild, wild west. That's people taking, taking action on their own. Yes, they have skills. Yes, they're doing it, you know, with, with, you know, Robin, not Robin Hood-ish, incentives, but, but they're doing it out of the goodness of their heart. They're volunteering their time, but there's no rules on what they're doing, right? And in fact, they're break— probably breaking international law in order to do it, right?
19:08Chris Romeo Just to give them some protections.
19:10Izar Tarandach I, I think that the way that I went to the Wild West is because of the, uh, retaliation component. You're not— I'm, I'm not seeing anything coming this guy's way. I'm, I'm sure that they have been targeted in the past and They must be under a lot of eyes, but especially with the component of possibly going kinetic very quick. The Wild West for me is the analogy because you are going to see the duo at the OK Corral in an ISP close to you.
19:43Chris Romeo Although in the Wild West, there were, there was a big movement of deputization as well.
19:48Izar Tarandach Yep.
19:49Chris Romeo So I mean, that, that the, the illustration works from that perspective in that a lot of those folks that were carrying guns and enforcing law were not trained peace officers. They were kind of sworn into action in times of trouble.
20:03Matt Coles You know the history of the Pinkertons, right?
20:07Chris Romeo Uh, no, no, but I vaguely, yeah, I need to look it up.
20:10Matt Coles Uh, actually, if you know Expedition Unknown did an episode on the Pinkertons, they were They were a lot of the law in the West.
20:19Chris Romeo Um, and I think they became Pinkerton Security.
20:22Matt Coles Yeah, they actually still exist. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Um, and so, uh, yeah, many of them were effectively privateers.
20:30Izar Tarandach Uh, those are the guys with the, the bow hats, right?
20:34Matt Coles And long guns. Yeah.
20:35Izar Tarandach Yeah.
20:35Matt Coles Yeah.
20:36Izar Tarandach So cool.
20:37Matt Coles It's, it's so cool unless you're, you know, in the way. Um, but, you know, and see, Blazing Saddles, I'm thinking about the Scammer Payback folks a little bit more. You know, what we see when they do the videos, you know, obviously we only see what they, what they curate. Um, and they're pretty open. They seem pretty honest, right? Uh, but they, they don't go after, they're not going after the cartel leaders, right? And if you want, if you see pictures of what the cartel leaders look like, or the, the, you know, the basically the paramilitary folks who are part of the cartels, at least in, in Mexico and other places, um, they're not going after those people. They're going after the, the drug mules and the, and the money mules and whatnot. And those people are usually unarmed, right? The police will take them down.
21:33Izar Tarandach Because again, you go, you go towards the things that you have the resources to deal with. Right.
21:38Matt Coles Right. But they know when they, they've reached a limit, right? They can only go so far. They're not going to go and physically get involved in many cases. I mean, they, they went and confronted somebody in a Home Depot parking lot once with a video camera, but if this is—
21:51Izar Tarandach because they don't have the resources, right?
21:52Matt Coles Yeah. If the guy had pulled out a gun, I don't know what they would have done. They probably would have—
21:55Izar Tarandach but that's the thing. The escalation goes that if you have like 4 of those call centers and they are under the, the same leadership and those guys managed to turn off those 4 call centers. The leadership's going to start looking at them as a threat and it's going to respond accordingly. And unfortunately, when the loss is big, then the investment to recover is, is big. They're going to go back kinetic.
22:22Matt Coles Sure. But they'll come back kinetic in a, in a potentially extrajudicial extrajudicial way. Did I say that right? Where they're not, um, you know, they're not doing it, they're doing it as a, they're doing it as a criminal organization and not as an arm of their government.
22:38Izar Tarandach Right. But the bullets flying don't, don't care. There will be bullets flying. You don't want to get caught into that. And I think that the last thing that we need is more bullets flying. Right.
22:47Matt Coles But so, but you're anonymous on cyberspace. So where are the bullets going to go?
22:53Izar Tarandach That's the thing. Are they going to stay in the cyberspace? I don't think so.
