46 min

The US National Cybersecurity Strategy - Introduction - Part One

With Chris Romeo, Izar Tarandach, and Matt Coles

Policy, regulation & software liability

The United States released a new National Cybersecurity Strategy. The gang gathers to discuss the new strategy and look at it from a practitioner's perspective.

Episode title image: The US National Cybersecurity Strategy - Introduction - Part One

Listen to the conversation

About this episode

The United States released a new National Cybersecurity Strategy. The gang gathers to discuss the new strategy and look at it from a practitioner's perspective. 

We discuss the impact and depth of the malicious actor section, with an increased emphasis on the nation-state and the details shared about nation-state adversaries.  We also get into a debate about a statement made regarding the dependence and need to be placed on the system instead of the end user to make security decisions. Is this strategy a call for big brother disguised as security improvements?

Is the US Government truly responsible for securing the Internet? Discussion and debate ensue.

We vowed to discuss the whole thing, and with this first episode, we got through the introduction. We will continue with additional episodes until we unpack the entire strategy.

Follow AI Security Table:

➜ Home: https://securitytable.ai/

➜ X: https://x.com/AISecurityTable

➜ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/ai-security-table/

➜ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AISecurityTable

Transcript · 46 min conversation

0:14Chris Romeo Hey folks, welcome to another episode of The Security Table. This is Chris Romeo. I'm also joined by Tanya Ward, Matt Coles, Izar Tarandash, all of my friends, what I collectively call the gang. Around the Security Table here.

0:29Matt Coles He calls us friends.

0:30Chris Romeo Yeah, of course.

0:32Tanya Ward This is—

0:32Chris Romeo we are all friends here until we start discussing and debating, and then sometimes it gets a little heated. That's okay. That's why we have the Security Table. And so just a really easy one today for us to deal with. I mean, the United States government came out with a National Cybersecurity Strategy, and so we could probably knock this out in like 5 minutes. I mean, it's not that complicated. Literally only like 35 pages or something. So, it's in the world of government documents, it's actually pretty short. But there's a lot of stuff in here to talk about. And so, when I think about this from a high level, you know, it's certainly something that we have to have. But let's talk about it from a high level first. Like, what are— before we even get into the details behind it, like, what are folks' kind of perceptions of this? When you're thinking about this National Cybersecurity Strategy?

1:27Izar Tarandach So, I think that the first thing to realize is that it's a strategy. So, it's okay that it's short on details of implementation. With that, taking that into consideration, I'm very happy that the last page or so is a window into implementation, how they think that this is going to go in. So that's already a good sign, I think. Right. But, uh, all in all, I think that they, they say all the right things. It looks like it's very targeted at certain audiences. So like, China, are you listening? Uh, there are some things that outright made me a bit worried and even afraid sometimes. But there are many things that made me happy.

2:17Chris Romeo Okay. So Tanya, what are— what's your kind of high-level perceptions of this strategy?

2:25Tanya Ward Similar observations to Asar. I thought it was a— it was a well-thought-out document. It hits all the key points, you know, talks a lot about, you know, the ransomware attacks. It, you know, goes into kind of, you know, really investing in our infrastructure. It talks about, you know, how do we really— when you think about the things that we sell and the things that we put out there, we all work within security. And security is always— if you think security versus functionality, security sometimes is the one that's kind of deprioritized in, in some cases. And it's starting to draw light that you may not make monetary gains necessarily as a result of it, But, you know, they're now starting to think about regulations and how to really drive that as a key point. And that really excites me as well. I think this is absolutely where we need to be at this moment in time. And also acknowledge I was excited to see the implementation side of it at the end, 2 pages at the end of the 37-page document, because as you're reading through, there's a lot of words like efficient and scale. And naturally, when it's a strategy, I'm thinking, well, how do you— what is efficiency? What does that necessarily mean? Doesn't necessarily mean. So I'm excited to see how they explore that and take this concept and then actually start implementing out on it. But I— there was really no surprises.

3:47Chris Romeo Okay, Matt, how about you?

3:49Matt Coles Yeah, all in all, I think I agree with everything Nizar and Tanya have said. I like the fact also that it was laid out. It covered points about defensive, a lot of defensive posture stuff, but some offensive posture things as well. Partnership was mentioned a significant number of times throughout the document, and both within the federal government, obviously talking US federal government here, as well as between private and public sectors. So as a vision document, I think that that was good. I don't think this is the first time we've seen this though. So we'll see if in practice how this gets adopted. But I think in general, you know, this is different from the presidential executive order on cybersecurity, which seemed more of a mandate, you know, more of a, you know, not less of a strategy and more of an action document. And this looks more like a high-level, you know, policy reinforcement, I think is maybe the way I would say it, with some specific changes I'm sure we'll get into. Around how public-private partnerships and interactions work.

