52 minSeason 2, episode 17

Security, Stories, Jazz and Stage Presence with Brook Schoenfield

With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles

Teams, careers & security culture

In this episode of 'The Security Table,' hosts Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles are joined by Brook Schoenfield, a seasoned security professional, to share insights and stories from his extensive career.

Episode title image: Security, Stories, Jazz and Stage Presence with Brook Schoenfield

Listen to the conversation

About this episode

In this episode of 'The Security Table,' hosts Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles are joined by Brook Schoenfield, a seasoned security professional, to share insights and stories from his extensive career. 

The conversation covers Brook's experience in writing books on security, lessons learned from his 40-year career, and personal anecdotes about his life as a musician, including playing with legends like Bo Diddley and Chuck Berry. Brook highlights the importance of ensemble work in both security and music.


Books written by Brook Schoenfield:

Secrets Of A Cyber Security Architect (Auerbach, 2019) https://brookschoenfield.com/?page_id=331

Securing Systems: Applied Security Architecture https://brookschoenfield.com/?page_id=245

Follow AI Security Table:

➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/

➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable

➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/

➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable

Transcript · 52 min conversation

0:08Brook Schoenfield All right.

0:10Chris Romeo Well, hey folks, welcome to another episode of the Security Table. And my name is Chris Romeo, joined by Izar Tarandash, Matt Coles, the normal gang around the mahogany table.

0:23Izar Tarandach Wait, wait, normal? Say that again.

0:25Chris Romeo Okay. Well, that was just a, I was trying to use a nice adjective to describe you. He means usual. The usual.

0:29Brook Schoenfield The usual.

0:31Matt Coles Usual.

0:32Chris Romeo Well, we are joined by our good friend Brooke Schoenfeld, who it's always a joy to, whenever I get a chance to interact with Brooke, it's always just such a joy because I learned many things and I hear many stories. And so that's the plan for this episode. We're just here. We're going to learn from Brooke. We're going to hear some stories. We're going to throw some things out, some hot takes that, uh, Brooke can react to and then people that listen to this don't know who we'll react to. We won't be able to, let me react to that. And then Brick will react to our, our responses.

1:04Brook Schoenfield And there are 3 people on this call, the other 3 people who are among the dearest people in this, in my life. Forget the industry, but in my life.

1:15Matt Coles Cheers.

1:15Brook Schoenfield Cheers. 3 of my dearest friends. And they have taught me so much. My practice has changed radically in the. In the interaction with each of these people. And so, you know, it's both a joy and always a privilege to talk to you folks because wow, you're the best. You really are.

1:38Izar Tarandach If we're still friends after this, it'll be memorable.

1:42Matt Coles No, if we're still friends after this, we did something wrong.

1:48Chris Romeo We did not push the envelope enough. We needed to push the envelope further. Well, let's, uh, let's, let's start. Yeah, I don't have an envelope. Does anyone even have a paper envelope anymore? How do you push an envelope? What kind of envelope? That was, but that was Raise the Roof. These are, those were just the roof. I taught you. I taught you. Matt has literally left the show.

2:09Matt Coles At least my Mac is not doing anything when I'm moving.

2:12Chris Romeo Okay. No, Matt, Matt's back.

2:13Matt Coles Yes.

2:13Chris Romeo There we go. He has envelopes.

2:15Brook Schoenfield Those are envelopes. Push it, Matt.

2:16Izar Tarandach They are so old. They're so old that they got, they got sealed just by the humidity in the room over time.

2:24Chris Romeo They're all addressed to the Internal Revenue Service for some reason. Not sure why he has a stack of envelopes.

2:30Izar Tarandach It's all the, it's all the hate. It's all the hate mail that I've been saving up to send.

2:34Chris Romeo Wait, you're not sending it to our show, are you?

2:36Matt Coles Wait, wait, wait.

2:37Chris Romeo You are the hosts.

2:39Matt Coles Does any of those come from Australia?

2:41Chris Romeo No, there's no hate.

2:43Matt Coles Did I have sweat from the treadmill?

2:46Izar Tarandach How do you, how do we know that none of these are coming from our favorite fan who keeps on sending us stuff?

2:50Chris Romeo Yeah, we do have a, we do have a favorite fan, but we also want to offer a shout out to those people in Australia. Oh yeah. Because they're blowing up our downloads. Not, not, not lying.

2:59Izar Tarandach That's, and Dublin.

3:01Chris Romeo And Dublin. Apparently that's the most, the city we're the most popular in. So another shout out to Dublin, but let's get to Brooke. We, we've spent enough time goofing around, which is kind of the story of all three of our lives. Brooke, let's, let's tell, tell this story about this book. You were telling us before we started about how you, uh, you, you're a prolific writer, author, you've written a bunch of different things, but you were telling us a kind of a behind the scenes story about one of the books that you, uh, had written. And I think it's, it's something that people need to hear.

3:30Brook Schoenfield Okay. Well, it's the third book, um, after Core Software Security, where I wrote a chapter, and then I wrote Securing Systems. And I thought, you know, there's so much material in here. All I got to do is cut out the best parts and put it in a new, in a new way and, and figure it out in some way. And, and I'll have another book out and it'll be great. And it'll be called something like Secrets of a Security Architect or something like that. Um, you know, or, or, or trade tricks of the trade. That's actually the working title I had, Tricks of the Trade. Right. And I thought, this is gonna be trivial. So I cut out all these little pieces and I assembled them. I used some, a script writing piece of software to assemble all these. And that's how they write scripts, by the way. You assemble pieces and, and, you know, and, and it allows you to do that really well. I, I don't know, in the comedy world, do you use the same kind of thing for assembling scripts for your, your, your, your talks? Chris, I know you do some standup comedy. I imagine it's the same.