22:58Chris Romeo I mean, you're separated by a pretty big geographic distribution there, right? As a— if these guys are going after folks that are call centers primarily in Asia, what are those criminal organizations going to do against these folks in the United States?
23:17Matt Coles Cut undersea cables and turn off the internet?
23:20Chris Romeo Well, that happened just yesterday, so.
23:23Matt Coles Yeah.
23:24Izar Tarandach No, I mean, I mean, yeah, it's really, let's be, oh my goodness, I can't believe that I'm talking about this. So if you open the back page of Soldier of Fortune magazine, you're going to get to know people willing to do stuff for, you know.
23:39Matt Coles Wait, that's a thing? For real?
23:41Chris Romeo Yeah, Soldier of Fortune's been around for a long time. I used to read it when I was a kid. I know, but.
23:46Matt Coles It wasn't just stories?
23:48Izar Tarandach No, it's not just like that.
23:49Chris Romeo No, the classifieds. He's talking about the classifieds in the back.
23:52Izar Tarandach No, but listen, mercenaries, there, there is— my point is there's enough dumb people out there who are going to do dumb things for dumb money, right?
24:00Chris Romeo Well, we all had a bully that we wanted that we were looking at that mercenary ad going, and this bully's about to get it from Sergeant Slaughter.
24:07Izar Tarandach Oh my God.
24:09Chris Romeo Paid my $50.
24:13Izar Tarandach But anyway, so if you don't want to go sell your fortune, there's Craigslist. But you know, the point is that there's enough—
24:21Chris Romeo better, far easier sources—
24:23Izar Tarandach that there's enough dumb people who will do dumb things for dumb money. So I don't think that that geographic separation is actually not too big.
24:32Chris Romeo I got you.
24:32Matt Coles There's also no reason— there's no— I mean, there's nothing in this bill at least that says that the individuals have to even be in the U.S. or even be U.S. citizens for that matter, right? They, they might be in their own governments or in their own environments. Maybe they're trying to destabilize the government, right? Maybe they have ulterior motives. Uh, you know, interestingly, Part B of the, of Section 3 of this bill has something interesting. Um, no letter of marque or reprisal shall be issued by the president without requiring a security bond to ensure that the letter is executed as needed or according to its terms.
25:12Izar Tarandach Well, that's the funding, right?
25:14Matt Coles That's the— no, well, that's the— no, that's the posting of the bond that is posted by the individual or organization that's getting the letter of marque.
25:22Chris Romeo So they forfeit their money, like, just like a bail bond. Right. If you run, if you get bonded out by a bondsman and you run and don't show up in court, you forfeit your money.
25:32Izar Tarandach Right.
25:33Matt Coles But this is basically the, the company, the organization, the organization gets a letter of marque to go after cryptocurrency and they take off with the $15 million in crypto and not return it to the US government. They lose the bond. So hopefully the bond is large enough to balance out the, the potential loss there.
25:50Izar Tarandach Oh, okay. I, sorry, I understood this completely different. So this says that this is basically you have to make this tall to play in this playground.
25:59Matt Coles Well, you have to be able to cover the cost. I mean, they're not going to give you free rein unless you do the job that they're, you're being free reined to do. I mean, which could be recovery.
26:12Izar Tarandach So we're really talking about, we're really talking about organizations with, with pockets.
26:17Chris Romeo Yeah. So I want to, I'm going to step back for a second here before we, uh, you know, before we wrap up this episode, I want to get your all your opinions on. But if we step all the way back to offense is the best defense, a concept that's been around for a long time in security, what are your takes on that? Do you agree with the whole hacking back idea or do you think it's nonsense?