5:04Tanya Ward I want to just call out that that was another eye-opening, the amount of acronyms in the document for all these different partnerships. I think I've written it down. There's like the SRMA, there's like the DDFI, there's like, but it's just sheer, like the sheer scale feel of everyone having to come together is just phenomenal.

5:32Izar Tarandach So on the acronym thing, there are at least 20 different acronyms for agencies and parts of the government mentioned here. But with that, only twice the acronym SBOM appears. Yay! That's good.

5:50Chris Romeo That's good because some of us have strong opinions about SBOM. And so I'll probably end up being more of the pundit in this exercise today just because as I went through this and I read every word of it from top to bottom, there's a lot of good stuff in here. But the easy part is laying out the vision and the strategy. Like, you can write a vision and strategy all day long. It's when the rubber meets the road is where this gets interesting and where it gets challenging. And you start to think about the scale of the technology industry and everybody that's gonna have to get on board with this. And, you know, that's when I start to become a little more cynical, I guess, about this thing ever turning into anything. Like, yeah, I mean, I'm gonna agree with a lot of things they say. Do I think I'm gonna see it in the next 10 years? Well, we'll get there. We'll get there when we start to unpack it.

6:46Izar Tarandach The thing with writing a strategy and having a vision, I think one of the things is that you have to tread a very, uh, uh, thin line between the obvious that everybody knows and tomorrow's problems. So yeah, there's a lot of stuff that, uh, in here that me at least as I read, I go, uh-huh, uh-huh. Yeah, yeah. That'd be, uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh. But then you get to some lines that immediately take you to, but how?

7:16Tanya Ward Did you feel like it was prioritized? Like, I didn't really get a sense that, you know, when normally you think about strategy, you have this overall concept, but then maybe it goes to the how, but I still feel like some strategies could potentially be prioritized.

7:33Matt Coles Yeah, there was not a whole lot of prioritization. I don't— it didn't come across as prioritization. I think it sort of said, I mean, everything is important. Right. But it put, it laid it, I mean, it, for me, it laid it out. So I think as a, I love using the word defense in depth, right? It's a defense in depth approach. There's all these layers, these pillars are more like layers, right? It isn't just that they're, you know, pillars sometimes brings to mind silos, but I would look at, I read these as layers of defense or layers of action, Right? Because some are defense and some are offense.

8:12Chris Romeo I mean, sometimes if you don't, if all the pillars aren't there, you can't handle the weight of whatever's sitting on top of it though. And so—

8:22Matt Coles Well, that's maybe true. Well, that's why, maybe that's why people like to use the onion because you use domes, it's domes, right? So it's spheres that have to carry their own weight. But anyway, a little bit of geometry and physics going on there.

8:33Chris Romeo No, this is the physics hour.

8:35Izar Tarandach One thing that I didn't see there or I, I seem to remember a very thin mention of 10 years or something.

8:45Matt Coles Just a second.

8:47Izar Tarandach I didn't see any kind of, uh, time horizon for this thing to happen. So that's to me— oh no, it was looking back at over the last 10 years. That, that to me bothers me a bit because government, at least at the strategy levels, is comes and goes, right? It's 4-year units, sometimes 8, and this stuff is going to take time. This stuff— some of this stuff is time that we ourselves have been doing for tens of years, right? And without too much knowledge about how the, the U.S. government operates, I, I wonder to myself How much of this is binding at all? Does this now have to be translated into actual laws that bind the government to do something? And what happens with the next government? Is it still bound to this?

9:45Chris Romeo Some of it, some of it will be if, if they can pass legislation, like we're gonna get to this and I'm jumping way ahead, but there's this section on shift liability for insecure software products and services that has language that says, Congress will have to enact laws, blah, blah, blah, to make this a reality.

10:04Izar Tarandach So let, let, let's really, really shortly jump there.

10:08Chris Romeo Okay.

10:08Izar Tarandach So last September, if memory serves right, we had Mudge at Congress testifying about Twitter's AppSec failures, ProdSec failures, right?

10:20Tanya Ward Yep.

10:21Izar Tarandach And then we had Congress send a letter to the Twitter CEO Agarwal, asking him to produce documentation attesting to the fact that those things were right or wrong. And then poof, Elon came in, bought what, did what he did with Twitter, and all that stuff apparently disappeared. So to me, that sounds like Congress taking something into their hands and saying, this is really important and we are going to go to the bottom of this. Congress has a very, very limited short life.

10:56Chris Romeo Yeah.

10:56Izar Tarandach So how do, do I contrast that with the lofty goals in the strategy that depend on Congress?