4:32Chris Romeo You, you get like this. I don't do standup. I do comedy, uh, in very many places because I think I'm funny, but it's never—

4:40Izar Tarandach But you are standing up when you are standing up when you do them.

4:44Matt Coles No, no, no. I think that you are mixing the on purpose. I don't go stand up on purpose.

4:49Chris Romeo On purpose.

4:50Matt Coles Yes. You don't make, you don't make a, you don't make a living at it.

4:54Brook Schoenfield Yeah. So, so anyway, I'm, I'm writing these things thinking this is all going to be really great. It's going to be really easy. I'll write a little introduction and I'll write a little section editor and say what this is all about and I'll arrange them in an order and it will take me, you know, a few weeks and it'll be done. And after I did it and after I paid someone to try and arrange them by things, because I wasn't getting around to it, it was such a god awful mess. Of nonsense. Not, not that my individual pieces were nonsense, but it just didn't come together. It didn't have a through line. It didn't have a feel of a book or, you know, it just little bits. It was horrible. It literally was horrible. I still have all that stuff laying around. I could even show it. No, I won't. 'Cause it's really boring. Um, but, uh, and it, the thing is by then a year had passed and, you know, I'd promised a, a draft in a year. And then I had to go back to the publisher who's like, where's my, where's my copy? When is it going to be? When is it going to be? When is it going to be? And I'm like, this is junk. I don't have it. And they said, okay, how long? Well, another year. I, I'll, I'll write, you know, just give me another year. I'll, all right. So it took a year for me to figure out what the through line of Secrets of a Cybersecurity Architect. By the way, the cyber was stuck in there by the publisher. I would never have put that in my title.

6:21Matt Coles You told me.

6:22Brook Schoenfield Yeah, yeah, yeah. However, you know, that they felt they needed that cyber in there. So it's not a word I like using except in certain contexts, but nevertheless. So, um, so that took me a year and I just kept fiddling and fiddling and worrying about it and trying to write stuff and throwing it out. And, um, then after about a year, it came to me how this book comes together into a whole and where some of that material might fall. Although I used almost none of those quotes, I rewrote everything. But, um, uh, you know, it, it finally came to me what the form of the book was. So then it took another year to actually write that book. And so that's the story of Secrets and how it, how it actually came around. Now, more than once some reader, you know, all of the 20 people who've read that book, um, a couple of them have come back to me and said, uh, uh, you know, this is really good. And, and it's a couple of people have called it a Bible. A couple of my books have been called a Bible, you know, of their subject. And that's really, really, I mean, oh my God, don't you wish that, uh, that's so, that's useful to somebody. So apparently Eventually I did get a book that was useful, but man, that was the roughest process yet. I have to say.

7:47Matt Coles The latest one is definitely the Bible. The one that you wrote with Dr. Ransom?

7:53Brook Schoenfield Yeah, well, we tried.

7:55Matt Coles On security development? That one is a Bible. But on the memories, what's the story in there that you like the most?

8:05Brook Schoenfield Well, you know, just for writers when they're writing or any project is, you know, don't, don't give up. Don't, if you have an idea, don't give up, but you've gotta find what it is. And of course there'll be dead ends. Of course. You know, think about, think about this book we're working on now collectively. I wrote a preface and Adam came in. Yeah, we're supposed to not talk about it, but Adam came in and said, your preface isn't right. And I'm rewriting it.

8:38Matt Coles It's okay. Nobody heard anything. Nobody heard anything. Forget about it. Do we have the flasher thing?

8:47Izar Tarandach Brooke is a living embodiment of numerous security properties and principles.

8:55Brook Schoenfield Yeah, but my OPSEC is terrible.

8:58Matt Coles He leaves, he leaves open source to the court.

9:02Chris Romeo He's just open sourcing everything. All right. Well, Brooke, here's a question for you. So you worked in and around the field of engineering for, I wanna say 40+ years. Am I right with that number?

9:18Brook Schoenfield I think this October, it'll be 40 years.

9:21Chris Romeo Be 40 years. Okay. And so what day exactly?

9:26Matt Coles I don't remember.

9:27Chris Romeo He's always gonna sell October.

9:29Brook Schoenfield I forgot the month.

9:30Chris Romeo Your, your, your work anniversary. But when you look back across that 40-year career, I guess what are, what are some of the takeaways that, that come to mind that, uh, that would be good to share with people that are at various stages of their career? Because I'm always curious when somebody. As a practitioner in one thing for so long? Like what, you know, you were driven to it. Like what, you know, just tell us some of the takeaways. Tell us some things that you've learned along your journey.

9:58Izar Tarandach What kept, what kept you here too? Like how did, how did you sustain that for so long?

