The Department of No
With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles
We’re discussing the complexities of saying 'yes' or 'no' in the context of security decisions in today’s episode and the enduring challenge of integrating security into software development. The conversation swerves into the intriguing idea of a trade-like progression for developers, contrasting it with current knowledge work.
About this episode
We’re discussing the complexities of saying 'yes' or 'no' in the context of security decisions in today’s episode and the enduring challenge of integrating security into software development. The conversation swerves into the intriguing idea of a trade-like progression for developers, contrasting it with current knowledge work. The episode culminates in a hit parade of pop culture references, including Star Wars, Star Trek, Firefly, and more. Tune in for a thought-provoking and fun conversation!
Article Link: How to Say 'No' Well
Follow AI Security Table:
➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/
➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable
➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/
➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable
Transcript · 45 min conversation
0:11Chris Romeo Hey folks, welcome to another episode of the Security Table where we are pondering the fact, or not even the fact, but the idea that is ISAR a GenAI? Yes. Is this just a video feed we're seeing that's being generated by a GenAI? And then just based on some statements he made about being quantum a few seconds ago before we—
0:36Izar Tarandach My name from now on is Mean Headroom.
0:40Chris Romeo Mean Headroom.
0:41Izar Tarandach You know, you know.
0:44Matt Coles Yeah, but where's the, where's the choppy video? Yeah. And, and the, and the funky background.
0:53Izar Tarandach Uh, yeah, that's beyond my—
0:55Matt Coles if you know, you know.
0:56Chris Romeo Yeah, I know, you know. Was that a movie?
0:59Matt Coles That was a TV series, unfortunately, on MTV.
1:02Chris Romeo Was that an HBO show though?
1:04Matt Coles No, MTV.
1:05Chris Romeo It was MTV.
1:07Matt Coles It was MTV.
1:07Izar Tarandach You've got to win some micro—
1:09Matt Coles if it, if it was on, if it was on MTV, on, on HBO, it would probably would have been a lot better and it would have ruined it.
1:18Chris Romeo I just remember it, but I don't remember any of the context of it.
1:21Matt Coles Of course, because it's just that memory. It's just the talking head that you remember.
1:24Chris Romeo It's just like Max Headroom. Max Headroom. I don't remember what he did. Did he solve crime or did he kill zombies or what did he do?
1:35Matt Coles There was some live action part.
1:37Izar Tarandach It was a TV series between 1987 and 1988.
1:40Matt Coles Yeah, it was on for one season or two seasons.
1:42Izar Tarandach Really? Yeah.
1:46Matt Coles Yeah.
1:46Izar Tarandach Good time.
1:47Chris Romeo Interesting. Okay. I don't even, I, I just couldn't remember the context of what it was.
1:51Izar Tarandach So, 20 minutes in the future, the world had become imbued with network television. It's illegal to turn off your TV and televisions are given to the needy. In this world, Network 23 has a wide-rated news program with a roving reporter called Edison Carter, blah, blah, blah, plots to cover up later births. Almost killed. Yeah.
2:11Matt Coles Yeah. He's, he's RoboCop for news. I was gonna say it's, it's, it's, um, what's the, it's RoboCop and, uh, something else. My God, what the hell was it? Anyway. Yeah, it's, it was, it was okay.
2:27Chris Romeo Based on that description, I, I, I literally tuned out to what you were reading after about one sentence and I, oh, so you got it.
2:35Matt Coles You, you need, you need the pic, you need the image. You need the image of Max Headroom.
2:38Chris Romeo I remember the image of Max Headroom, but that description. Transcription was like, wow, this sounds really boring, which is probably what the audience thought too. Okay, so let's set up what we want to talk about here, cuz we've got an article. Often we do as inspiration, and I just have to find the article. Okay. The article's title is How to Say No Well, and it literally has a picture of Scooby-Doo. I just noticed. In the, in the little blog post picture. So I don't know, is that like, I don't know. I mean, maybe there's a Scooby-Doo reference in here somewhere.
3:15Matt Coles I mean, if you look at it closely, which finger is he holding up?
3:19Chris Romeo Is it the middle one?
3:20Matt Coles Which one is he?
3:21Chris Romeo First, it's the index finger.
3:23Matt Coles It is, but it looks really close.
3:24Chris Romeo Wait, wait. Yeah, but dogs don't have fingers. Hold on, hold on. Stop the presses.
3:29Izar Tarandach Yeah, but no, no, it's, it's starting, it's starting as a question.
3:32Matt Coles Scooby, Scooby-Doo, Scooby does, Scooby-Doo does have fingers. We've, we've seen this in the episodes. Yes, absolutely.
3:36Chris Romeo Dogs don't have ears.
3:39Izar Tarandach Dogs don't have fingers, but Scooby-Doo.
3:44Chris Romeo All right, so here's a crazy idea. Scooby-Doo is actually an alien. He was a dog.
3:52Matt Coles Remove the mask.
3:52Izar Tarandach He could talk.
3:53Chris Romeo He could say zoinkers and rrow.
3:57Matt Coles Rrow.
3:58Izar Tarandach Rrow.
3:58Chris Romeo Yeah, exactly. Have you seen the—
4:00Matt Coles have you seen the YouTube videos of dogs that speak more than, more than a few words?
4:04Chris Romeo and I think they're aliens as well. This is, this is very quickly turning into a paranormal podcast.
4:10Matt Coles So we can, we can, we can, we can, uh, we can get a whole new demographic of people here.
4:15Chris Romeo Just, I'm not going to say it was aliens, but it was— was it Agent Scully or Mulder who said the truth is out there?