11:04Chris Romeo Yeah, I think, I mean, I think a lot of this is not dependent on Congress though. It's dependent on other agencies.

11:09Tanya Ward Yeah.

11:09Chris Romeo I mean, other agencies are gonna have to run, you know, CISA for example, is gonna have to be at the center of a lot of these things.

11:16Izar Tarandach But you need, but you need law backing to be able to tell CISA is going to ask for something.

11:21Chris Romeo For some of them, others, others you don't like for, you know, you know, for implementing requirements for critical infrastructure. That's not gonna be a law.

11:31Matt Coles Sure.

11:31Izar Tarandach Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But what you were saying before, the shifting the, what was it? Responsibility or blame?

11:38Chris Romeo Liability. Liability.

11:39Izar Tarandach Liability. Yeah. Shifting the liability. That you actually need a law, right?

11:43Chris Romeo Yeah. And they called it out. They called out in that section that Congress will need to enact laws to make this a reality. And so, but with a lot of the other ones, I think it's in the power of presuming the individual parts of the government have budget, it becomes part of their charter and part of them executing and using their budget to meet these goals versus needing congressional backing to do it. So, but I think let's start going through it because I think we'll find some examples and we can start to— and start to pick away at those examples and understand, you know, then we can talk about is there congressional requirement, you know, do we need laws to make this a reality? Because some of these things, there's been laws talked about as well. But let's start with the introduction kind of sections before we get into the pillars because there was one that caught my attention and it was right on page 3, the section on malicious actors. As a security professional, I'd like, you know, I've certainly thought about malicious actors and the challenges of nation-state, but this really focused in and I thought it was really interesting was very well written, talking about, you know, China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and then going into details about what some of the challenges have been in how they've come after us in the past as the United States of America. And then it was, there was just a depth to this section that for me, it was just a, it was, it was educational. And I felt like I already knew quite a bit about this section, but it, it just, it was helpful for me to get the perspective of the government right now about what they're seeing from these particular areas. So, um, it was actually very refreshing.

13:22Matt Coles I think it was very refreshing too, because, because while this document is probably targeted at, uh, big corporations and obviously the federal government, and, you know, because a number of organizations are going to need to look at this and understand what's coming, you know, what's going to be expected of them, how they may organize, but also the, the folks like us, the security professionals who are then it's gonna trickle down to eventually, or I, I don't know that the general populace would be, would be interested in something like this, but certainly there are folks out in the population who are not security professionals who will look at this. And it's good to see sort of peeling back the layers a little bit here about what, what are some of the challenges we're facing as if we didn't know, but It's always good to reinforce that, that there are very specific actors who are doing, doing things that we need to be aware of and try to avoid getting harmed by.

14:19Tanya Ward I always think it's good to have these types of opening. It's a level set. It's a kind of a rechecking and a reality check of what's happening in the world. You know, technology is changing functionality that it kind of goes back to initially like We still have a lot of old function, like a lot of old systems out there. The switch then from analog to digital, like it's just this whole ecosystem that we're working in. Like my mom may not understand about the digital ecosystem, but she certainly understands, like if she's teaching in some of the new, new ways that she has to, she had to teach during COVID like she gets, she gets that kind of concept. And, um, I don't know. I just, I thought it was, um, it was a good reality check and something that everybody can understand.

15:04Izar Tarandach To me, I think that's to, to, to both your points. In that bit, the, the, the one sentence that caught my attention was, okay, China, North Korea, Iran, bad people do bad stuff. Fine. Actually, people do bad stuff. Because for them, they're not bad people. They have their interests. And nations operate on interests. They're not good or bad.

15:26Matt Coles And, but also we should be cognizant of there are not, it's not necessarily the entire populace of those.

15:30Tanya Ward Of course. Yeah.

15:31Matt Coles Yeah.

15:31Chris Romeo Right.

15:32Tanya Ward Yeah.

15:32Izar Tarandach But the, the, the, the, the line that, that caught my attention in there was the cyber operations of criminal syndicates now represent a threat to the national security, public safety, and economic prosperity of the United States and its allies and partners. So not only it elevates criminal syndicates to a national security problem, which opens up a whole lot set of tools that can be used against them now. But it also includes allies and partners. So NATO and all that good stuff.

16:01Tanya Ward United Nations and yeah.

16:02Izar Tarandach Comes, comes under that, that umbrella. And when you start at the end, it says, um, criminal syndicates often operate out of states that do not cooperate with US law enforcement and frequently encourage, harbor, and tolerate such activities. So now you are bringing to the public eye the fact that, yeah, it's a criminal enterprise, but it could well be a government standing behind it. Like, we, we know that North Korea has all kinds of criminal enterprises that they deal with, uh, drugs and, and smuggling and whatnot. But now elevating that to cyber and putting that on national strategy and saying, hey, yeah, you're a criminal. We ordinarily would say that the local police has to deal with you, but Actually, no, you are a government. So now it becomes a bit higher level than that.