10:03Brook Schoenfield Would be great to hear. Well, that's a great question, Matt. That is a truly great question. Um, to be honest, I was a musician and an activist. And a part-time college professor. I loved teaching. Love. But I didn't have enough work to make a whole living. And I was really doing well as a musician, right? And I kind of threw it all away to join a community of people that I really loved and loved working with, being an anti-nuclear activist in San Francisco. So there's a little background here. And I hated the work. Loved the people, hated the work. I'm not going to be an act— well, I am an activist, as you know, in terms of what I want to change. I do bring that to everything I do. But, um, but nevertheless, I didn't really like the work, um, at all. And it wasn't going to sustain me and it wasn't enough money to raise a kid, which I wanted to have. And so, uh, we were talking about having a kid. So, um, You know, there were some problems there and I remembered that I'd done really well with programming and computers in col— in my master's. And I thought, huh, I wonder if I can do this. We were writing a little program. Um, in those days, mail merge wasn't something that you had as part of your word processor. It was something you wrote and we were writing a mail merge. And the person doing it decided they didn't want to do it. They were volunteering. And I said, that looks a lot like the code that I was writing in college. I'll bet I can do this. And once I'd written that, I realized this is fun. So that's the first thing I realized. There's an intersection in careers between what people will pay for, what you can stand doing, or better if it's fun. And, and coding is fun, uh, for me anyway. And, um, at the same time, something you can sustain for a long time that people will pay you for, right? And that was a nice thing, and I needed to make more money. That was really the reason. And I wanted a little more freedom in my life, um, than the standard type office job or going into a retail or doing anything like that. And I said, I can do this. And I could do it. And it turns out I could do it pretty well. And so then I got a job. So that was my first commercial project. That was in 1984, 1885. And then I got a real job and I just studied computer science as hard and as difficult as I have. So that's the next takeaway. If you don't know, just self-educate. And I have known so many. I know wonderful engineers who never finished high school, but are smart, self-educating people. So I'm not knocking a college education at all. But when you're interviewing people, just because they don't have one doesn't mean they can't do the job. Find out about the person and their skills, right? Um, it's one marker, but it's not the only marker. And how many people have you had that had PhDs that couldn't code their way out of a paper bag? Um, so, you know, it works both ways. And so, uh, that was the second thing. I really wanted to know how it worked down to the bottom. So I started studying, uh, I think it was, uh, um, what is that processor? Anyway, there's a book about processors and I studied it and went down to logic gates and tried to figure out my computer science and get it down. Right. And that stood me well. Okay. So that's another takeaway. Third takeaway. If you don't know, keep waiting because you got to get all the networks built in your brain. So here's a hilarious thing. They invited me to the design meetings in my second job. That first time I was like hired as a, as a programmer. Okay. Little startup called Cilantro and they still exist by the way. Um, and do something totally different, but, but they still exist. And, um, they invited me to design meetings. Now, the people in that design meeting, there was John Carone, who is one of my great mentors, who, who was the CEO and brilliant, um, a person who helped write the DARPA net, a person who is now, um, working on the, for the National Science Foundation and was the head of a research lab at Texas A&M. Those kind of level of people were there at that time. And this is like 1986-ish, maybe '87. And I'm sitting in this meeting and I swear to you, in that first couple of meetings, I had no idea what they were talking about. None. And I'm sitting there because I have no, no design experience. I don't know what they're talking about, right? It's just words and I'm just trying to take it in. I didn't say a word, not a word. And I remember after about 6 weeks. I asked the question and John looks at me and says, great question, Brooke. Keep listening. And that is some of the best advice I've ever had in my career is that just because you don't know what's going on doesn't mean your brain won't get enough of the background over time to begin to be able to form the different ways. You have to wait for that to happen. Don't be in a rush. It takes a while. Unless of course you're preternaturally disposed. My friend, um, I think of his name, um, I think his first name is Sandeep, but I can't remember his last name. Anyway, he's some, you know, huge vice VP at some company now, a brilliant guy. But when he was in his early 20s, he was a better architect than many of the people in IT at Cisco. He just preternaturally You know, there are those people, but for us mere mortals, you gotta wait and do the time and eventually it will, it will start to form and you'll begin, you know, the reason they hired me at Cisco is because I had all this design background. I was a really good designer by, by the year 2000, you know, from 1987 to 2000, I became a really good designer. With lots of experience, having designed a lot of stuff. And that's, you know, a wonderful story right there for anybody to, when you're starting, don't be in a rush. Let it happen because it takes a while for us mere mortals. You know, I guess I'm smart enough, but, but, you know, I'm, I'm not, I'm not Sandeep who is just preternaturally an architect by, by, by ability. And brilliant in that way. But it happened. I became a designer. They took me at Cisco because so few people in InfoSec had design experience in those days, and they were building out architecture. That was the days when we were building architecture as a security architecture as a function, and they needed people with design capability, and they didn't have a lot who wanted to be security people. So, you know, there's another thing, you know, use what you got because it might be—

17:22Izar Tarandach just as, just as an aside, uh, that was the top, that's the topic that we might be covering next, next, uh, set, next, um, podcast episode, going back to archi— going back to architecture and design as a, as a foundation of, of IT and cybersecurity.

17:38Brook Schoenfield I, I don't think we can get around it. And that was what was happening. Cisco was way ahead of the curve, right? So was the NSA. They were really thinking about, and because we talked to them, that's how I know. Um, and they were way ahead of the curve as some companies were. Yeah, but then they were, and they were publishing that stuff. So it's all okay. Um, but, uh, they were thinking, go on. Sorry.

18:05Matt Coles It's, it's, it's interesting that you, you, you mentioned like people that, uh, greatest sentences that changed the way that you do things or that validated the way that you do things. To me, it's interesting because years ago you told me one sentence that completely changed the way that I approach things. And that's a story that I've been telling people in talks, one-to-one, everything. Years and years ago, you told me nobody wants— nobody likes to be told that their baby is ugly. And that happened when I was looking for a way to talk to developers and architects about the things that we are finding in threat modeling. And I just couldn't get them to listen. I just couldn't get them to like see that there was value in what I was saying. And then you came with that sentence and all of a sudden it wasn't even a verb. It was like an angelic choir in the background going, oh, And, and, and from then on, every time before I opened my mouth, I could hear you saying those words and just me thinking, how do I sell to people these corrections that I want, these changes that I want them to make to their design that's going to make it more robust, that's going to, to make it better.