4:25Izar Tarandach I want to believe, but I don't know who.
4:29Chris Romeo Whole other episode. All right, so this article says how to say no well. And this, I'll read the first sentence. Security's push to avoid being a department of no has overcorrected. And they do, one of the things I was chuckling about, they do make fun about the fact that lately every B-side seems to have a talk on avoiding the no and reframing security teams as a department of yes.
4:54Matt Coles Be an enabler, not a roadblock.
4:57Chris Romeo Why do we have to be so positive? Like, what's wrong with no? I like saying no. I happen to enjoy it. I enjoy seeing the looks on people's faces when I say no. Yeah.
5:07Izar Tarandach But every time that you say that, I, I get a, a glimpse of Martin Sheen on his knees going, oh, and well, that's a completely different scenario, you know? Yeah. It's just not what, what happens.
5:18Chris Romeo None shall pass.
5:19Matt Coles None shall pass is the better reference.
5:22Chris Romeo But even, even before we get to security, like, I like saying no. I find myself, I just passed, I'm, I've just passed over the 50-year mark of, of life. I'm 51 now.
5:35Matt Coles And now you're curmudgeonly.
5:37Chris Romeo I say no a lot more than I say yes, because what I find, here's what I find. You guys tell me if you have this same experience. Okay. Somebody will ask me about something. They will say, hey, in 6 months, do you want to do this? And I'm always past, you know, before 50-year-old me is always like, yeah, that sounds great. And then do you know exactly what happens? You get to the, we get to the week before the event and I'm like, why did I say that I would do this? Why? I do not want to travel to Istanbul to speak to, I love, I mean, I don't have a problem with Istanbul. It was the first thing that came to my mind. Like, I don't want to fly to Istanbul for 27 hours. To speak to, you know, uh, 5 people in a hotel conference room. Oh, let's meet up or something. And so what I, what I realize now though is like, I just need to say no up front. So I say no up front a lot more to things now because I think about, I factor it through future me. I look at future me shaking my fist going, why did you say you would do this?
6:43Matt Coles As long as, at least you're, at least you're consistent and you're clear as opposed to, uh, let's see what happens in 3 months from now.
6:51Chris Romeo But here's the thing. Check in with me after the holidays.
6:54Izar Tarandach Here's the thing. You just perfectly exemplified the thing. For good or bad, the security department is the adult in the room. You have all the developers running around, shiny things and going, let's write this, let's write the other one, let's give this kind of capability. And the security is going, no, no, no, don't touch that. Let that drop it. Drop it.
7:15Matt Coles Don't put that in your mouth. You don't know where that's been.
7:19Izar Tarandach So, you know, as the adult in the room, once upon a time, it was great to say no, or I'm going to smack you through the head. But nowadays you can't. So you just have to say nice nos, letting people know that their ideas are valued, being listened to. That, yeah, sure, why not? But, uh, at the end of the day, the buck stops with security.
7:46Matt Coles Does it?
7:47Izar Tarandach It does.
7:47Matt Coles It really? Yeah.
7:48Izar Tarandach Yeah. Yeah. It used to. It used to. My new philosophy is I am great at identifying risk. You own it. I'm not waking up at 3 in the morning because of your risk. I'm going to tell you that it exists. You're going to sign off on it, but you own it.
8:05Matt Coles This goes back to, we've, we've, we've had this conversation about DevSecOps and, and ownership and accountability. And capability, right? So yeah, we definitely in security find problems. We identify risk and we communicate that to the business. Business does own it because ultimately they're going to make the decision based on what security says today. Are we really giving them the capability by not being truthful with them? So if we say yes all the time, then obviously we're not looked at as a roadblock in any way, shape, or form. But are we really giving the right information to make a truly informed decision? As opposed to, as opposed to, well, we don't recommend you do that, AKA no, but—
9:02Izar Tarandach Well, no, no, no, that's the thing. You just said no, but that's not what you're saying.
9:08Matt Coles You're saying yes, but I'm not, you're like, you're saying, hey, you know what?
9:12Izar Tarandach You want to do this thing?
9:13Matt Coles Sure.
9:14Izar Tarandach Why not?
9:14Chris Romeo But no, I know Matt, like, to do first, his personality is more likely saying no, but here's why. Whereas I would, I would agree in general, Izar, I think the principle you're, you're, you're sharing is correct. I think Matt is a unique individual who is actually thinking no, but.
9:35Izar Tarandach How can I make this a positive as opposed to, but Matt is the good one.
9:39Chris Romeo He's always been the nice one out of this group. Matt is the nice one, which is very frightening.
9:45Matt Coles Mm-hmm.
9:45Chris Romeo Very frightening.
9:47Izar Tarandach You know, uh, I, I'm reminded, and let's date ourselves yet again. I'm reminded of a, a line in The Island of Dr. No, it was called, the James Bond movie where James Bond, no, no, no, you're, you're mixing.
10:01Matt Coles You're mixing two movies, Island of Dr. Moreau and Dr. No.
10:05Chris Romeo It's Dr. No.
10:06Matt Coles Yeah.
10:07Izar Tarandach So it's Dr. No. And, and James Bond is like, he's, he's, he's stapled to the wall.
10:14Matt Coles Add a third movie in there.
10:16Izar Tarandach No, he's stapled to the wall.
10:18Chris Romeo Treasure Island. No, Love Boat.
10:20Matt Coles No, Treasure Island. Treasure Island.
10:21Chris Romeo Yeah. Treasure Island. Okay.