16:52Chris Romeo Yeah.

16:52Izar Tarandach I think that's, that, that's pretty important to put out there.

16:54Tanya Ward Yeah.

16:54Chris Romeo No, I agree. I think that is, that is pretty important. Um, I'm gonna, I'm gonna, I'm gonna just add another perspective here that I think it's, I think it's important for us to acknowledge this, and this may not be popular, but I don't care. I'm gonna say it anyway. The United States government, we do, does, does cyber operations as well. Not cybercrime. I don't, I don't think our government government is proliferating cybercrime by any stretch of the imagination, but it's important to acknowledge like this is our— and I live in the United States of America, I'm a citizen here. This is our governmental perspective looking outbound, but don't lose focus on the fact that we perform cyber operations against other nations and whatnot. The United States is not sitting here in a bubble, not participating in cyber capabilities and cyber types of things as well. So I think it's important to, especially if we have people who are listening to this that maybe are not as plugged in as we are, just important to realize that the United States government does operations as well.

18:01Izar Tarandach That's a very important point to put out there. But without going into the good guys, bad guys, I think that the text by itself makes a very clear distinction that we are talking about the kind of cyber operations that can be understood as a criminal activity.

18:20Chris Romeo Okay, good point.

18:20Izar Tarandach So the actors that have been, apart from China, the actors that have been named in here, Iran, North Korea, they're under a lot of scrutiny and a lot of limitations in what they can do with their money in the international market and all that stuff. And these criminal enterprises, sometimes they are a lifeline in terms of moving money around or getting resources or getting money. Like we are not just talking about cyber espionage, industrial espionage or anything like that, right? But we are actually talking about dollars coming in. So specifying that moves the criminal operation at the volumes that we see nowadays, which are not small. Moving to a strategic level, which is pretty important.

19:08Matt Coles Now, would you not—

19:10Izar Tarandach but wouldn't you—

19:10Matt Coles I mean, not to touch upon that, spend a lot of time here, but there are other criminal enterprises that operate at nation-state levels that are not nation-state-backed.

19:20Tanya Ward Exactly. Yeah, right.

19:21Matt Coles Cartels and, uh, you know, in—

19:24Izar Tarandach but that's the distinction. Cartels and stuff like that, mostly, and to the best of my knowledge, and I could be very wrong here. The US manages to have some kind of cooperation with local law enforcement agencies at some level to have an oversight to do local operations against these people with the participation of the United States, of course, but locally led. The actors that are named in here, you're not going to see Iran inviting the FBI in any time to do investigations into Iran.

19:57Chris Romeo It's true. Yeah.

19:59Izar Tarandach Okay.

20:00Chris Romeo I think it was a good distinction though, just to— just— and I'm glad you pointed us back to that. The document is focused on criminal syndicates, like cyber operations of criminal syndicates in regards to these other countries and whatnot. Anybody else have anything in the introduction before we get to Pillar 1? What else? Anything in the introduction you wanted to talk about?

20:21Matt Coles I want to highlight. So on page 4, So on page 4, and this is actually, this really goes to, I mean, I think what we're gonna talk a lot about, you brought it up, you know, shift of liability. But I read a little bit more into this. And so the statement here is, "A single person's momentary lapse in judgment, use of an outdated password, or errant click of a suspicious link." And I would even suggest maybe not even a suspicious link in some cases. Should not have national security consequences. Our collective cyber resilience cannot rely on the constant vigilance of our smallest organizations and individual citizens. Now, it's important. It, it didn't say, it didn't say exclusively, right? So, so we still need citizens to be, to be diligent, right? But, but the, the message here is it's not just their problem. And I, you know, the first half of that sentence is if a single individual has a level of control or a level of capability that can, you know, result in damage of critical infrastructure or otherwise cause, you know, leak of secrets or whatever at the national security level, then obviously we need to solve that problem. Um, but I'm a little, a little perplexed actually about what are the bounds of this, of this conversation in its entirety, right? What is the US boundary in, with respect to national security? Is it critical infrastructure within our borders? And I bring that up because obviously, you know, we work with multinational corporations, right, that have locations all over the world and employees, you know, that are connected to those corporations. What's the extent of this policy document or this strategy? What constitutes the extent of national— what constitutes the extent of national security and what consequences would we foresee here?

22:26Tanya Ward Are you talking about scope, like the scope of the industries?

22:31Matt Coles Scope of the industries, but also the policy direction here.