19:23Brook Schoenfield And that's, to me, it's, it's like, because I'm going to tell you, the first security assessment I ever did. Laura Lindsay, I was shadowing Lauren Z, or she was shadowing me to make sure I didn't do anything too terrible. And we went in and when we walked out, she said, Brooke, we're not the cops. We're here to help these people be successful. And so I'll just pass that on that, you know, I had my own come to be nice moment. Or, you know. Come to the deity of your choice moment is, you know, uh, that, uh, that, uh, you know, so, so it was, it's a learned thing, by the way, you know, so you took it as wisdom, but Laura, you know, basically very softly with a wet noodle slapped my wrist and said, behave, Brooke. We're, we're, we're trying to help these people. And, and I just, you know, I'm hoping we can get badges.

20:25Chris Romeo I just want a badge that goes along with that. Like, she told you not to be a cop, but I want that badge to be in a meeting and be like, let me just show you my identification.

20:34Brook Schoenfield I am not a cop. Why do you think you can tell me that?

20:37Matt Coles Here, let me show you why.

20:40Brook Schoenfield But you know, that should never stop us. That should never stop us from remembering that we are, we do hold expertise they need. One. And that we are being in service and in value, but there are things we should own. Like, I never let— I'm more than willing to talk about risk with anyone, but I remember that as the security expert and as the risk expert, I hold the ultimate responsibility for doing that well. And, um, if, you know, one of these very lawyerly brilliant engineers tries to lawyerly talk me out of a risk, I don't let them. In fact, I don't even engage in that conversation. I say, no, I'm the expert. I'm telling you this is the risk and here's why. And you can agree or not agree, but this is it. That's my job. And we should always remember that.

21:33Izar Tarandach So there needs to be, there needs to be a, needs to be an episode like that old, um, uh, Law and Order show. You know, there's, there's, there's this There's two groups in New York in the criminal justice system, the lawyers who prosecute, offend, prosecute, prosecute, prosecute, and those that arrest them.

21:57Chris Romeo Uh, these are their stories. That's what we need though. We need that. That'd be good television.

22:04Matt Coles We have to make one of those.

22:07Izar Tarandach Cybersecurity and cybersecurity and risk.

22:11Chris Romeo That'd be so boring. Oh God. Be so boring. Can you imagine how boring that show would be?

22:19Matt Coles Oh man. No, no. I'm betting it'll go, go a good one. Okay.

22:22Izar Tarandach So hold on. We'd have to, we'd have to do it in Mr. Robot style so we at least get, we take the hacking stuff outta the way, you know, um, but make it real enough. Um, and then you have to, and then you have to have, uh, I guess you'd have to have the, the SOC, the, the, the incident handler, you know, an incident incident handling scene as part of the, uh, as part of the risk discussion, you know, there, no, otherwise those meetings are, all those meetings, those meetings are so, so, so boring.

22:48Matt Coles We have to have a scene where somebody's banging on a keyboard, then you can hear, and then they raise their hands and you can still hear.

22:54Chris Romeo It'll be like a mix of like the Naked Gun and, you know, those kind of parody movies with technology movies and stuff. And The Office.

23:05Brook Schoenfield I can't imagine. So I really would— how boring it would be to have a visual media, like, like a movie or television or whatever, um, looking at someone sitting at, I mean, The Matrix did as best as you can do with someone sitting at a terminal.

23:24Izar Tarandach So that's actually, I wanted to ask you that, Brooke, because you know, you're over your storied career. If we look, I, I've, we've seen, we've seen over the years, you know, many people have done these, these, you know, tiered lists of movies and things. Neil deGrasse Tyson did one recently about, about science movies and, you know, Inception, uh, not Inception, but, uh, um, Interstellar and those other movies, right? And he ranked them. But if we look at the hacking movies over the years, the security movies over the years, like Hackers and Sneakers and, you know, Sneakers, I think personally is probably one of the best, best examples of, of, you know, somebody sitting in front of a keyboard in front of a console. Hacking, right?

24:03Matt Coles Apart from the, you remember Mr. Goodslate?

24:05Izar Tarandach I guess they actually did proper, you know, things properly. And they had to cut it, you know, down to an hour-long episode and whatnot. But if you had the, if you look back across that and the mirror of your, of your career, right? Ha, uh, Hackers, sorry, Sneakers came out in the, in the '80s. Hackers came out in the '90s.

24:24Brook Schoenfield I don't remember it much.

24:26Izar Tarandach Um, but, but a lot of the other ones, uh, Southwark and, uh, Dan Alpert was in that one.

24:32Brook Schoenfield Uh, they're just ridiculous.

24:33Izar Tarandach They're terrible, but they're awesome.

24:35Brook Schoenfield Yeah.

24:35Izar Tarandach Well, but they're awesome.

24:36Brook Schoenfield It's all the same. They're fun. But, but Swordfish. Oh, come on.

24:40Izar Tarandach Swordfish.

24:41Brook Schoenfield Oh, they, they, they, you know, I, I, most of them, the, the computer part of it is just so absurd that, and I'm gonna put in a plug here because I have a financial interest in it. They're, they're building a movie off of a novel called Calculated, but there's one thing in the, the writer wrote the, it's a, it's a wonderful novel. Um, but there's one thing that she wrote, there's some secret thing that's supposed to like open up or close things. And I'm like, you know, there are actual techniques. If you had talked to a com security person who could have told you how this works, and you should have written that because. Anybody, any, most kids know that this is nonsense today. And, you know, um, and I, I hate to call out that author, but that one little bit is not well thought out. I'll just tell you. Um, and, and that's the truth of most of these things. Yeah. They're bad.