10:22Izar Tarandach Okay. So Dr. No and James Bond is stapled to the, to the wall and Dr. No is going through his plans as nefarious.
10:30Matt Coles No, no, wait, isn't he on the table with the laser?
10:33Izar Tarandach No, no, no. That, that, that, that laser is the other one. The laser is with the sharks.
10:37Chris Romeo That's Austin Powers.
10:39Izar Tarandach And oh, that's the name I was trying to remember. Anyway, so, so he, he's in the wall and, and Dr. No is going through his nefarious plans as those guys are want to do.
10:51Matt Coles Oh, obviously.
10:51Izar Tarandach Yes.
10:52Matt Coles They have to reveal the whole plan just before they—
10:54Chris Romeo wait, wait, wait.
10:54Izar Tarandach Here's the Ranger and James Bond goes. But what do you expect me to do? And he turns to the camera and says, I expect you to die, Mr. Bond. I expect you to die. So it's basically, they come to us and say, I want to do this. And we say, no. And they say, so what do you want me to do?
11:11Matt Coles And then the next line is, I expect you to die.
11:14Chris Romeo That's what we're supposed to tell them?
11:18Izar Tarandach But sometimes, so you think of—
11:19Chris Romeo Is that the moral of the story? That we're supposed to tell the people we work with, we expect you to die.
11:24Izar Tarandach No, no, no, no. The risk, the risk, the risk would leave the project to not succeed.
11:31Matt Coles You have to, you have to say, you have to erase that feature from your PRD.
11:35Izar Tarandach Stink.
11:37Matt Coles You idiot.
11:38Chris Romeo Okay, so let's, let's get back to this department of no thing low. Like, I think that, that there are, this article does have some correctness in that we have overcorrected so far into we have to be, we have to be cognizant of everybody's feelings and we don't want anyone That's what, that's what he, that's what the article said. Oh, you're just, you're practicing. Okay.
12:02Matt Coles I see.
12:02Chris Romeo No, but I mean, that's, that's, that's what it's saying is like, you can't say no because it's good. And, and the article even described it, the, the inverse of this as shades of toxic positivity where we prioritize harmony over hard truths, risk acceptance as a cargo cult. I don't know what a cargo cult is.
12:23Matt Coles Wait, wait, that's an, is our term.
12:24Izar Tarandach I tried to explain.
12:25Matt Coles Okay.
12:26Chris Romeo Hold on. Let's, okay. So let's, let's unpack the whole thing though. So, so shades of toxic positivity. I can honestly say that is not something anyone has ever accused me of in my entire life of being too positive. Like you're just too positive. That was too positive of an answer.
12:41Izar Tarandach Don't, don't you have ponies in the farm?
12:44Chris Romeo No, no, no, no, no ponies yet.
12:48Matt Coles You're positively positive.
12:50Chris Romeo Is this something? Is this something that's like generational?
12:54Matt Coles It must be. I mean, we're, we're all of that age that you described earlier.
13:00Izar Tarandach It's probably a side effect of, uh, crypto fairy dust. People, people believe too much and they start flying around.
13:07Chris Romeo Crypto fairy dust. Is that where you snort blockchain or, or Bitcoin or like, I'm, uh, I'm, no, no, no.
13:14Izar Tarandach It's from before. It's, it's when you script it, uh, when you just, uh, put SSL and everything and all of a sudden you're—
13:20Matt Coles TLS gives you wings.
13:22Izar Tarandach Yeah, it does. It does.
13:24Chris Romeo That's true though. It does.
13:26Matt Coles It does.
13:26Chris Romeo It makes you more powerful.
13:27Matt Coles It does. Encryption solves everything, right?
13:30Chris Romeo It solves a lot. It does solve a lot. I miss— other than when the quantum computers can break all the encryption.
13:37Matt Coles You know, so there, there—
13:38Chris Romeo all right.
13:39Matt Coles So just ignoring the article for just a moment, there is another way to go. And you can, you could go with the 5 whys. Why do you want to do that? Yeah.
13:48Chris Romeo Why?
13:48Matt Coles Just ask why.
13:51Izar Tarandach So that's the thing. Lately I've been working with 3 whys and I noticed that whenever I bring risk—
13:56Chris Romeo I thought you said 3 wives. I'm like, wait, what?
14:02Matt Coles Did you move to Utah?
14:05Chris Romeo I mean, but you said the 3 whys.
14:07Izar Tarandach Okay.
14:07Matt Coles 3, 1, 4.
14:08Chris Romeo Let me just clarify.
14:09Izar Tarandach One is so hard and enjoy. I just don't have the energy for more than one.
14:15Matt Coles We're gonna, we're gonna get canceled so bad.
14:17Chris Romeo No, no, people don't cancel. You don't get canceled anymore.
14:21Matt Coles Oh, that's right.
14:21Chris Romeo No, canceling is canceling is canceled.
14:23Izar Tarandach So anyway, 3 questions that evoke the reason for doing something. Okay. So the point is. Somebody comes to me and says, I want to do this. And I tell them, here's the risk. Here's the chances that it's gonna happen. And here's what I would prefer you to do. And their first question is, why? And I answer, usually saying, why do I believe that that's going to happen? The second question, surprisingly, is why? Because now they're asking, how do I know the thing that I'm saying? And the third question is surprise, surprise. Why, why do I think that what I know is actually going to happen? And I noticed that if I let it get to the third one, I basically lost it.
15:13Matt Coles Because they're, they're going, they are going back with you, right? They're pushing on your boundaries.
15:18Izar Tarandach But not only that, at some point I have to give up the fact that I don't have data to support what I'm saying past my experience and indicators here and there.