22:35Chris Romeo Well, the document covers like improvements to the internet as a whole, which you could argue, I guess you could argue the internet's critical infrastructure at this point of our existence as a society or a collection of societies. But yeah, I think it's probably bigger than just critical infrastructure.

22:54Tanya Ward It also talks about throughout the document somewhere around the, about protecting being stewards of personal data and making sure that we, well, companies who handle personal data, is responsible for protecting it as well. Yeah, that's true.

23:14Chris Romeo That was a good point.

23:15Tanya Ward So, I think it's much broader. I think it's a private and public sector.

23:19Chris Romeo Yeah, yeah, absolutely.

23:21Izar Tarandach In that same scope, I read the same sentence that Matt called out in a different way. To me it looks like, especially because of the title of the section, Rebalance the Responsibility to Defend Cyberspace.

23:33Tanya Ward Mm-hmm.

23:34Izar Tarandach I see it as a preamble to coming and saying everything is too free, everything is too accessible because people will have these momentary lapses in judgment. That, that's just human nature. I, I find—

23:46Chris Romeo Yeah, but isn't this, isn't this what we want though? Like when I was thinking about this, I'm glad Matt drew attention to this cuz I remember reading it and I didn't note it. But as a security professional, I want systems, I want to build products and systems in such a way that I can take away the challenge that the individual, perhaps uneducated user has. And I'll give you an example with phishing. Think about how phishing has evolved now to the fact that you shouldn't have a report phishing button anymore because you've got technology that is, that is so good on the server side that's preventing. And that's— and it's not perfect, but it's— you think about the number of phishing emails you get today versus the number we got 10 years ago. And 10 years ago, every morning you would have a few in your inbox to sift through and look at and go, "That's not it." I think about how often does a phishing email get to my inbox these days? Not very often. And it's because the products and systems and technology behind that problem have gotten to the point where they're insulating me as a user, but they're also insulating somebody who doesn't do cybersecurity for a living. So isn't that what we want?

24:57Izar Tarandach But Chris, that's what you want as the draconian monocle-wearing security professional.

25:03Chris Romeo Well, let me get my monocle. Hold on. Where's my monocle? Where is it?

25:06Izar Tarandach The rest of the world, the rest of the world, you just get like, yeah, there we go. The rest of the world, they want information to be free, right? They want everything to be everywhere. They want everything to be accessible. We want people to move between environments easy and free. So that's exactly what I saw here in, in, in this few paragraphs. I saw a call out for the industry to start reining back those things and saying, no, not everybody should be able to fire nuclear missiles whenever they feel like. We need at least two people turning the keys at the same time, right? And that's in time is going to generate some form of backlash. And now there's a strategy to come back and say, ah, remember when we talked about that stuff here?

25:51Tanya Ward Mm-hmm.

25:52Chris Romeo So you think this is the precursor to Big Brother, to 1984?

25:55Izar Tarandach No, no, no, no. I'm not going that, that far. I think that this is the precursor to be able to tell, for example, uh, uh, somebody in the supply chain of, uh, the, the defense industry, somebody that, that, I don't know, they create parts for a, a fighter jet or something. It's a precursor to telling them, uh, we have to take a look at the list of people that work for you and we are going to have a say if, uh, new candidates can work with you or not.

26:21Chris Romeo I mean, they do that now though. That exists. That's called the security clearance process.

26:25Izar Tarandach And down to which level?

26:27Chris Romeo I mean, yeah. I mean, you, but that's, I mean, you have to vet people that work in critical, but, but that goes into diversification.

26:33Izar Tarandach It doesn't go into the fact that sometimes the guy milling the machine. Perhaps he doesn't, uh, milling the part. He doesn't know all the details of the part, but he has the ability of measuring that part and moving those measurements around. But he didn't get to vet it because he just operates the machine that makes the, the part.

26:53Chris Romeo I think they vet those, those folks get vetted.

26:55Izar Tarandach Yeah, at some point it stops because it stops being, uh, economically viable. It takes a lot of money to vet someone.

27:04Chris Romeo I would wanna fact-check that a little deeper 'cause I, in my understanding and experience about, in about that world is that people are very well vetted. And the reason why an airplane, a fighter jet costs what it does isn't because the metal, isn't because it's made out of alloys that are, you know, found in some planet on the other side of the galaxy. It's because you've got all that process and regulation and everything that goes into building that thing. It's not like— because there's a lot of bloat in there, but anyway, that's a whole other issue. That's a whole other issue.