25:38Izar Tarandach I'm sorry. Then you get the, then you get the hacker, you get the hacker-related movies like, like, uh, Jurassic Park or, uh, oh, I never met the tunics.

25:47Brook Schoenfield Yeah, but he's an insider.

25:49Chris Romeo They applied one patch.

25:51Brook Schoenfield He's, yeah, he's, he's an insider. And because he has access, it's more believable to me that because he's, I mean, think about San Francisco. Okay. Another story. County, city and county of San Francisco. I forget what year this was. It was in the teens, early teens, uh, 2013, 14, somewhere in there. Maybe it was 12. I don't remember. But, um, there was a guy who got, he felt he was, he had all access to every router and networking equipment in San Francisco. And because he was being terminated, he changed the passwords all to one password he knew, and then he wouldn't give it up. And he said, too bad, so I don't work there anymore. And the judge, you know, he sat in jail for 6 weeks because for contempt of court, because he wouldn't give it up.

26:38Chris Romeo I remember that.

26:38Brook Schoenfield And finally the mayor talked him into giving it up. I think, I think that's how it went down. Yeah. But wait, wait a bit. You know, so, so Jurassic Park is believable in that way because someone with a lot of access can do things like that if you're not watching them. But, and we have examples in real life, but some of these things depend on technology we don't have. And they didn't needn't because there is technology we have that does that stuff.

27:03Matt Coles Now, Dirk Kleff, let's reverse, let's reverse the premise. If you think back about the things that you saw and the things that you experienced, do you have one that could turn into a good movie?

27:17Chris Romeo Huh.

27:17Brook Schoenfield I have to think about that. Yeah, but it's got nothing to do with security. Or, or it does, but in a different way. Um, and I'm not sure I want to tell that story here publicly and have tied to me.

27:29Matt Coles I'm not advised.

27:30Izar Tarandach I'm not advised.

27:31Brook Schoenfield Let me just say that one time I stopped a missile launch with a little, um, silo, you know, or the little light sticks. When I was an activist and that—

27:41Matt Coles No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Go again from the beginning.

27:46Brook Schoenfield No, no, I'm not going to tell that story.

27:49Chris Romeo He's got to anonymize. He's got to, he's got to protect his, uh, his own profession.

27:53Matt Coles What's the name of the time period between doing something wrong and—

27:56Chris Romeo Statutes of limitations.

27:58Brook Schoenfield Oh, I'm way beyond that. I'm way beyond that.

28:00Chris Romeo But in national security, there really isn't any. Just FYI.

28:04Brook Schoenfield Yeah. Yeah.

28:05Izar Tarandach Was it a big, so, don't give anyone any ideas.

28:09Brook Schoenfield Don't give anyone any ideas.

28:10Chris Romeo No ideas. So, let me tell you, let me tell you my favorite Brooks story. Okay. Cause I, it's, it's, I wanna, I, I love Brooks reaction to this cause we, he and I have a shared experience that, uh, that has become a tradition for us. And, uh, it's, it's, it, it, it, the way it came together was just, was pretty amazing. And my misunderstanding about. The background behind it. So maybe 4 or 5 years ago, uh, out at RSA, Brooke and I connected, said, hey, let's, uh, let's have dinner. And he's like, oh, well, there's this great Chinese restaurant, uh, right by the Moscone Center. It's called Fang. And I was like, okay, that sounds good. I think it was, it was Brooke, myself, my wife, Deb, uh, Justin, that was in sales for Security Journey at the time. And I think Brooke, your daughter, I think might've been there. Does that sound right? The first year. And so, but we go in and we sit down and, and Brooke's like, oh yeah, this, this restaurant's great. You know, I've lived in San Francisco for a long time. I knew it. And so he calls the chef over. Turns out the chef is a world-renowned Chinese chef. Very, very non-imposing, just a very kind of normal guy. Didn't have any air about him. And Brooke looks at him and says, uh, chef, would you, uh, please make us a, a very enjoyable meal? And so the chef grabs all the menus literally out of our hands, just rips them out of our hands. And he goes, okay, any allergies? And we're like, no. And he's like, okay. He goes off into the kitchen and all of a sudden, maybe 15 minutes later, dish after dish starts hitting the table of the most incredible Chinese food I've ever eaten in my life. And it's like chef was weaving a, a, a he was like composing a symphony of taste and food and everything. And so I couldn't go in there and order the things that I ate cuz I don't have any idea what they were. I don't know what the dishes were called or anything, but dish after dish keeps coming down in front of us and we're just eating and eating and just having a great time. And so this be, has become a tradition of, uh, of Brooke and mine. And so then the second year we go, we go to Fang. They're filming a reality show inside of Fang. So we're outside and we're like, we want to go eat. They're like, okay, well, can you just need to sign this release in case we use your face on the reality show? And so we're like, great. And so we end up having the same experience. We call chef over and, and ask him to prepare us a delicious meal. Off he takes the menus again, off he goes. But now there's cameras and people shooting, recording. Various scenes happening inside of this restaurant. And so we had another great time. We've done it a few other times. All of this to say, when Brooke originally told me that he lived in San Francisco for many years, I thought he had a relationship, like he knew the chef and like this was, he was friends with the chef or something. And that's why the chef, that's why the chef was taking such good care of him. And he's like, I think it was last year or the year before, he's like, I didn't know him before we walked in. You're the first. And so here I go thinking like, Brooke is creating, he has this network of people and he's like, oh, let me just check with Jeff. Hey, I was like, no, he had never met him before. He just went with the line.

31:21Brook Schoenfield That's not quite true. Okay.