15:30Matt Coles You should always have a backup. You should always have a backup.
15:32Chris Romeo Security using the 3 Ys on you as a security person.
15:36Izar Tarandach Basically, yeah.
15:37Chris Romeo Yeah.
15:38Matt Coles But if you're going to be a security person, you should start with why. Don't start with yes or no. Start with why.
15:44Izar Tarandach That is true. That is true. You're telling them, hey, listen, you should check your input because if you don't, injection things will happen, right? But then they come to you and say, why? And I'm like, because people want to do bad things to your system. So bad things will happen. And they go back to why? Well, because there is a motive in here and they are going to get something out of it. And he's going, why? And if you got to that third why, then the discussion has gotten to a point where no substantial arguments that you bring can be made to bypass the fact that they completely ignore the risk and they completely ignore the, the fact that somebody is willing to do that bad thing.
16:27Matt Coles No, no. I, I think, well, maybe, maybe I'll say maybe here because there's an alternative. They don't know. There's a knowledge gap.
16:39Chris Romeo Yeah.
16:39Matt Coles You should be using this as a learning opportunity.
16:42Izar Tarandach Then it's a discussion from authority. You have to do this because I'm telling you, and I know, but again, I can't bring it to the table.
16:51Matt Coles So you want to strong-arm the developers is what you're saying.
16:54Chris Romeo That's what we used to do.
16:55Izar Tarandach No, no, I want them to be Boy Scouts and do it because it's the right thing to do.
17:02Chris Romeo Ah, but you know what though? That's, that's the thing we've been talking about. So this, I'm going to throw a whole other, a whole other grenade into the closet here. That's something we've been talking about for 20 years. As long as OWASP has been around is when I can draw the lineage to this. We haven't really won anything.
17:24Izar Tarandach Don't get me started on OWASP developers.
17:27Chris Romeo We have used this for 20 years now. Yeah, but I wasn't aiming at OWASP. I was just saying, I was using OWASP as a yardstick to how long the problem space has existed. And my point is, have we really achieved much in this developer-centric security thing of getting developers to own security?
17:49Matt Coles How many, how many CVEs a year? I mean, if we're on an exponential, exponential path here.
17:56Izar Tarandach Forget about that. How many security questions are being asked when a developer is being interviewed for a job?
18:02Matt Coles Yeah.
18:03Chris Romeo So I guess the question is, have we lost or have we, did we just do, do we need to do something different?
18:10Matt Coles We're pushing the, we're pushing the rock sideways, not up.
18:13Izar Tarandach We haven't lost, but I think that we are at yet another inflection point with the whole AI thing that we've been hearing about, where for 20, 30 years we've been trying to get developers to do the right thing, but we have focused on Building the science, building the art, building the things that we do as security and ops teams. And occasionally reaching out to the other side and saying, hey, could you do this thing together with me? Or could you do this thing by yourself? Now we are on this inflection point where people are looking around and saying, soon we will have no more developers. I swear, I hope that never happens. But, uh, the code that's being generated is bad. And the people who are reading the code to see if it's bad. Are looking for the wrong things that we would look for. So we are at this tip point that I think that if we don't, if we miss this one again, it's going to take a long time to recover and a lot of energy to recover.
19:12Chris Romeo So AI is not the solution then. Hell no. So we're kind of, we're admitting, I'm admitting, I'm throwing on the table here. We've been at this for 25 plus years. And we really haven't made a dent in developer-centric security. What is—
19:31Izar Tarandach we have created tools and we have created workflows, but they haven't been instituted.
19:38Chris Romeo So we've done, yeah, we've done, we've done things, we've done things, but it had— my point is we have not changed behavior.
19:45Matt Coles They're Band-Aids at this point.
19:47Izar Tarandach Exactly.
19:47Chris Romeo Behavior has not changed. Why? What do we need to do differently then? We need to go unlock this, this missing behavior change.
19:59Matt Coles We need to go, we, we need to go back. We, we've, we, I think we've talked about this before as well. We need to get that into course curriculums at the high school and college level.
20:11Chris Romeo I mean, that's, that's a 10-year. Is it a 10-year?
20:15Matt Coles You asked what we need to do. Yeah.
20:18Chris Romeo Great.
20:19Matt Coles So there's an option is get developers early.
20:21Chris Romeo What I've, what I've found, oh, right. Executive order. There we go. That, that'll save the world. Boom. What a, what a, but the, see, I think the part of the challenge with that, but that is put tariffs on bad code. That's a good idea. We'll do that. But, but to your point though, like changing the university system, well, And that's something I've said for, for a long time as well. Like, I think it's, I think it's what we need to do. Do I think it's possible? Anything is possible. Do I think it's easy? No, because those people don't— every time I try to reach out to academia to say, hey, I'm somebody in industry and I would love to help influence the next generation, I get crickets because they don't want people, they don't want people like us coming into their playground.
21:07Izar Tarandach No, that, that's not it. That's not it because their playground is a completely different sphere.
21:12Chris Romeo For them, they think it is.
21:14Izar Tarandach Academia does not produce developers.
21:17Chris Romeo No, true.
21:19Izar Tarandach Well, they are working on a completely different set of things.
21:22Chris Romeo It should, it should produce developers.
21:25Izar Tarandach I had to refute somebody asking me, hey, why doesn't this conference have an academic track? And I had to explain to them that I don't want to be listening about people saying that if a firewall was a perfect sphere in a vacuum, then this and this other thing would happen. That, that, that's not how shit works in the real world, right?