27:36Tanya Ward I was curious, kind of jumping on to what you said, Matt, the part that really got me interested in that section that you were talking about was together, partnership together. I love that word together. Together, industry and government must drive effective and equitable collaboration. And I think this is the summary of everything that we're trying to do. Correct market failures because obviously if the, you know, if there's a loss of financial, you know, it has a direct impact on the economy. Then, you know, harms, minimize harms from cyber, you know, incidents to society. So when I think about, I mean, you think about malware attacks in hospitals, I mean, who's attacking? I mean, that to me, attacking those systems and trying to bring things down, just, I mean, It's almost like a human, it's a human rights issue here. And then the other one was defend our shared digital ecosystem, which is like protecting my data, like protecting, you know, the information that may be about me within that ecosystem. So I'm curious to know from you, when we talk about that together partnership, what does that really mean? Does that mean regulation? Does it mean we work together on things? Do we establish standards that are out there? Because maybe both, you know, that are out there, but a lot of different things. And then I'm thinking there's so many standards, there's so many different frameworks coming out. But anyway, I would love to hear your thoughts on that.

29:02Izar Tarandach To me, it means—

29:04Matt Coles go ahead, Isar.

29:06Izar Tarandach Absolutely nothing. Okay. I file it under the duh category. Like, yeah, everybody has to work together, of course. Otherwise, nothing is going to ever get done. On the other hand, when have we ever worked together? We love to say that we work together. What?

29:25Tanya Ward We don't work together.

29:26Izar Tarandach Government and private, uh, I, I mean, sure, when the money is good, but at some point, again, those interests start diverging, and that's when you get friction, and that's when you get slowed down, and Yeah, we are working together. We're just not getting anywhere for the work.

29:48Chris Romeo But I mean, industry's not going to work together for unless there's some benefit.

29:54Tanya Ward Exactly. Yeah.

29:55Chris Romeo Right. Because this is free market economy. This is like my, I don't do things in a company. Sometimes I do things for the greater good perhaps, but in general I do things because one, there's a regulation or some mandate that says I have to. Soc 2. I'm sorry, I had something in my throat there. Sorry, I'm sorry. I'm back. I'm back now. But I mean, like, that's— so when I think about together, you know, these words together, industry and governments drive effective, it does seem like kind of high-level perspective. Like, I don't think industry is in general going to stand up and say, we're going to do everything in this. There's gonna have to be some pushing that's happening to make this a reality.

30:42Izar Tarandach Which is where the law discussion comes in, right? Unless you put some sort of very big stick behind this thing, there isn't enough carrots.

30:50Matt Coles Well, you know, so—

30:51Izar Tarandach Especially when your interests diverge.

30:53Matt Coles Some organizations, some organizations, companies, et cetera, will look at this as an opportunity. There's obviously gaps that need to be filled, right? And they may want to, we see this with standards all the time. Companies will drive standards in a certain way. Not only do they have the vision and the capabilities to be able to solve a problem and to innovate in a certain way, but obviously they want to be able to play in that environment that gets created. And so it really, I mean, we've been doing this for decades, right? I mean, DARPA is not strictly a public organization. Public sector organization. You know, there's partnerships with NIST and MITRE and others all over the place. And so, you know, this is not a new concept. So I think this is more of a reinvigoration of that sort of a— the tail end of this section, I think, is— you're right, Tanya— is really highlighting partnership, partnership, partnership, and that it's all get-together.

31:58Izar Tarandach Yeah.

31:59Matt Coles I sense it as a re-up of the desire of the federal government to work with organizations. But I want to bring us back to the very beginning of that section. And the very, the second statement, I think highlights it here, right? Today, end users bear too great a burden for mitigating cyber risks. This is a clear call to action that whatever mitigations we thought were in place or whatever mitigations we provided to customers or to users to safeguard themselves. The US government is suggesting that we need to build it, build that stuff in. And I think we've— sorry.

32:42Tanya Ward Go ahead. Sorry, Matt.

32:43Matt Coles I was just going to add, this is, I think, where— I mean, it's in the section title. It's mentioned as in both bold text and just prior to that, two fundamental shifts in how the United States allocate roles, responsibilities, and resources in cyberspace, right? This is a plan of action to push, and this is back to the liability question, right? Push more action on the part of vendors and suppliers and corporations to do right by their customers and not have the, and by those customers being federal government in many cases. As opposed to the government taking on those actions itself.

33:29Chris Romeo But if you raise the bar, you know, like when I think about what you just said, one, you can achieve that with companies with regulation. You can also achieve it by raising the bar across the industry. And so, by raising the bar across the industry, I think companies do care about their customers' data at this point. Like, I wouldn't have said that I think I'd say that 5 years ago. I probably wouldn't say it 10 years ago, just looking across my experience in the industry. I don't think anybody doesn't care about their customer data at this point. I think that the bar could be raised though as a way to lead them into this.