31:22Chris Romeo I'm sorry. Correct me.

31:23Brook Schoenfield Let me, let me set the stage. So, so the first time I had these coupons that we got, I think it was at RSA or sometime. And, um, me and a friend went over there and redeemed our coupons for an appetizer and we bought drinks, right? And we sat at the bar and I went, wow, these are incredible. It was a Northern Chinese dish. The, the, the, um, it was a really interesting take on the, if you've ever had the, the onion cakes, I really love the onion cakes, but it was very interesting. So it was on my my, my radar as a restaurant, right? Well, for our, either our anniversary or my wife's birthday, we said, let's go out. Let's go to Fang. And we came in and she's a vegetarian. So we wanted to work that out. I think she was eating fish at the time. I don't remember, but you know, there were some restrictions and she can't have any chili. So we just told them. And, and he said, will you just trust me to do the meal? And I said, sure, rather than ordering, can I just take care of it for you? He actually said that to us. And we said, sure. I mean, how bad can it be? Right? And it was incredible. It was just as incredible as everyone we've had. So I had had that experience already and I knew it was better. Wait, wait, wait.

32:51Izar Tarandach Did you just, did you just 4-question frameworks the restaurant?

32:55Matt Coles Actually, I was thinking the chef goes in, the chief waiter comes to him and says, what's happening? He says, it's that guy again. Just give him one of everything.

33:08Brook Schoenfield Well, that could be. It's, uh, but, but then I went to the bathroom and all the gold medals are not hanging where you see them. They're out next to the bathroom hidden. Down, you know, you have to go to the bathroom and you see them on the— and I realized, oh, that's why this meal is so good. Because this guy's a gold medal winning chef and, you know, and it's an open kitchen so you can see everybody working and he's watching to make sure it's everything's going, you know, but he's out the room. So that's kind of the whole story is that's the background on which I had confidence that if we just told Chef Fong to get us dinner. It would be fantastic.

33:46Chris Romeo But I had still thought that you guys were friends and that's why we were getting this treatment. Cause I'm like, man, Brooke is a baller. Look at this guy. He's just like, shut up.

33:56Brook Schoenfield I don't know him from last week.

33:57Chris Romeo It was a good move.

33:59Izar Tarandach So, so Brooke, so Brooke, Brooke threat models the restaurant with what can go wrong, chooses to ignore all of the things that can go wrong. And, and he calls, he did a good job and he did a good job.

34:12Matt Coles He called out the allergy first, so he won't deal with assumptions. That's it.

34:16Chris Romeo That's good stuff.

34:20Brook Schoenfield So, so it wasn't entirely uninformed, but it wasn't as informed as you thought. Um, clearly. Oh yeah. No, I'm, I don't know that chef.

34:29Izar Tarandach Um, you must be fun at, you must be fun at sushi. You must be fun in a sushi restaurant. You just show up at the bar and you don't give me stuff.

34:36Brook Schoenfield Yeah. Well, oh, but you know what? My favorite birthday party is to have a roll your own sushi party at my house. And everyone brings whatever they have. So if you have vegans, they bring their stuff and they roll it. You know, I make a whole bunch of sushi rice and put out the nori and, and boards and knives and everything and all the stuff you need and, and just let people roll whatever they're going to roll. And if somebody wants to put, you know, they need beef in there, fine, whatever. And, you know, those people who are fish-centric or never eat fish, whatever. And it's hilarious. You have to have a mat underneath the table because rice cooks.

35:17Matt Coles I lost it. I pulled out the knives.

35:20Izar Tarandach Yeah, I was going to say you have to have a first aid kit nearby. I'm sure.

35:24Brook Schoenfield It's not for children.

35:27Matt Coles It's not a child's.

35:29Izar Tarandach Let's, let's talk about threat modeling in daily life right there, huh?

35:34Chris Romeo That's true. That's true. Um, Brooke, I wanted to, uh, I wanted to ask another question just cuz I wanna hog our time here primarily. Uh, but I know that in, in conversation, what else is in conversations that we've had offline? Uh, well, when we talked about your musical career, that it's just something I didn't, I never understood the depth of your musical career and also some of the people, some of the famous people that you've played music with. Was pretty cool to me to hear that. And if you're willing to share, I'd love to just share with our audience the kind of the other side of away from technology when you were, when you're in the music world, tell us a little bit about your background and history there. And if you don't mind, I'd love to hear those stories again about some of those famous people you played with.

36:20Brook Schoenfield Sure. Um, uh, if it's of interest to folks, uh, it doesn't have much to do with any of this, but, but it does because our whole being comes to our work, whether you think so or not. You know, whether you're just putting on your little face and you think so, you're still bringing all your stuff, right? So you're all there. And the best job, I think, is one that lets you be all there. Not, not in an unbounded way. It's not a therapy session. Work isn't a therapy session, right? You know, if you come in and say, yes, I'm great, it's horrible. Yeah. It leads you to You know, you can come in and say, I'm having a really bad day. I just had a fight with my spouse and it's just horrible. That's fine. People want to know that, but they don't want to sit there and go over all the problems and fix your relationship with your spouse. You know, there's a balance.

37:08Izar Tarandach Excuse me while I, excuse me while I grind my ax.