21:43Matt Coles So here's the other challenge. You target, we focus on the wrong people. So if we're going to those co— to those colleges or wherever you're, you often, you're going for computer science programs, but computer science people are not developers.
21:56Izar Tarandach Exactly.
21:57Matt Coles You need the forestry folks. You need the botanist folks. You need biology folks. You need political science folks. Those are the ones. Who are producing developers these days.
22:07Izar Tarandach Uh, there I'm going to disagree.
22:10Chris Romeo Mm-hmm.
22:10Matt Coles Go ahead.
22:11Izar Tarandach I think that you had the solution when you started talking about it, going to high school. The same way that there is a push, at least in this country, for people to think twice before going to an academic career and go more to the practical stuff. Electricians, plumbers, all that kind of thing. My point is that now with the changes that we are seeing, and I don't want to touch on the honor and pride of anybody here, but I think that we are going to see developers taking the side of a more practical craft. And the same way that you have master plumbers, you're going to have master developers because those are people who are going to be writing code closer to the machine, while a lot of lofty people are going to research and push out prototypes that are going to be developed over time into products and stuff like that.
23:10Chris Romeo So I think that that's the best part. I don't know that I, I don't know that I, I don't, I, I, I don't, I don't agree in general with what you're saying. Like, this is knowledge work versus, like, white collar versus blue collar. You can say you don't like those terms or whatever. It is what it is.
23:25Matt Coles It's, it's a cultural office work versus office work versus, uh, versus warehouse work or whatever. Yeah.
23:32Chris Romeo But, but that's not true for— there is a difference. There, there is certainly electrician, plumber, HVAC people. I love those people. I think they're, I think, and that's what I recommend that, that like kids that don't know what they want to do with their lives, that's what I recommend they do. And, and for real, because think about it, how old is, how old is the person who provides those services for you. Mine are all in their 60s.
23:56Izar Tarandach I have respect for those people. Yeah. Yeah.
23:58Chris Romeo Mine are in their 60s. They're very successful people because everybody looks down on them, but they make over $1 million a year cuz they have 3 trucks that roll. And, but my point is it's a development, becoming a developer is something that is at a different level of knowledge working than electrician, plumbing, HVAC. And I'm, I'm not lean, I'm not looking down on those people, but think about how much has elec— being an electrician changed in the last 10 years? Like how much has it evol— how much has the knowledge base of a, of an electrician, uh, evolved in the last 10 years?
24:37Matt Coles There's, there's some with, with, with smart homes and, and other devices.
24:41Izar Tarandach Yeah.
24:41Chris Romeo But in general, you still wire a house the same way.
24:44Izar Tarandach Right.
24:44Chris Romeo You wire a panel the same way. Let's turn that back to you.
24:47Izar Tarandach Auto mechanics, auto mechanics have changed completely.
24:50Chris Romeo Well, they have the, the way they diagnose problems has changed. They still gotta take the brake pads off and put the brake pads on.
24:58Izar Tarandach What has changed is they have to understand the codes. They have to understand why the computer's not working. They have to understand what to do.
25:04Chris Romeo Uh, I think they just, in general, they replace the computers. They don't, they don't troubleshoot the, but it's, it's how they get the diagnos— it's how they get diagnostics. But my, my general point is. A developer is always going to be different than an electrician because just because in the developer's world, the, what their, their knowledge that the things they need to know are evolving at an exponential rate, new frameworks come out, new languages, but the way that they, the way that they learn should be the same.
25:34Izar Tarandach You don't need a developer spending their first year thinking if epsilon is, uh, small as we want and it goes close to infinity, then what happens to this function?
25:46Chris Romeo Yeah. I mean, nobody does that in the real world, but they, but they should have the same pipeline as a plumber or a, uh, so you're saying from like a career progression, like a guild, because I've heard that, like, I have a, I have a friend that runs a software development company here in, uh, the Raleigh-Durham area. And they have this, this, uh, they have that idea. They, they, they practice from a software development perspective what you are describing here. They call it their Software Development Guild and you start as an apprentice and you make your way up through a progression to become a, I don't think they call it a master, come a master coder anymore. I don't remember what they, they have a term for like the top, when you get to the top upper echelon of. and part of it is your own knowledge and experience and ability, and part of it is bringing other people along, being a teacher of other, because like you can't say you're a, uh, a top anything if you can't teach other people how to do it, right? At some point, make them better.
26:50Izar Tarandach A milestone for, for those stepping stones needs to be your code is safe, your code is secure.
26:56Chris Romeo So, oh no, you just had to throw that into, yeah. Totally, because I, I actually, I really kind of want to ju—
27:03Matt Coles think about this a little bit more, touch upon this a bit more. This actually sounds really interesting. So today, if you, if you're in a soft— if you're in a company that does software development, and we should probably preface this with, I, I imagine there are companies, there are large companies and some, and mid and small companies that, that have actual developer, um, developer as an engineering role. With a proper progression from junior engineer all the way up to some senior top-level engineer. And there's a, a scale that has measurable milestones and whatnot. But a vast portion of companies, I imagine, don't. They have developers who come in for certain jobs and they don't have an engineering function. They don't have a, a, a role for that normally. I, I would imagine there are some, at least a that don't do that. So if we, so let's, let's first start with take a, take a company that has a regular engineering function. If you switch it out, switch that to an apprenticeship type or trade type progression, does anything change? And ignore for a moment if you change the curriculum or change the requirements, because that's, that will change it automatically. But, you know, if we just change it up to make it more like the progression from a plumber or from electrician, does anything change? What do you, what do you keep in? What do you, what do you put out? Right? So for instance, does, is architecture and design part of the developer track? Part of that developer process?