34:06Tanya Ward I think if you can move on to the next strategic objective, 1.1, it does call out that the marketplace insufficiently rewards, which was the initial point that I had brought up. Before, and often disadvantages the owners and operators of critical infrastructure. I would say it's more than critical infrastructure. You know, we're honed in on it. But going back to the point of the 3 different kind of areas that they're targeting, who actually invest in proactive measures to prevent or mitigate the effects of cyber incidents. So it's not just what you were saying. It's not about that users don't necessarily or they're not aware about how to protect themselves. I think it's a case of, you know, people are making, or, you know, companies are making decisions when they put out products to try to maybe capitalize on putting more features in versus really thinking about how to protect, you know, when the product gets deployed or whatever, an application gets deployed that actually it's got all the, you know, as you said, the defense in depth and all the appropriate controls in place to prevent it. So it's a bit confusing between the company— there's all a company aspect to it and what you build, but there's also end user, I think, as well.

35:26Matt Coles Isar, you're looking confused, perplexed, concerned, frustrated.

35:31Tanya Ward He's coming up with a word of the day.

35:32Izar Tarandach I can feel it. Well, the word of the day— security.

35:37Matt Coles He asked ChatGPT and he was trying—

35:40Izar Tarandach he was waiting for the answer to Yeah, no, I was going back here trying to look for the place where, where, uh, Daniel was. And but, but one thing that keeps coming back to me is what Chris said about being in the industry for the greater good. And I keep thinking to how many private initiatives actually work for their good. And going back to the incentives thing and some of what Tanya alluded to, how do we push companies to work together and then match with the standards? And that got me to— sorry, page 23, where the strategy addresses, for example, DNS and BGP and IPv6. And they call it a cleanup, which to me is a nice kick on the back of, uh, academia, because we know that, uh, IPv4 and DNS as it was, and BGP started down there. And but hey, DARPA had a say on it too. But, uh, the, the point is that these are standards and they are the backbones of what we do and use today. So how, how would government and private initiative work together to fix just these three things? Actually, let's take just one. Let's say BGP. Okay, no, sorry, I don't know how much you guys are familiar with BGP. Let's go with DNS. So the—

37:18Matt Coles DNS is an IETF protocol, right?

37:24Tanya Ward Yeah.

37:24Izar Tarandach So the strategy says that the way that government is going to do this is by promoting that they are going to use better standards. Now, how much— how does that fit with the working together, Tanya? And what kind of incentives are we giving to industry to work globally better because the US government is improving itself? You see where I'm going with this? Like, there is a dance in here between government and industry.

37:55Tanya Ward That's kind of like when I was reading, there was— I kind of felt similar to you in terms of different sections that I was reading. I was— it was a bit unclear, you know?

38:06Izar Tarandach It's not that it's unclear. I see here sort of like there's a strange tug of war in here where both parties are apparently on the same side.

38:17Chris Romeo Yeah. But when you think about this, like the US government doesn't control IETF. The US government doesn't control the internet. It doesn't control anything. The internet is governed by the IETF, which generates standards, which then has generated more secure alternatives to DNS, for example, right? Like there is a secure There is a way to embed cryptographic signatures.

38:46Matt Coles DNSSEC.

38:46Chris Romeo DNSSEC. DNSSEC. For some reason, I couldn't— I can't believe I couldn't put those two things together.

38:50Izar Tarandach But what the strategy is saying, and you are pointing to, is there are better standards and our way to push them forward together with private initiative is for the US government to adopt them faster.

39:03Tanya Ward Yeah.

39:04Chris Romeo I don't think there's anything else that the US government can do though. Right? Because the internet, the US government, it doesn't own the internet. The US government can't deprecate, you know, DNS, older RFCs in regards to DNS because it doesn't have the power to do it.

39:20Izar Tarandach That, that's not what I'm asking them to do. I'm asking what impact, if at all, the US government saying we are going to adopt this secure technologies faster is going to have on the private side. There are no incentives. There are no penalties.

39:37Chris Romeo Yeah.

39:38Izar Tarandach How many companies have you heard, oh, we're going to go to IPv6 because the US government just did?

39:44Chris Romeo Yeah. No, it's a good point. I mean—

39:48Tanya Ward Sorry, you just— so I understand, you're saying that if the government— your point is if the government leads by example, everybody else will follow suit. No. And so you're saying that that's the— We're assuming that that's obviously incorrect, but it's called out in the document.