26:47Matt Coles It's poke the— I think it's, you know, to some extent, I think it's poke the bear. Right? If somebody is coming after you and attacking you, I, I wanna be careful. We know that there are different personas of attackers, right? We, we do this in our, we put this in our threat models. Who is it coming after us, right? Is it nation states? Is it activists? Is it, you know, script kiddies? Hacking, hacking back a script kiddie versus hacking back a nation state. And you may not know who the actor actually is when you're being attacked. Right? Until attribution. This is all notion of attribution. So, attribution. Yeah, attribution. Attribution is hard, right? So, that's part of the problem.
27:32Chris Romeo Yeah.
27:32Izar Tarandach So, beyond that, we are in 2025. It's the first time that I can remember that security organizations inside companies are having to justify heavily their budget. Okay, we are having to show that, yes, we are cost center, but we do have some kind of return. Do we really want to get some of that budget now and start playing Wild West? Plus, we haven't even gotten to the point where we can eradicate MySQL injection. Do we really want to start poking people around?
28:10Chris Romeo Well, right.
28:10Matt Coles So that's, I guess that's the other part, um, you know, is if we are, if, if an organization wants to take it on them, upon themselves to go on the offense, they have to recognize, they should recognize where their, where their own faults are, because it's going to be like, it's going to be like the capture the flag event at DEF CON.
28:31Izar Tarandach Yes, exactly.
28:32Matt Coles Right. And so, because in Seattle there's, so If I understand correctly, and I've, I have never been part of this event, but it's, it's sounds exciting. Uh, right. You as a team, you have a comp, you have a goal where you have to capture flags in, in the other, in the system that's provided for you, but you're able to attack your comp, the competing teams, if I understand correctly. And so your weaknesses and your defenses are going to be what keeps, you know, you're either spending your time attacking or you're spending your time defending or you're spending time getting the goal. And can you do it all really well?
29:11Izar Tarandach Look, if this becomes a thing, you can look for me in the next, uh, Black Hat. I'll be the guy in the corner selling leather jackets, uh, dark glasses, and copies of, uh, William Gibson literature. Because seriously, don't we have anything better to do?
29:28Chris Romeo I mean, I think on the principle of hacking back, I've been against this idea since its very inception in security. And primarily because to Matt's point about personas, like the nation-state, highly funded, highly skilled, you don't want to draw their attention back. Because they're good. They're— but listen, they're good. They'll— most of the time you don't even know they're there. So let's be honest, in modern enterprises across, across the world, most of the time when those people are there, you never even know they were there, and they're gone, and they clean their tracks and take the stuff they want, and you never know.
30:12Izar Tarandach That's the right and sensible way of looking at this. But now I just want to ask one question. Metrics. Nowadays in defense, okay, we already have a problem with metrics. Now what you're going to start asking you on the standup, hey Carl, how many places have you attacked today?
30:30Chris Romeo I hope that would be awesome. I might go to a standup.
30:36Matt Coles What I plan to do today is take out Taiwan. And what am I going to do tomorrow? What I did yesterday.
30:44Izar Tarandach Exactly.
30:47Chris Romeo I mean, it's, it's, it's, we're laughing about it, but with the rise of AI and the capabilities to be able to use AI tools to generate things, the world of breaking stuff just got easier than it was 5 years ago, 2 years ago, 1 year ago.
31:05Izar Tarandach It did, it did, but you know.
31:08Matt Coles Oh my God, can you think of the guardrails on, on AI agents? That would—
31:11Izar Tarandach Oh, please. Can, can, can, can't we just go back to what was the, the, the, the program, Robot Wars, and, and just have it like out in an arena. You bring your agents, I'll bring my agents, and, and whatever happens, happens.
31:25Chris Romeo They fight it out. I mean, we did have that. It's called The Matrix. Keanu, you know, battle against Agent Smith. Yeah.
31:34Izar Tarandach For some reason I'm going, I'm getting vibes of redhead in a red dress. Anyway, but no, seriously, no, no, no, this whole hacking back thing, leave it to the professionals, leave it to law enforcement, leave it to the people who are actually equipped and empowered to do these things. Because otherwise, seriously, what are we even doing here?
31:59Matt Coles You know, it's going to be a great time for defenders.