28:35Chris Romeo You're getting into the, the curriculum side of it. I think the, the big challenge with a pro, with something like that is, can the organization, or is the organization willing to accept it? Because one of the things I saw at a big, and I'm going to say the name this time around, the big technology company that I might perhaps used to work at was they had a very well-defined career ladder progression for every job role. But the challenge was there were only so many slots in a given 300-person organization that were available every calendar year. So you could have 2 people on your direct team of 10 out of an organization, out of the organization size of 300 that were just killing it. But could you, couldn't get those 2 people promoted at the same time, even though you had the career ladder, the progression, everything made sense.
29:27Matt Coles Yep.
29:27Chris Romeo It was a battle royale just to get the one person promoted up that ladder. Right. And so my point is, it doesn't matter what we call the system and how beautiful the system is, if the organization doesn't stand behind it. It won't work. It won't be any different than what happens to them.
29:45Matt Coles Right now, having said that, the apprenticeship program or the, or the, sorry, the, the electrician plumber program is not company dependent. It's industry dependent.
29:55Chris Romeo True. True. Right. It's accepted way that they train people in that particular industry. Correct. Yeah.
30:02Matt Coles And so would that work? And if that becomes a vehicle for Introducing new types of skills or reinforcing certain skills. And this is, this is upending how business works today, right? If we were to even, if, if this was even possible, but highly unlikely. But would that work? Would that be a meaningful path? Basically put coders, developers, architects, engineers into a process. By which the industry would, would allow a progression. And then we get consistency across the industry because there would be standards. The other thing is electrician— electricians and plumbers have standards. They have individual code, like codes exist across— codes exist across communities. And you could think about codes or policies existing across companies, but the standards are the same.
31:00Chris Romeo I don't even know who sets those standards, like from an electrician perspective, like who defines what an apprentice is versus a journeyman versus a master electrician.
31:11Izar Tarandach They have like a guilds and the guild sets the standard. Yeah, I think so.
31:18Chris Romeo Doing some research here on the fly cause yeah, I don't know. I, I like, I, I, I like the idea.
31:24Izar Tarandach Yeah, that's right. We, OSHA.
31:29Matt Coles OSHA sets it. OSHA sets safety standards. Um, maybe it's by state. Oh, that would be, that would be bad.
31:37Izar Tarandach I wouldn't be surprised.
31:39Matt Coles Uh, National Electric Code.
31:41Chris Romeo So the electricians have a code of, uh, a code to be the rules of how you do electricity. Oh, it is a determined by state. Provincial or local licensing boards. Yeah.
31:55Matt Coles So maybe that would be a challenge.
31:57Chris Romeo Yeah. So it's not, so the, so the electrician, even so there, so there may be more diversity in the standards of what a journeyman electrician is than we realize as outsiders who aren't electricians.
32:08Izar Tarandach Mm-hmm.
32:09Chris Romeo State by state, city by city. It's kind of like law.
32:13Matt Coles It's kind of like law then. Law is state by state.
32:16Chris Romeo I always thought it was standard. If you would've asked me before this conversation, like what defines an apprentice electrician, I would've said, oh, there's a, there's some standard somewhere that defines what it is. But it turns out there isn't. It's very determined by where you live.
32:30Matt Coles Yeah. That's interesting. So that, that is very much, so, le— law is that way too, right? There's a base sort of, everyone knows the same law, but then each state has potentially their own bar requirements.
32:42Chris Romeo I didn't know that either. So maybe we're breaking our own model here. That we thought was going to be such a perfect answer.
32:49Matt Coles Well, instead of it, instead of it being state by state, it's company by company today, right?
32:56Chris Romeo Yeah. And that's the challenge is you can't get companies to agree about anything, much less take the dedicate the time to say we're going to create a system of growth for our engineers.
33:07Matt Coles And herein we just invented the reason why ISC² exists.
33:12Chris Romeo Oh man.
33:14Matt Coles Driving consistency across a set of individuals, right? That's—
33:18Izar Tarandach You had to go there.
33:19Matt Coles I had to because it is the answer, right? Oh, I know. I see where it is.
33:26Izar Tarandach One answer and a bad one.
33:28Matt Coles It could be. It could be, but it fits the niche that we're talking about, right? Of there are different standards for what it means to be a junior versus senior engineer across different companies. How do you get consistency of, of capability? You make a certification process.
33:48Izar Tarandach It does, but I have to ask again, did they— okay, they haven't gone to developers. They, they are still security people.
33:58Matt Coles Well, it's, and it's because it's cost prohibitive and time prohibitive in part, but also developers are not full-time security people, right? I mean, this is, this is the co— this is the certification process. If there was a different certification process for developers, and by the way, Is there one? Is there an IC² for developers? Not for security, but for just how to code?
34:18Chris Romeo I think so. I don't think so.
34:21Matt Coles I don't think so either. And if there, but if there were, why wouldn't you make, you know, like, like there are, um, domains for the CSSLP or the CISSP, why not have domains that could include security and privacy for developers?
34:37Izar Tarandach Because it slows them down. No, we can't slow them down.
34:40Matt Coles It doesn't slow them down if it's part of their base knowledge.
34:44Izar Tarandach There is no base knowledge. Base knowledge is, can you, can you pass this interview? That's the base knowledge.
34:49Matt Coles That's, that's how you get into the job, but then you have to be able to code.
34:53Izar Tarandach That's not the thing that everybody wants.