40:07Izar Tarandach No, that's not what I'm saying. Look, they say, such a cleanup, quotes, their quotes, efforts to reduce systemic risk requires identification of the most pressing of these security challenges, further development of effective security measures, and close collaboration between public and private sectors to reduce our risk exposure. Without disrupting the platforms and services built atop this infrastructure. Okay, the federal government will lead by ensuring that its networks have implemented these and other security measures while partnering with stakeholders, whoever that is, to develop and drive adoption of solutions that will improve blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. So they will lead by adopting standards that, as Chris points out, already exist that have not been globally adopted because PKI is hard. So it's great that you called out BGP and DNS, two things that make people really lose sleep and rightly at night. But then you kick the ball to a tomorrow problem by saying, hey, we're going to do the right thing, you guys do whatever you want.

41:18Matt Coles Well, so, so let's just be— this goes back to the scope question I think I asked earlier. Right? So it's sort of this document plays in a number of different areas. And I think that's the important thing here. So the US government has options when it comes to critical infrastructure, right? We probably need a history lesson about how the internet, what the internet is and how it actually formed, right? It is not a thing of and of itself. It is a collection of networks. Those collection networks are run by organizations and governments that manage the connectivity between systems. And it's always an option for any government to be able to create a closed network, right? They don't have to be on the public internet, right? Why does Facebook and the air defense systems for the US need to be on the same network?

42:17Tanya Ward Right?

42:18Matt Coles So we should be careful here. Maybe this is adding some credence or some weight, federal direction to federal agencies to say, listen, do we really need to have the internet as our backbone? Now, I'm not saying that they're just going to turn off connectivity. Either they can't or they shouldn't, but they have options, right? They could go ahead and implement DNSSEC or IPv6 or IPv10 or whatever they want to do, right? All advanced research stuff. And they call out RD&D, which is research, development, and demonstration. So not just building, not just designing new things, but designing new things that work. And they can demonstrate it works and they provide value. They give them the capabilities they want. And either they can do it by themselves, or they can do it with others who have technical expertise and make this a true partnership because Facebook can benefit from IPv10 just as well as the US government can.

43:20Tanya Ward But I would add in that it's a lead by example because if you start, if a government says, well, we're going to start adopting these, as you coined it, Isar, these protocols have already, these more secure protocols have existed for a period of time, then people that are buying into that space, the federal space, are going to start to have to support it. And then what will happen is there's this cascading effect that, you know, so I do think in time that it will drive— you're looking like surprised. I mean, if— let me put it into like, if I say, hey, you know, Chris, when you come over to my house, I want to make sure you do this, this, and this. You know, at some point that becomes, you know, a behavior, a characteristic will change that will end up happening in other areas.

44:10Izar Tarandach I'm just going to ask again, when was the last time that you saw anybody do any kind of systemic change just because the US government led by example?

44:22Tanya Ward Do you not think SBOM potentially? Do you not think that's changing the industry?

44:27Matt Coles We had that episode.

44:28Izar Tarandach It's changing one industry. It's creating an SBOM industry. That's a good point.

44:34Tanya Ward It's almost like you, you have like, you know, you're expecting that things are just gonna happen overnight and it, it's going, it takes time. Change takes time.

44:42Chris Romeo Yeah. And I think to Tanya, I think, I think what Tanya's saying is like, I, I think there, it does, it's not gonna hurt anything for the US government to, to, to try to, to, because, but if you think about it, like the, all, if, if all of the, the federal agencies fall into this and start following these practices, the defense industrial complex or the Lockheed Martins and, and whatnot of the world will do that because they follow the government.

45:08Izar Tarandach Uh, and so there's a chance there could be, they'll do it because they have to, to be, to, to be inter-operational.

45:14Chris Romeo Not because they're, but that could, that could drag more of industry into it though over time. Unfortunately, we're outta time for this episode. We're right in the, we're right in the middle of it, right in the, the, the thick of it here. But we, we made it We haven't even gotten to pillar 1 yet, and there's 5 pillars. We're still in the intro, but what I'm going to do is we're going to put a bookmark right here in this conversation, and we'll pick this up in our next episode. And then I swear we'll get to pillar— we'll at least get to pillar 1. We will cover pillar 1 in the next hour of the Security Table, most definitely, and hopefully a little bit more.

45:46Izar Tarandach But we'll lead by example and get to pillar 1.

45:48Chris Romeo That's right. Come on, pillar 1. But folks, thanks.

45:51Tanya Ward Follow.

45:51Izar Tarandach Then everybody has to follow.

45:52Chris Romeo Everybody will get— so folks, Thanks for tuning in, and we'll, we'll see you in the next episode of Security Table where we'll continue this conversation of the National Cybersecurity Strategy that's come out here in the United States. Thanks for listening.

Transcript supplied by AssemblyAI. It may contain transcription errors.

Originally published as The Security Table. Part of the AI Security Table archive.