37:11Brook Schoenfield Yes, exactly. Or whatever. How are you thinking? You know, I'm staying out of people's relationships. But so, yes, I've been a lifelong musician. Um, I really wanted to be a musician, a first, a blues musician, and then a jazz musician really desperately. And, um, I've trained really hard. I went to conservatory for a couple of years. Um, you know, I've got a lot of background there. I've taught music for years. I even taught, uh, jazz improvisation for UCLA Extension. You know, I have a lot of history here. Um, uh, whether I'm good enough to actually be a working jazz musician is another question. It's a very rarefied universe. Um, so, you know, that would be in the, the, the ears of the beholder. But yeah, I've spent a lot of time trying to learn how to play and play well. Um, whether I do or not is again in the ears of the beholder. But, um, in that journey I have met some interesting people. Um, uh, for a while, uh, I was running into, um, Oh God, his name's gonna, it'll come to me. Um, but, but let me tell some stories here. So, uh, when I moved to Albuquerque, New Mexico in, uh, I think 1973, it was late 1973. Um, cuz remember I'm old. Uh, and, uh, I'll just say that security, depending upon how you count it, is either my 5th, 6th, or 7th career. So yeah. Um, just remember that. So, um, uh, I moved there and we were trying to, you know, form a band and, and do the usual band thing. And I was trying to get involved and we had some really great players. And it turned out that Bo Diddley was looking for a backup band for a singer he was producing, Cookie V. And she's fantastic, by the way, Cookie V. And so we went out and auditioned and she said, this is the band. You guys are great. And so that brought us to working with Bo every single day. He was doing production. We were in his studio every day. We were, you know, getting tips, um, you know, to how to be successful because he was producing Cookie. And the thing is, whenever we would go out and do a gig. At least the first night, sometimes more, Bo would play with us when he wasn't on tour. And so I have played with Bo Diddley a lot, and he's a— was a wonderful man, I will tell you, an absolutely wonderful man and a great mentor. I learned so much about the business of music and, and, and, and why that is actually just as important. I mean, I used to be the guy, the guitar player. I'd stand sort of in my crappy clothes, sort of facing away from the audience because I was scared of them and, and just blowing my horn and trying to make the singer sound great. Right? That's my job. But Bo taught me to be a, a presence on stage. And I mean, this is a man who could walk on stage. You're playing like the introductory thing as you do, and Bo walks on stage and he starts singing and within 15 seconds The room is dead on him. This man had charisma beyond charisma. He could make a room of people just shut up and pay attention to him and only him. And meanwhile, you're trying to, because he, you know, he wasn't, he wasn't like the most, um, schooled musician, although a very good musician. Um, and so you're busy trying to tune to his, his guitar and stuff while he's, because he didn't like tune it to a tuner or anything. And he's a little out and you're like, whoa, let's get it in here. Um, but, uh, yeah, Bo was a wonderful man. Absolutely wonderful, supportive, delightful. Went in the studio with him, did a lot of work with him, played with him a lot. So that was the Bo Diddley story. And then of course Cookie got pregnant and had a fight with her husband and quit the band and all things fall apart. Um, right when we were about to break. Of course.

41:22Matt Coles But did you ever play with Gary McGraw? No.

41:26Brook Schoenfield Gary is a great violinist. If you go listen to the, it's called the Something Liberals. It's the name of a cocktail. Um, um, uh, but, uh, it's the name of his band, but I've heard them. I've heard recordings and live things. He's very good. He's very good. Um, so anyway, um, that's one story and the other story probably of interest to people is is playing with, uh, Chuck Berry. So when Chuck Berry was going around, he would often use backup bands, not always, but often use backup bands, um, just in the area. And, um, so, uh, Chuck Berry was coming to town and they needed to put a backup band, so they hired the best jazz musicians in town. This is in San Luis Obispo. Okay. And there are 4 of us, you know, bass player, or 3 of us. Bass player, guitar player, and drummer. And, and I worked with, with both of them, but particularly the, the drummer was the drummer in this really ex— incredible Afro jazz ensemble that, that we wrote music for and played with. Um, uh, Leon White, great player, like phenomenal. So he walks in and he looks and he says, guitar player, you can leave. 'Cause I don't need a guitar player, right? I just need a bass player and a drummer. And I'm like, okay, all right. So I start going, nah, wait, let's hear you. This true story. Let's, let's hear you. This, this story has a great punchline too, by the way. Just hang with it. So, okay. So we start playing and I know exactly what to do. And he goes, you can stay, but drummer, you're playing the wrong stuff. And I thought Leon was fine, right? And Leon says, okay, tell me what to play. And he says, simpler, just keep it simple. And we started, he's like playing 4, 8 bars. I mean, you know, not a whole tune, just a little bit of a tune to get the feel for it. And he stops us and he says, no, simple. This goes on for maybe 6 or 7 different starts. Now, Leon White, I never saw him upset ever. The man was the coolest creature. On the bandstand. He did not get upset. You could critique him. You could say, this doesn't work. This does work. He was just really great to work with. And he's getting mad. I can tell he's getting frustrated. And you can sort of see the smoke coming out of his ears, although nothing nasty is coming out of his mouth. Right. Um, and finally Chuck says, dang it, play country. And Leon goes, oh, okay. And we drop into the tune and he goes, tick, tick, tick, tick to tick and you know play 4 bars and Chuck says perfect that was the whole rehearsal we never played one song through not one because you're supposed to know how to play these bloody songs you're not supposed to like need to rehearse you know this kind of simple chord changes that Chuck uses he's supposed to be able to hear it he gives you a key you start you go you pay attention okay So great, we're ready. Chuck says, hey, realizing I can play, he says, let's play a little. So curtains closed, nothing's happening. Chuck and I for about 30 minutes trade blues lines and play blues. He was a phenomenal blues player. You never hear it in his stuff. Phenomenal blues player. I was blown away, but he was really kind to me and he liked my playing too. And it was all great. And we just sort So I'm having this moment of like, hey, I'm, I'm making it, man. I'm with Chuck Berry. I'm playing the blues. It's great. This is life. Right. Okay. End of afternoon session. First gig. He launches into Roll Over Beethoven and he does his shtick. I mean, this is a 70-year-old or 60, late 60s-year-old man. He's doing splits on stage, the whole thing, right? And I mean, The man was in shape, let me tell you. And he's doing his thing and I'm just cranking behind him the way you're supposed to do it, keeping it right in there, everything. And he turns to me, he says, take it. There are news cameras, cuz this is his opening show, right? This is a big deal. And I'm like sucking it up stupidly. Let me get to that. So I, I wailed through the first chorus and I should have stopped right there. But oh no, I went on to the second chorus because the cameras are on me. I'm having my moment, right? I'm playing with Chuck Berry, I'm soloing, it's great. And he walks to the microphone about halfway through the chorus and says, ain't gonna let that guitar player steal my show.