34:54Chris Romeo There are a lot of developer-focused certifications that are not security related though. Like, think about the various cloud providers have their own little certifications now. Like, you can be Red Hat certified, you can be And these are not security things.
35:11Matt Coles These are just general, that, that's, that's, do you know the portfolio and do you know how to, what they go, what they, it's really how do you, when should you apply this versus that? I mean, it, yeah, it doesn't necessarily tell you how to make rockstar bulletproof code. And I don't mean security bulletproof. I mean, like, you know, functional, but, um, but those are mostly marketing certifications more so than.
35:36Chris Romeo I mean, they, they, yeah, they, uh, not to, not to devalue anyone, uh, anyone's certificates that they have, but ChatGPT does say like organizations like IEEE or the British Computer Society have had certifications or credentials aimed at validating certain software engineering skills. So there's, I didn't know that.
35:58Matt Coles They exist.
35:59Chris Romeo I didn't know that's what IEEE did.
36:00Izar Tarandach I had no clue.
36:03Matt Coles I mean, it makes sense. I mean, ACM, right? American Computing Machinery or Association of Computing Machinery.
36:09Chris Romeo Yeah.
36:10Matt Coles Um, makes sense. It makes sense that they would have those. I mean, that's, and then you have ISO standards, right? That could be a baseline.
36:18Chris Romeo But it's, it's funny that, that, that those haven't taken off like the security certifications of the world have.
36:24Matt Coles Somebody is a good, somebody has sold security certifications as of value to the business. Because do you know why? It's the Kerberos problem. It's a third— it's a third party of trust. As a consumer, and you're, and you're a supplier, you can tell me that you're, that your developers are good, or that your security people are good, or I can trust this other organization that vouches for you. It's the PKI problem, right?
36:51Chris Romeo Passing off the trust to a third party.
36:53Matt Coles Outsourcing trust, which is how security works a lot today. TLS works that way today. SSO.
37:01Izar Tarandach SSO.
37:01Matt Coles Yep. Mutual, uh, um, OAuth, right?
37:05Chris Romeo So we haven't solved any problems. All we've done is circled around a number of problems. We haven't.
37:10Matt Coles We've avoided the question of yes or no.
37:13Chris Romeo No, we haven't.
37:15Izar Tarandach No, no, we haven't.
37:16Chris Romeo No, we have.
37:18Matt Coles Yes, we have.
37:19Izar Tarandach And I'll keep going with yes, but it's working for me. People seem to like it.
37:29Matt Coles You know, if you start with yes and then go with the but, what you're saying to the developer is, okay, I can go because they don't care about the but because it slows them down. You need to start with the no, but.
37:45Chris Romeo I heard somebody else describe it as yes, if.
37:49Izar Tarandach Yeah.
37:50Chris Romeo As a, as a different way. It's not yes, but it's like, it's yes, if you do this. So can I build this feature this way?
37:58Izar Tarandach Yes.
37:59Chris Romeo If you add multifactor authentication to it, because it's—
38:02Izar Tarandach Yes, but I need to do things before.
38:04Matt Coles And I would, I would switch that around to if yes, because again, yes.
38:12Chris Romeo Block. If yes, block. Yeah, gotcha. Go to the grocery store.
38:17Izar Tarandach Bring me, bring me bread. And if there were eggs, bring me two.
38:21Matt Coles If, if condition true, else false.
38:27Izar Tarandach Now you're speaking too much of their language. They'll think that you're one of them.
38:31Matt Coles Oh really? Is that a problem?
38:34Chris Romeo All right. I can't hang up on this episode until I understand what a cargo cult is. And so Isar was going to explain this to me. So it's in the article. Hold on, just in case this is about to get me in trouble. And it says risk acceptance as cargo cult as one of the reasons about security saying no.
38:52Izar Tarandach And we have spoken about this before. Because I had to explain this like a thousand times and I can't understand why. A cargo cult. So the place is the Pacific. The time is the end of World War II. Natives in small islands had seen planes go by and drop, uh, supplies.
39:12Chris Romeo Oh, you did tell me this before.
39:14Izar Tarandach Okay. Keep going though.
39:15Chris Romeo You see, you people just don't think it's seriously enough to remind, remember.
39:18Izar Tarandach Yeah.
39:18Matt Coles New listeners.
39:19Chris Romeo We have new listeners in Australia, so yeah, go ask Google.
39:23Izar Tarandach Get off the treadmill and go ask Google.
39:25Matt Coles Wait, you can do, you can ask Google from the treadmill, you know, right? That we have the power. Oh, that's that, that, yeah, there's, we have the technology.
39:31Chris Romeo So that's right. So Cargo Cults, they thought that the natives thought that they were gods dropping things outta the planes.
39:38Izar Tarandach So they would build airstrips in order to call for the, the gods to come and deliver.
39:45Chris Romeo Yeah.
39:45Matt Coles So, so what do you want me to do? I want you to Google it, Mr. Bond.
39:50Chris Romeo How many movie references can we intermingle? The Island of Dr. Moreau saying no to Austin Powers.
39:59Izar Tarandach How many do you want?
40:01Matt Coles Huh? Han shot first.
40:04Chris Romeo That's true. Boba Fett's a movie, baby.
40:07Izar Tarandach That's what it is.
40:07Chris Romeo Is that the, uh, what was that called? What was it called? The new one, the new Star Wars show where it was about the bounty hunter guy.
40:15Matt Coles Mandalorian.
40:17Izar Tarandach There is no, there is no new Star Wars.
40:21Chris Romeo You don't even want, you don't even want to get into that in my opinion.