32:02Izar Tarandach No, it's not.
32:02Chris Romeo It's the golden age. No, it's not. No, it's not.
32:06Izar Tarandach No, it's not.
32:07Matt Coles Those, those people who are going on the offensive are gonna need, need good defenses.
32:11Izar Tarandach No, no, no, no, no.
32:14Matt Coles You go off, have fun storming the castle. I'm here building the castle.
32:18Izar Tarandach No, no, no. Because it's soon, as soon as attacking becomes that prevalent, what happens is people take a step back, take all of their crown jewels off of whatever is, is, is even like able to be reached and then just let the kids attack each other and have fun and, and back and forth.
32:35Chris Romeo You couldn't do that in this, in this day and age. An airline's gonna take off, take away their online booking system.
32:42Izar Tarandach That's what, 75% of their business. You mean that they work on it? Perhaps that's the way, perhaps that's the way that we get, get jobs back. We're going to get, we get travel agents because they'll have to actually call people. Who on their phone will have to pick that phone up.
32:58Chris Romeo Yeah, I can see, I can see you doing call phone support, you know, or like I'm trying to book a trip and you're like, that's the stupidest place I could, you could go. I just want a ticket to Atlanta.
33:11Izar Tarandach Yeah. Well, but I'm going to complain anyway.
33:14Matt Coles Wait, you, you could go, you could totally threat model that. I want to, I want to take it to Atlanta. What could possibly go wrong?
33:22Izar Tarandach Now I would start with why Atlanta, but fine. Yeah.
33:25Chris Romeo What a business idea. Threat modeling on the phone. You call in and someone's like, what are you working on, Isar?
33:34Izar Tarandach You know that that's very, very, very dangerously close to what are you wearing? So what money—
33:41Chris Romeo What's that question?
33:43Izar Tarandach That's something I should ask. When I change the threat modeling. Slowly apply my controls. So that's the fifth question.
33:50Chris Romeo That's the fifth question now that you've added to the—
33:53Izar Tarandach I put on, I put on my wizard robes.
33:56Matt Coles 1900 threat model.
33:58Chris Romeo What?
33:59Izar Tarandach Oh boy.
34:00Chris Romeo Now we're going, now we're going on the, now we're going in the wrong direction.
34:04Matt Coles The wrong direction.
34:07Chris Romeo All right. So I think we're, we should have a recess before we go any further.
34:10Matt Coles Yes.
34:10Chris Romeo We've reached, that's what I'm about to do. We've reached a consensus.
34:12Izar Tarandach So many ideas right now.
34:14Chris Romeo None of us are, none of us are in favor of hacking back, Pirates of the Cyber Minds, or any of these other types of things. It's, it's, I don't know, it's flashy, it could be attention getting, and then, but it's, at the end of the day, it's not gonna move the needle. It's not gonna, it's not gonna, it's not gonna, it's not gonna make your defenses any better to go out and try to get revenge.
34:39Izar Tarandach It might move the needle, but in the wrong— in a direction that you did not think of. Not the one— one, one that you didn't think of.
34:47Chris Romeo Yeah, the consequences may be— you may open the door and we call them— find out there's—
34:54Matt Coles we call them side effects.
34:55Chris Romeo There's 8 feet of water on the other side of the door.
34:59Izar Tarandach We call them unintended consequences.
35:02Chris Romeo Yeah, or that sounds like—
35:03Izar Tarandach what is—
35:04Chris Romeo what do we become, lawyers?
35:05Matt Coles Or viol— or violating assumptions.
35:09Chris Romeo Folks, thank you for turning into the Cybercrime and Law podcast with 3 people who aren't lawyers and—
35:16Izar Tarandach Oh, hello there!
35:17Matt Coles —but we have ChatGPT or connection to law enforcement. Yeah.
35:20Izar Tarandach Both believe in law enforcement.
35:21Chris Romeo But we've got a lot of opinions. So, all right, folks, thanks for listening to the Security Table.
Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.
Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.