46:02Chris Romeo Boom.

46:03Brook Schoenfield And I go right back. And that was the first and last solo I ever played with Chuck Berry.

46:09Matt Coles So wait, this is recorded somewhere? We can find this?

46:12Brook Schoenfield I imagine it is because it happened.

46:14Chris Romeo Oh God.

46:16Matt Coles Let's—

46:18Brook Schoenfield the rest of the gigs must be on the Internet Archive somewhere. I just did what I was supposed to do and played my lines like I'm supposed to play them, and there were no more solos.

46:31Izar Tarandach Oh, was the name of your band at this— what was the name of your band at the time?

46:35Brook Schoenfield I don't remember. Oh well, the band we came from was the Jackson Showfield— the Showfield Jackson African Jazz Ensemble.

46:44Matt Coles That must have been awesome. I'm thinking like Back to the Future. Yeah.

46:50Izar Tarandach Michael J. Fox.

46:52Brook Schoenfield Yeah.

46:52Matt Coles Everybody like stops and looks at him like, your kids are gonna love this stuff.

46:58Brook Schoenfield True story, man.

47:00Chris Romeo True.

47:00Brook Schoenfield Absolute 100% true story.

47:04Izar Tarandach You have stage presence. You worked well with them. They should have cast you as, uh, as, um, Marty McFly.

47:10Matt Coles Yep.

47:11Brook Schoenfield Yeah. I don't know how to act. I don't know how to hit the mark. I don't know how to keep my eyes open, you know, for the, for the camera.

47:19Izar Tarandach You could have been, you could have been the stunt, you could have been the stunt double. You could have been the stand-in.

47:23Brook Schoenfield Yeah.

47:24Chris Romeo Well, Brooke, that was, uh, yeah, that was great. Thank you for sharing those stories. I know I've had a chance to hear those before and I was like, I'm going to try to find a way to get those out so that others can hear. Cause there's more to life. but there's more to life than security, right? People can get so caught up in, this is what we do and it's about the industry and it's about, I'm an influencer and I'm this and I'm that and everybody's looking at me and there's so much more to life than what we do at work. Like, and that's why I love that story.

47:53Brook Schoenfield Can I tell you what playing jazz in San Francisco with some of the greatest players I've ever played with taught me? So, you know, here I am young. I was young. I was maybe 20, 25 or something, 28 when I played with Chuck and 23 when I played with Bo, you know, young, full of it, cocky, whatever. Um, years later, roll years later, and I'm playing with, with Joyce Baker, who is one of the greatest drummers again I've ever played with. Fabulous musician. Um, you can go and see Opie Bellis any old time you want. She plays with the monster players. She plays festivals. She's great. She's absolutely phenomenal singer. Um, and, uh, we had a couple of bass players that walked through that, that band, uh, with us. Um, most of them really great. Um, anyway, what I learned from playing with them for 5 years is it's about the ensemble, not about my solo. It's about the ensemble and how we support each other. So if, if Joyce just happens in the middle of something to drop into a reggae beat, you go into the right reggae guitar part and you make it really excellent. Absolutely excellent. Even though one would never expect that in the middle of a walking jazz solo. Or, you know, I remember one time Joyce was really mad cuz we were being replaced by a not, uh, almost said a, not a nice word, not a very good or skilled band, but they did covers and we were being replaced and Joyce was really mad at that gig. And I mean, oh my God, it was like sitting next to, um, it was like sitting next to, uh, uh, the Jones brother, um, the phenomenal drummer. I mean, it was just, it was so amazing. She's so good, but it was a bit loud and cantankerous. I can tell you. So you make that happen. Whatever's happening, you make it happen and you make it happen really good. And you're there in service to the whole sound. And when we do security, it's the same thing. We're in service to, to finding the risk tolerance that is appropriate and then serving that and reaching that. Not perfection, not close all risks. Sorry, folks. Not going to happen. Um, and it's impossible, but we're there in service to this larger goal. That, that, that it takes an ensemble to reach. And that's what playing in that band really, really taught me over those years is to give up on my ego so much and my worries and my insecurities and being out in front and just play the music as best as possible and make it sound great.

50:43Matt Coles And that comes super clear when we work with you, because that's the way that you work with us.

50:50Chris Romeo Yeah, I think we gotta end because that's the best place. But that's a great place to end. What would that, that with that message from Brooke? I don't, that's, that's what people need to take away from this. And so Brooke, thank you for being a part of the Security Table. And, uh, we'll do this again soon because this is, this is fun. I just, I like to hear stories. I like to hear the stories that you have. So we really, uh, we really do love you and, uh, Good, good. Forward to a future show again. Talk again.

51:16Brook Schoenfield You are really such amazing people. Never forget that.

Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.

Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.