40:24Izar Tarandach Star Wars.
40:24Chris Romeo Save that for a different episode.
40:26Izar Tarandach This is not the show that you want to watch.
40:28Matt Coles Assassin.
40:30Chris Romeo Because you know this whole Star Wars thing, I just don't get everybody's appreciation of it. I don't understand it.
40:36Matt Coles Star Trek is way better, but Star—
40:39Chris Romeo I agree. Star Trek is so much more cerebral. It's kind of like an intellectual show. I never watched Battlestar Galactica.
40:45Matt Coles Babylon 5.
40:47Izar Tarandach Babylon 5.
40:48Chris Romeo Wasn't that just the rotating space station thing?
40:52Matt Coles Well, they had gravity. Oh yeah. It was, it was rotating cuz they had gravity. More importantly, Babylon 5 was the precursor to Battlestar Galactica—
41:02Chris Romeo uh-uh, wait what?
41:05Izar Tarandach Battlestar Galactica '80s!
41:08Matt Coles Oh yeah, true.
41:08Izar Tarandach Was the answer to Star Wars and Babylon 5 was the answer to Star Trek without the whole let's be peaceful thing. Yes. And being blown by lasers every episode.
41:21Chris Romeo Wait, wait, wait.
41:22Izar Tarandach It wasn't Babylon 5.
41:23Matt Coles DS9 was definitely not the, uh, let's be DS9 and Babylon 5 were very similar.
41:28Chris Romeo Was Babylon 5 part of the Star Trek universe?
41:30Matt Coles No, no, no. And it was, and it was not part of the Battlestar Galactica universe either, but it was, it's very similar. It was very independent, but a very similar.
41:40Izar Tarandach Babylon 5 came out at the same time that SGI came out with the Indigo boxes. Mm-hmm. And that put, uh, special effects at the hands of everybody.
41:49Matt Coles Oh my God. Yeah.
41:50Izar Tarandach For the life of me, Babylon 5 used those things every, every episode. Every episode. Uh, and if you happen to be working with Indigos at the time, you would look at it and like, am I still at work?
42:04Matt Coles And, uh, I mean, J, JMS, J. Michael Straczynski was masterful. He had mapped out the entire 5 or 6 season show. And then when it got canceled at season 4, made a little bit of a challenge. What do you do? Or maybe it was canceled season— it was canceled like with almost the last episode. Last season available, and, and they had the movies.
42:25Izar Tarandach You, you know what, the movies.
42:26Chris Romeo You know what show I'm still so annoyed that it ended the way that it did?
42:32Matt Coles Warehouse 13.
42:33Izar Tarandach If you don't say Firefly, it was—
42:35Chris Romeo Firefly was only one season. It was called Last Man on Earth.
42:40Izar Tarandach That was a good—
42:41Chris Romeo it was— and I love those type of like post-apocalyptic, and this was a, this is a post-apocalyptic comedy With no monsters or anything. It's just people trying to survive after the, after when they're the last people on Earth.
42:55Izar Tarandach Mm-hmm.
42:55Chris Romeo But then they ended up canceling it. And so they had this cliffhanger, which wasn't a very good cliffhanger at the end of the final season where the people came up outta the ground, spoiler alert, wearing like gas masks or something. And then they canceled it and I'm like, kid, just gimme one more episode to wrap this thing up.
43:14Izar Tarandach It's left on Exercise to the reader, right? Yeah.
43:16Matt Coles So many, so many shows, so many shows that get canceled.
43:20Izar Tarandach Resident Alien.
43:21Matt Coles I'm into Resident Alien. Yep. That was a good one. Did it get canceled?
43:25Izar Tarandach That's really good. No, no, no, no. Oh, good. No, not that I know.
43:30Chris Romeo We hate when things get canceled.
43:31Matt Coles Yeah. Or, or what? Or rushed. I mean, Firefly got canceled and that was bad. Warehouse 13 got canceled, but they had a, a short season.
43:39Chris Romeo Did they do a movie? Warehouse 13 was closeouts. I thought they closed out Firefly. Didn't he make a movie?
43:45Matt Coles Oh yeah. Serenity.
43:45Izar Tarandach They, they, they got to make a movie.
43:47Chris Romeo Yeah.
43:47Izar Tarandach And they killed, they killed the best.
43:50Matt Coles Yeah.
43:50Chris Romeo Yeah. 'Cause the, there was such a fan uprising though when they canceled Fireflies. People were like petitioning in front of the studios and stuff.
44:00Izar Tarandach No, they, they sent, they sent a ton of peanuts, I think, to the studio.
44:05Chris Romeo I believe they were, they were a pa— that was probably the most passionate fan base I've ever heard of as far as the, uh, the end of the show.
44:11Izar Tarandach It was a great show. Come on.
44:13Matt Coles It was.
44:13Chris Romeo Well, this has been a fun jaunt around the security table. We've covered about 50 different topics.
44:22Matt Coles And we avoided the question of yes and no.
44:25Chris Romeo So I just want to leave our audience with this. When in doubt, say no, because in 6 months, you don't want to do it.
44:33Matt Coles Wait, but if somebody asks if you're a god, you say yes.
44:37Izar Tarandach You say yes, but if yes, if you were in Thor's planet. Yes, but I'm on the fucking show right now. I'm not doing any miracles.
44:48Matt Coles As you wish.
44:52Izar Tarandach Oh, that's inconceivable.
44:54Chris Romeo There you go. All right. Well, thank you for tuning into this wild, wacky episode of the Security Table. Look forward to talking to you soon.
Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.
Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.
